Our Troops Need Reform Rabbis
Opinion
By Benjamin Abramowitz
In 1916, at the age of 15 and just a decade after landing at Ellis Island, my father enlisted in the U.S. Army. He served with distinction for 35 years, retiring as a lieutenant colonel.
After graduating college, I, too, joined the service, taking a commission in the infantry. I served for 28 years, including two combat tours in Vietnam, and retired as a colonel.
My oldest son, Dave, a 1982 graduate of the Air Force Academy and an Army aviator, is now a colonel serving in Iraq. My two other sons served as commissioned officers in the Army Reserve and National Guard, and my grandson Jacob is a third-year cadet at West Point.
For three generations my family has served this country, and throughout it all we have had help from rabbis in keeping Jewish tradition a part of our lives, even when we were stationed away from an organized Jewish community. Rabbis were always available to meet our needs, including providing a Jewish education for our sons. Indeed, it was at a Seder conducted by Rabbi Judah Miller in a church basement outside of Fort Riley, Kan., that I met my future wife.
Unfortunately, I fear my grandson Jacob may not have as easy a time practicing his faith — and for this the Reform movement is much to blame.
According to the Jewish Welfare Board, today there are 29 rabbis on active duty in the armed services. Only six of them are in the Army, and none are Reform. Of the 26 rabbis in the other branches of the military, only three are Reform.
The lack of Reform rabbis serving in the military is not a new problem — it goes back some 40 years — but with an untold number of Jewish men and women deployed to Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere around the globe, it is high time the Reform movement honor its obligation to our troops.
The genesis of the problem dates back to the Vietnam War. Prior to Vietnam, the Orthodox, Conservative and Reform rabbinates each met one-third of the military’s requirement for Jewish chaplains. Back then, the Reform movement’s seminary, Hebrew Union College, would not ordain a rabbi if he — there were no female rabbis at the time — refused to serve. When the military requirement was not met by volunteers, physically fit members of the seminary’s graduating class drew lots.
Once the Vietnam War became unpopular, however, Hebrew Union College apparently removed the requirement to serve, and since that time the participation of Reform rabbis in the military has been minimal.
Many Orthodox rabbis do a first-class job as military chaplains, serving not only the Jews in their units but also personnel of other faiths. Some Orthodox rabbis, however, do not have the flexibility that is often needed in military units. Separating men and women at services or not going out into the field on the Sabbath are just two examples where some of the military’s more observant chaplains may not be able to meet the needs of those they are ministering to.
Reform rabbis are well positioned to accommodate the needs of these Jewish men and women — after all, most Jewish members of the military come from a Reform or secular background — but by all appearances the movement’s rabbinical leadership is not particularly interested in encouraging its colleagues to serve. Leaders of the Reform rabbinate recently turned down an offer from the Navy to spend two days aboard an aircraft carrier, where they would have had an opportunity to talk to Jewish sailors and observe how the military works.
The military, of course, is not for everyone. But it is important to remember that those rabbis who do elect to serve are not required to carry a weapon, walk point on a patrol, participate in an ambush or otherwise engage in violent actions.
I know that many Jews have a very negative view of the military and military service. I also know that this view is based on scant, biased knowledge of what is perceived to be a monolithic military culture in which antisemitism is institutionalized. Such stereotypes are belied by my nearly three decades’ worth of experience as an Army infantry officer, and ought to be put to rest once and for all.
Every day American Jews are heeding the call to serve, and they deserve to have rabbis who are trained and motivated to meet their special needs. It is long past time that the Reform rabbinate, too, heeds the call to serve.
Benjamin Abramowitz is a retired Army colonel.
Advertisements
Advertisements
As a (now retired) Air Force officer, I recall only one duty station (Wiesbaden, Germany) in my career (1962-1982) to which a Jewish chaplain (Reform) was assigned. For the rest of the time, I had no access to a rabbi except through joining a nearby Jewish synagogue (none of which reached out to military Jews, living on-base or off). At that time, the US Air Force had less than ten Jewish chaplains worldwide. We were a largely neglected lot to say the least, although I recall a visiting Army circuit-riding rabbi when I was in The Netherlands. In some measure, this lack of outreach led me away from Judaism into other spiritual practices for many years but I ultimately returned to the fold. Now I watch while the Jewish population plummets in terms of synagogue/temple affiliation, secular Judaism fast becoming the norm. From my perspective, at century's end, we will see only Orthodox Jews and secular Jews. Life is....
I am a retired Naval Aviator who seved 27 yrs. During that time there were two Reform Rabbis(both wartime and peacetime service who made a material difference in the Jewish life of my wife and me. The current lack of current chaplains(Reform certainly deprives servicemen & women of their talent and bolsters Jewish life. I am presently a member of Temple Rodef Shalom in Falls Church.VA which has membership of 1,400 families and is the largest Jewish congregation in Virginia. Contrary to the comments of David Cohen, we are growing & will certainly exceed the orthodox if all grow as rapidly.
Very interesting...I agree...has this been sent to HUC-JIR? Also, I am interested in your family's Ansbach synagogue history. I saw Gloria's article in the JWV publication. My late father was a WW2 Chaplain's Assistant turned Reform Rabbi...was at Ansbach, Yom Kippur 1945. Seeking more info. Thank you for your service, your thoughtful article, and your anticipated help.
I agree 100% with Col. Abramowitz. He is a wise man.
Still seeking to contact you regarding your family's Ansbach Synagogue history, as mentioned in Gloria's JWV article. Please contact me. Thank you.