In the latest battle in his war against proselytizing in the ranks of America’s military, Air Force veteran and church-state separation activist Mikey Weinstein is taking aim at the Reserve Officers’ Training Corps.
Weinstein, who sued the Air Force in 2005 for religious coercion, is calling attention to a passage in the Junior ROTC’s curriculum that questions the legitimacy of the separation between church and state. Researchers at Weinstein’s Military Religious Freedom Foundation, a not-for-profit group he founded to protect First Amendment rights in the military, discovered the passage in an educational guide distributed by the Defense Department to the military’s high-school leadership training program.
Weinstein, who represents the second generation of his family to graduate from the Air Force Academy, sees this newest revelation as but one example of evangelical Christianity’s creeping encroachment in all branches of the armed forces. The 52-year-old attorney from New Mexico has made it his mission — in an almost evangelical sense — to beat back what he sees as a campaign to Christianize the military.
In October 2005, Weinstein fired his opening salvo when he sued the Air Force. That suit came after his son Curtis, a cadet at the academy, told Weinstein that he had been subjected to antisemitic harassment, and evidence indicating a pattern of proselytizing emerged. The case was dismissed last year by a federal district court judge on legal technicalities, but Weinstein, a lifelong Republican, is eager to file a bevy of new lawsuits. Among the possibilities, Weinstein said, is a court case against the Junior ROTC.
“This is the 13th stroke of a crazy clock,” Weinstein said. Referring to the JROTC’s textbook, he added: “It’s not just religious predation. This is an example of the metaphysical rape of our youth, the ones being prepped for the military in the Junior ROTC.”
Weinstein also said that, in recent weeks, a powerhouse Washington law firm, WilmerHale, finished formulating a far-reaching litigation strategy for his foundation.
The Junior ROTC textbook chapter, titled “You the People — The Citizen Action Group Process,” recommends that cadets read an excerpt from an article that makes the argument that Thomas Jefferson’s 1802 letter to the Danbury Baptists — often cited as the basis for the separation between government and religion — was solely intended to keep the state from meddling in the church, and not the other way around.
“In summary, the ‘separation’ phrase so frequently invoked today was rarely mentioned by any of the Founders; and even Jefferson’s explanation of his phrase is diametrically opposed to the manner in which courts apply it today,” the textbook reads.
A Junior ROTC spokesman did not return a call seeking comment.
This is the type of discovery that keeps Weinstein, a former Reagan White House lawyer who worked on the Iran-Contra defense, plugging away. A one-time boxer, Weinstein has the pugnacious constitution of a pit bull. And with his compact, stocky build and dour grimace, he even bears a slight resemblance to one.
Weinstein’s fiery rhetoric — one of his most oft-repeated phrases is, “My job is to lay down a withering field of fire, take no prisoners and leave sucking chest wounds” — and in-your-face tactics haven’t always won him friends in the organized Jewish community. And he isn’t shy about naming those organizations that, he said, have lost their “fighting spirit.”
According to Weinstein, Jewish leaders such as the Anti-Defamation League’s Abraham Foxman and the American Jewish Committee’s David Harris do American Jews no favors by not speaking out more on the issue of evangelicals proselytizing in the military. Neither Foxman nor Harris returned calls from the Forward seeking comment.
Marc Stern, who frequently handles constitutional church-state issues as general counsel of the American Jewish Congress, described Weinstein as a “mixed bag.”
“I thought he was unduly confrontational about the Air Force guidelines, and I think that comes from years of improper activity going on uncorrected,” Stern said. “But,” he added, “I don’t find it a particularly useful way of dealing with government officials.”
Still, Stern notes, “Almost no cause is advanced without somebody who is not meshugene about the cause and prepared to do battle.”
Stern also pointed to Weinstein’s unflappable military credentials as the reason that veterans and armed forces personnel turn to him for help and not to the major Jewish groups.
On any given day, the peripatetic activist fields up to 250 calls from military troops, as well as from members of the media. Weinstein also receives a steady stream of death threats — on average, three to four a week.
Those threats increased markedly in late April, Weinstein said, during the lead-up to a debate at the Air Force Academy in which he and Jay Sekulow, a messianic Jew who serves as chief counsel of the conservative American Center for Law and Justice, argued the proper bounds of religion in the military. Weinstein also expressed concern that those threats would increase when Curtis, the last of his sons to graduate from the Academy, receives his diploma May 30.
The Air Force Academy debate not withstanding, Weinstein’s public appearances are most often funding appeals for his nascent foundation. He is in the midst of a national tour of sorts, hitting some synagogue groups, but mostly invite-only gatherings at private homes, to get out his message. Weinstein said that he hopes to raise $1 million a year to support his work. So far, he said, the fundraising effort, which he puts “in the six figures,” has been buoyed by joint appearances with foundation trustee Ambassador Joseph Wilson, who famously accused the Bush administration of outing his wife as a covert CIA agent.
At his appearances, Weinstein is also hawking his 2006 book, “With God on Our Side: One Man’s War Against an Evangelical Coup in America’s Military.” That tome will soon be outdated by a sequel, tentatively titled “Taking God to Court.”
Even when Weinstein is signing books, his fierce commitment to America’s armed forces is apparent. In a nod to his military roots, Weinstein wears his class ring from the Air Force Academy, where he and his wife, Bonnie, were married in the school chapel’s only Jewish wedding. The ring, with a prominent aqua-marine stone set in the center, is inscribed with two words: “Never Again.”
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.
Copyright © 2013, Forward Association, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Reconsider Decision on Rabbis and Intermarriage
Is Steven Hawking’s Decision To Boycott Israel a Boon to BDS?
Alas, Poor GOP: 3 D.C. Scandals That Weren't
Forced Out by Nazis, Grandmother Returns With Family to Germany
Mother of Jewish Teen Killed on Brooklyn Bridge Speaks Out
You've successfully signed up!
I agree with Weinstein. The leading Jewish Organizations such as the ADL and AJC have become far too willing to suck up to the powers that be. There are times when one has to say, "enough", and Weinstein had done that. Kudos to Mikey.
I have to agree with the goals of Mr. Weinstein. I don't know if I would support all of his tactics towards arriving at those goals. Because of the way the military is structured and its purpose, it is absolutely necessary for the military to be 'religously' and 'politically' blind. If you are in the military, your religion & politics are private and should be kept there. It is one of the things a person gives up when joining the military. I need to say that my father is Jewish (active in his synagogue) and a retired USAF officer. I myself am a born-again Christian (no I was not raised Jewish).
Thanks for the even-handed article on this contentious issue. It makes it abundantly clear that there remains work to do to educate our nation's military leadership on the need to value all faiths equally among the service members serving in our armed forces. Sadly,it is apparent that our own national leadership has turned its back on Jewish personnel serving our country in our armed forces. This is equally important to change. How can we expect the Department of Defense to take our concerns seriously when we can't get our leadership to do so?
I realize that Weinstein is pugnacious and, therefore, does not represent the cause in the most "Episcoplian" manner. Nevertheless, his point is well made. Some years ago, I was the NBC Officer for my reserve unit. My friend Paul W. was the range officer for our unit. Despite having a military chaplain in our unit, field exercises were scheduled more than 5 times on important Jewish holidays. We spoke with the chaplain; we pointed out that drills were not scheduled for Easter or Christmas holidays. His response was that since we were the only Jewish members of the unit, we needed to accomodate to the unit, not the other way 'round. Finally, Paul and I decided that we would no longer attend drill if it was scheduled on important holidays. And we informed the Commander (through our superiors) that both his NBC and range officers would not be available for field exercises if they conflicted with religious holidays. The Commander spoke with both of us personally and stated that since the yearly calendar was scheduled far in advance, it was our responsibility to inform the Commander if there were institutional issues which would prevent us from coming to drill and conducting required training. We explained that we had spoken with the Chaplain on numerous occasions and repeated the Chaplain's reply. We were dismissed. Nothing further was said about this incident; within 6 months the Chaplain was replaced with another individual. When introduced to the unit in formation, he indicated that he would like to meet with any unit members who had specific concerns about unit conduct and religious activities. For the remaining 10 years in that unit, exercises were never scheduled on holidays. It takes persistance. And we must remember, that some people will always act badly, but the majority want to do the right thing if they know what the right thing is.
Unfortunately for the likes of Mikey Weinstein, it is a fact that the sio-called 'separation of church and state'-- peddled in latter days largely by atheistic and agnostic lawyers-- is completely bogus as a version of what America's Christian or deist Founders desired. In the first instance, the constitutional amendment was framed only to prevent some states, former colonies, from establishing and privileging a particular denomination of Christianity as the one and only, and penalising inhabitants who preferred other churches. This has been seized on by activist fanatics such as Weinstein as a pretext for turning religious profession, observance and symbolism into dirty little secrets: their tiniest vestiges must make way in the public dsquare for the 1960s cult of 'diversity' and 'tolerance'. And now even an honest discussion of the historical dimension in a textbook is heretical! Weinstein and his fellow activists had better beware. It is the Southron evangelical Christian fans of the Armageddon scenario who are fighting Israel's battles these days, and there's only so much provocative riling from infidels that they can take.
The fact is that it isn't 1945 and there aren't 5-6 hundred thousand Jews in the military anymore. It's yet aother example of Jews making enemes out of evangelical Christians when there is more than enough others out there who would love to have us dead.
You go, Mikey! Once we get the military under Christian domination, it will be a short step from there to "Onward Christian Soldiers." The military will become the new vanguard for the Patriot Act...First target? Moderate (thoughtful; faithful) Evangelical Christians... Stan Moody, Ph.D www.christianpolicyinstitute.org 207/626-0594 Dr.Stan Moody, an evangelical Baptist minister and founder of the Christian Policy Institute, has served in the Maine House of Representatives as both a Republican and a Democrat. Dr. Moody is the author of several provocative books, including, "Crisis in Evangelical Scholarship" and "McChurched: 300 Million Served and Still Hungry." Pastor of a rural country church in Central Maine, Moody has enjoyed a long and productive career in small business development and management.
what is happening in the armed forces is only part of the plan of the religious right.i believe these organization want to proselytize all non-christians.