Real Winner of War on Terror: Osama Bin Laden

Decade Later, Terrorists Are Flexing Muscle More Than Ever

Top Target: A May 30 car bombing in Iraq, where more than a third of terrorist deaths have occurred over the past decade.
Getty Images
Top Target: A May 30 car bombing in Iraq, where more than a third of terrorist deaths have occurred over the past decade.

By J.J. Goldberg

Published May 31, 2013, issue of June 07, 2013.

(page 2 of 2)

Beginning in 2004 the State Department replaced Patterns with a new publication, Country Reports in Terrorism. It gave data for dozens of countries but no worldwide totals. The Obama administration resumed publishing worldwide totals in 2009. Incidents now topped 10,000. There was no way to compare current figures with earlier ones.

The Australian institute stepped in last year with its own study, the Global Terrorism Index. It examined trends in 158 countries over the course of a decade, starting with 2002, immediately after the 9/11 attacks.

The Index uses a University of Maryland definition for terrorism, casting a somewhat narrower net than the Obama State Department. Terrorism is defined as “threatened or actual use of illegal force and violence by a non-state actor to attain a political, economic, religious or social goal through coercion and intimidation.”

Actions by governments are not included. Neither are individual acts of passion that could be defined as hate crimes, even when seemingly motivated by religious or political fervor.

The report lists 15 groups responsible for the most incidents or deaths. The Afghan Taliban is far in the lead in both categories, followed by other Islamic groups including Al Qaeda in Iraq and the Somali Al Shabaab. Other highly prolific groups include the Colombian Marxist group FARC, the Communist Party of India-Maoist and the Sri Lankan nationalist Tamil Tigers.

The report doesn’t mention right-wing Christian and anti-abortion groups that are responsible for roughly half of all terrorists deaths in the United States in the past decade. However, given that U.S. fatalities total fewer than 60 over the decade, the number is statistically insignificant in the global pattern.

Examining the statistics by country, the vast majority of incidents and deaths prove to involve Islamic insurgencies in a handful of countries. Iraq, Pakistan and Afghanistan are responsible for fully half of all the world’s 64,000 terrorist deaths over the decade. Iraq alone accounts for more than one-third.

Next in line, in order, are India, Yemen, Somalia, Nigeria, Thailand, Russia and Philippines. Together, the top 10 hot spots account for 87% of all terrorist fatalities since 2002. Of those, only India and Philippines have significant insurgencies that aren’t Islamic-related.

Of the 158 countries surveyed, only 31 had no terrorist incidents at all. Terrorism in North America was virtually negligible. Europe had 19 times as many deaths as the United States.

Perhaps the report’s most striking bit of news is the timing. Most non-Islamic terrorism has declined precipitously over the decade. But each of the most troubled countries, Iraq, Pakistan and Afghanistan, saw its numbers rise explosively after the United States military moved in. Also striking, the numbers plateaued in 2007 and began to decline as American involvement began to scale down.

We tend to search for a great many reasons to explain the rise of Islamic terrorism, but the message most often recited by the terrorists themselves is the simplest: We want you out of our countries. Even Osama bin Laden began his anti-American war after America set up a permanent military presence in his native Saudi Arabia.

The conclusion is sobering: It could be that the most important single cause of terrorism is — the war on terror.

Contact J.J. Goldberg at goldberg@forward.com or visit his blog at www.forward.com



Would you like to receive updates about new stories?






















We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.