In 2008, the German city of Munich celebrated its 850th birthday amid much fanfare, and various cultural institutions were asked to mark the occasion. When the recently opened Jewish Museum was approached, it reacted with ambivalence. Indeed, for nearly half the history of Munich — more than 400 years — Jews were excluded from taking part in the life of the city.
This is where Bernhard Purin, the museum’s director, stepped in. Last September, the museum unveiled its contribution to the festival year, City Without Jews: The Dark Side of Munich’s History, a stark and effective exhibition about the various persecutions and expulsions that formed the bedrock of Munich’s history of antisemitism long before the Holocaust. The exhibit runs until the end of August.
Opened in May 2007, the Jewish Museum Munich is the youngest Jewish museum in Europe. The contrast to Jewish Museum Berlin — Germany’s most famous such museum — could hardly be more striking.
Where the Berlin museum attempts an exhaustive history of the Jewish experience in Germany, starting with the Middle Ages and leading up to the present day, the approach favored by Munich is to represent the history of Jews in that city via a compact and thoughtful permanent collection that combines interactive installations, artwork and a few well-chosen ritual objects and historical artifacts. A visitor can take in the exhibit in less than an hour, before making his way upstairs to view the changing exhibitions.
The same impulse for compression characterizes City Without Jews, which tells its story through a dozen small displays of representative objects and video interviews.
For instance, the pogrom of 1285, sparked by accusations of ritual murder, where between 68 and 187 members of Munich’s first Jewish community were locked inside their burning synagogue, is signified by a 19th-century edition of the Nuremberg Memorbuch, the 1296 commemoration of prominent community leaders and martyrs compiled by the Nuremberg Jewish community.
The 1349 accusation of host desecration — a common medieval accusation that the Jews abused the consecrated host in order to repeat the suffering of Christ — is represented through a 1624 painting, which was displayed for nearly 200 years in Munich’s St. Salvator Church. The old folklorist legend of the Wandering Jew inspired artists from Heinrich Heine to Richard Wagner before the Nazis twisted it to embody all the degenerative traits they ascribed to the Jews. This phantomlike figure that has, over time, emblemized the internal experience of Jews in the Diaspora is represented by a coat stand with an umbrella and an old edition of the newspaper Frankfurter Zeitung; it is a reference to a Lion Feuchtwanger story in which the Wandering Jew is spotted in Munich’s famous Odeon Café, reading a newspaper.
The Nazi persecution and mass murder are metonymically represented by an empty trunk with the initials of its last owner, Rosa Picard. A businesswoman from Munich, Picard filled the trunk with valuables and entrusted it to a Christian family before she and her family perished.
A counterpoint to this decidedly downbeat exhibition is the three-part series of temporary installations, Places of Exile.
“We wanted to answer the question:Where did the Jews of Munich live when they were not allowed to live in Munich? So we looked for three places of exile,” Purin explained.
After exhibits on Istanbul and Tel Aviv, the final installment, on display until August 30, looks at New York City’s Washington Heights, which became the center of Munich’s exiled Jewish community during World War II.
In particular, the exhibit focuses on Beth Hillel Synagogue, a Conservative congregation founded in 1940 by the chief rabbi of the Munich Jewish community, Leo Baerwald, who had fled Germany. The first services, held on Rosh Hashanah of that year in the Paramount Hall on 183rd Street, attracted 800 people.
Initially, services were held in German and followed the tradition of southern German Jews, known as Minhag Schwaben. German Jews were such a prominent minority, and so much German was spoken on the streets of Washington Heights in the 1940s and ’50s, that they ironically nicknamed the neighborhood “Das Vierte Reich” — or the Fourth Reich.
In the first decade, the congregation grew to 750 families from 200 and moved into a former post office at 571 West 182nd Street, just south of Yeshiva University. As members became more assimilated and prosperous, services were increasingly held in English. Throughout the 1960s and ’70s, the congregation was in steady decline caused by suburbanization and the new waves of immigrants from the Dominican Republic, which changed the demographic of the neighborhood.
In 1980, Beth Hillel merged with the Orthodox Congregation Beth Israel and, despite ever-shrinking numbers, managed to survive until 2000, when it finally closed its doors. Today, the building on 182nd Street is home to a department store.
Purin’s co-curator for the project is Celia J. Bergoffen, an urban archeologist who excavated the Eldridge Street Synagogue mikveh in 2001. Together with Purin, she conducted interviews with members of the community and tracked down pertinent artifacts.
“It was funny to see that they were very professional in talking about their childhood in Germany, because that’s what they are doing in schools and for the [Steven] Spielberg video project, but they never were asked about the other 80% of their lives, which started in 1939 or 1940, when they were teenagers in Washington Heights,” Purin explained.
Among the surviving congregants of Beth Hillel is Eric Bloch, a professor emeritus at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, who was born in Munich in 1928. In an interview with Bergoffen, he discusses the role that the congregation played in easing the transition to America: “I think the importance of Beth Hillel and the other Jewish congregations was to help immigrants establish themselves in the new country. They were a very important source of support.” The interview is published in the exhibition brochure, which can be ordered, free of charge, from the museum.
Among the items installed in the exhibition are two memorial stones from Munich’s destroyed main synagogue and a yellow Jewish star that wound up at a synagogue in Paramus, N.J. Another relic is the parochet (ark curtain) from Beth Hillel, which was found in 2002 at a Berlin flea market.
“It is in some ways a little bit funny that the history of this congregation in Washington Heights will now be kept in Munich,” Purin mused.
City Without Jews: The Dark Side of Munich’s History and Places of Exile 3: Munich and Washington Heights are on view at the Jewish Museum Munich until August 30.
A.J. Goldmann is a writer based in Berlin. His articles on art and culture have appeared in various publications, including The Wall Street Journal, USA Today and The Christian Science Monitor.
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.
Copyright © 2013, Forward Association, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Why Do Jews Intermarry at a Much Higher Rate Than Others?
The Mirror in the Mikveh
If Rabbis Are Allowed To Intermarry, Get Ready for the Non-Jewish Rabbi
Top 10 Badass Mah Jongg Jews
Auschwitz Museum 'May Not Reflect Real Facts' Says Hungarian Lawmaker
You've successfully signed up!
As a D.P. to the U.S. I learned my yiddishkeit from Rabbi Shlomo Kahn and Canter Schattenberg at Cong Beth Israel of Washington Heights. Without their influence and the influence of their very "Yekke" shul I think I would have been an assimilated Jew of parents who, due to the Nazi years, questioned the advisability of a strong Jewish identity. Rabbi Kahn took many young children and guided them to their Jewish roots and an appreciation of their history.
The article was very interesting but there is one error. Beth Israel and Beth Hillel closed their doors but did not disappear completely. It merged with the Mount Sinai Jewish Center on 187th Street and Bennett Avenue, where the memorial tablets of the old Shuls are still on display.
I was a first generation American who was born and raised in Washington Heights in a 5 story tenement on 179th Street and Broadway. My parent's were refugees from Germany in the 30's and met in New York City at the New World Club. I remember that my father had a subscription to the Aufbau. I went to P.S. 132, J.H.S 115 and then the Bronx High School of Science. I took the A train down to 145th Street and changed to the D train up to Jerome Avenue. My parent's were members of Congregation Beth Israel and my Jewish mentors were Rabbi Kahn and Cantor Shattenberg. They gave me my Jewish identity. I was in the boys choir. My father, who had to work on shabbos in a bakery in order to earn a living, came home in the evening and always asked me if I went to Synagogue. It motivated me to go since I didn't want to disapoint him. I left Washington Heights, at age 21 after I graduated from CCNY,in 1968, during the Vietnam war. I spent 20 years in the Air Force in three operational aircraft as a Navigator. I am very proud of my service and love my country, which I am happy to have been born in. I later started an Insurance business which I passed on to my number two son after 18 years. This is the story of a boy born of German Jewish parent's in Washington Heights.
I was uncomfortable with both the content and tone of this article.Most books dealing with that time period tell about the harrowing times in the camps and ghettos, but few exist that describe what immigration was like especially for older people. I arrived in N.Y. with my mother and brother in December of 1938. My father followed in March 1939. He had been arrested and taken to Dachau but released after 3 weeks because of my mother was able to secure visas to Switzerland for us. I was 12 years old when I arrived here. No, we did not settle in "The Fourth Reich" but in Williamsburg, Brooklyn.Being new immigrants at that time was a harrowing experience!Only my mother was able to find work such as cleaning apartments for people or sewing in factories.I did babysitting to help out. Two years after our arrival my father died suddenly from a massive brain hemmorhage; an autopsy revealed scar tissue ,and it was determined that he had been beaten on the head while at Dachau.That was the only thing he told my mother about when he returned from Dachau. At the time of his death he was 53, my mother 42 and I, at age 15 went to work to support the family. I also attended High School 5 nights a week. Looking back on that time period makes me wonder how I managed all of that. I am 83 years old now. I am the mother of four wonderful children, all adults now, and six grandchildren three of whom are now also adults. I went back to school at age 42 and earned a BA & MA and became a High School English Teacher. I am now retired but have been a Volunteer at THE MUSEUM OF JEWISH HERITAGE for seven years.I am hoping that my work there will make young people aware that what happened then will never happen again ! (Recent history tells us otherwise but we can not lose hope) TIkUN OLAM !
My brother (born 1937 in Vienna) and I (born 1943 at Wadsworth Hospital in Washington Heights) lived in Washington Heights off Pinehurst Avenue and 183 Street. My parents moved from Jersey City to Washington Heights in the early 1940's. They were part of a group of Viennese jews who were more assimilated than the more Orthodox German jews of the eastern part of Washington Heights (from Broadway to St. Nicholas Avenue). They maintained the Viennese traditions of walking through the park on week-ends. On any given Sunday, you could hear German spoken with a Viennese accent in Fort Tryon Park. In addition, they continued their tradition of attending concerts and operas. They associated mainly with other Viennese jews and mostly attended High Holliday services and did celebrate passover meals. Although they tried to maintain their Viennese lifestyle, they were reluctant to talk about their former life. I guess it was because my father lost his mother at Terezen and his sister was gassed at Auschwitz.
Roger Adler San Antonio, Texas
I recently moved to Washington Heights, where my grandmother, a Holocaust survivor from Frankfurt, lived when I was a child. I need to find a synagogue nearly, but I feel like Goldilocks with the porridge — no shul where I've attended services seems "just right." There are many Orthodox congregations and Reform one; they aren't right for me. I would like to find a Conservative shul to call my spiritual home — especially one with lots of adult educational programs, because my Hebrew is lousy.
I would appreciate any help/advice from residents of the neighborhood. Thank you and Happy New Year.
My parents and I immigrated to Washington Heights from England (after leaving Germany in 1939) and resided on 181st, as well as Ft. Washington Ave. and Bennett Ave. when I got married. We attended Beth Israel shul and our son Barry was Bar Mitzvahed there and was taught by Cantor Shatenberg and Rabbi Kahn. At home only German was spoken and all the traditional German way of life was kept. Saturday afternoons were spent with the family in Ft. Tryon Park. I moved fromthe Heights after my dear parents passed away, but still return to the beauty parlor and to Gruenebaums bakery for the German water Challas and Streusel Kuchen.