No Easy Answers: Jewish college presidents, like David Leebron of Rice, say they are sometimes caught between their own strongly held beliefs and the requirement to nurture a culture of diversity.
As the debate about Israel rages on college campuses across America, there is one figure for whom the conversation takes on strikingly personal dimensions: the Jewish college president.
About 20 Jewish men and women hold the highest positions at universities across the country, including campuses that have become hotbeds of political activism on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. For these individuals, the role of president entails a constant balancing act between encouraging free speech on campus and honoring their personal, often supportive, views of Israel.
Click here to see map
In a series of interviews with the Forward, 10 current and former Jewish college presidents held forth on what the University of California’s Mark Yudof described as the “schizophrenia” of the Jewish college president — the moments when one’s Jewish identity bumps up against the interests of the institution. For many college presidents, the movement to boycott, divest from and implement sanctions against Israel — commonly known as BDS — represented a red line: Presidents who were previously disinclined to speak out against anti-Israel activity on campus in the name of preserving open dialogue found themselves publicly opposing the movement.
But going public on Israel had its limits. Several presidents voiced exasperation with the Jewish community’s scrutiny of campus events, preferring to mediate the Israel-Palestine debate internally. Still others described their efforts to extinguish sparks before they flared into small fires, by coaching Jewish and Muslim students in civil dialogue.
Yudof, who has run the 10-college U.C. system since 2008, is one president for whom the topic of BDS merited not only public condemnation, but also action. A self-described “strong defender of Israel” who oversees some of the most combustive campuses in America, Yudof has been alternately portrayed as a First Amendment wonk out of step with Jewish interests and an unblinking Zionist beholden to them.
In 2010, when U.C. Berkeley and U.C. San Diego students introduced bills in their student governments calling for divestment from General Electric Co. and United Technologies — two companies that manufacture Israeli military gear — Yudof felt compelled to take a decisive step. That May, he issued a statement saying that the Board of Regents would not consider BDS, since it was the board’s policy to take up divestment only if America’s government said that the regime in question was committing genocide. But for Yudof, there was a secondary reason.
“I thought there was a double standard with Israel,” he said. “It was unimaginable. Other countries were given a pass, and they were going to enforce this boycott against a tiny country in the Middle East. In my judgment, but for it being the Jewish state, it would not be on their list for a boycott.”
In the end, neither school adopted the bills.
Judith Shapiro, who served as president of Barnard College from 1994 to 2008, cited similar reasons for publicly opposing the BDS movement at Columbia University and Barnard in 2002. Her term at Barnard saw a major flare-up on the topic of Israel when Jewish alumni and community members vociferously opposed the tenure of professor Nadia Abu El Haj, contending that her book, “Facts on the Ground,” called into question the Jewish connection to the Land of Israel. Shapiro took a hands-off approach in this instance, reassuring alumni that the tenure process would examine El Haj — who was eventually hired — fairly and vigorously.
But in the case of a faculty and student call for BDS, Shapiro went public. She issued a statement with Columbia President Lee Bollinger, saying that the two opposed BDS in part because it squelched public debate about the conflict on campus. The university’s Advisory Committee on Socially Responsible Investing took up the question of divesting from companies that benefit from the Israeli occupation, but the proposal was ultimately rejected.
Thousands of Jews packed into a Johannesburg shul to pay tribute to Mandela, the 'Joseph of South Africa.'
The current NFL season demonstrates the great flaw of pro football: The quarterback has become too important. How did this happen? It all goes back to Sid Luckman.
A quiet revolution is taking place among ultra-Orthodox women in Jerusalem. They have discovered the power of mascara.
The Council of Jews in Germany receives a river of hate mail.
Disturbingly, a study shows that 60% of the letters come from well-educated Germans, including some university professors: http://jd.fo/t1for
Does that number surprise you? Share your reactions in the comments.
"Also, one will beautify [Shabbat candle lighting] when the wick is made from cotton, flax or cannabis…”
While researching #Shabbat customs, Yosef Glassman came across this reference. It sent him on a mission to learn about the biblical history of weed: http://jd.fo/j1d05
Could a 1976 movie starring Alain Delon have predicted the tale of Cornelius Gurlitt, found to be holding 1,280 pieces of Nazi-looted art in his Munich apartment?
Find out: http://jd.fo/a1Voc
Greek geometricians like Euclid knew that letters could be used to solve numerical problems.
Philologos explains how rabbis do the same with the Hebrew alphabet: http://jd.fo/i1d9n
What does the Bible say about contraception?
Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg explains: http://jd.fo/f1cV9
Can you recognize Mandy Patinkin without his beard?
The beloved facial hair that has become Saul Berenson's trademark look on "Homeland," is no more: http://jd.fo/h1cpf
Once, there was a less-complicated time when Jewish and African freedom struggles went hand in hand.
J.J. Goldberg recalls memories of Mandela from a Zionist childhood: http://jd.fo/e1VRI
"Wall" or "separation barrier"? "Palestine" or "West Bank"?
Why writing about the Holy Land can get pretty tricky: http://jd.fo/j1cGe
What flavors define #Jerusalem?
WATCH Yotam Ottolenghi and Sami Tamimi describe their top picks:http://jd.fo/e1UgG
Did they miss any? Let us know in the comments.
Nelson Mandela was a global symbol of the fight for human dignity. But there were two sides to any great leader — and Mandela sometimes made Jews very uncomfortable.
May his memory be a blessing.
Need a weekend movie suggestion?
Read Ezra Glinter's review of the new Coen Brothers movie, "Inside Llewyn Davis," which opens in theaters tomorrow: http://jd.fo/t1f36
Nelson Mandela has become a beloved icon for all of South Africa. But his death is also mourned by the Jewish community, with which he shared an enduring bond.
Richard Goldstone remembers a great man: http://jd.fo/i1cV8