The New Meaning of the Bar and Bat Mitzvah

We humans are resistant to change. It unsettles us. Causes us discomfort. And anxiety. And yet, as first articulated by the Greek philosopher, Heraclitus, change is the only constant. Whether or not we like it, things do change. What is in our control is how we choose to handle it. Do we deny its inevitability and cling to the waning status quo? Do we embrace the opportunity to evolve and enhance the experience?

This January, I will chant my Torah portion in honor of my 30th anniversary of becoming a bat mitzvah. It is an annual tradition and is a lasting gift from a one-time event that occurred as I teetered on the precipice between childhood and adulthood. Thirty years after the fact, I can so clearly recall the hours of practicing for my service. Digging into commentaries with my mom in order to write my d’var torah. Spending hours, learning with the rabbi, until I was able to make the text my own. When I stood on the bimah and received the Torah from the hands of my parents and grandparents, I was keenly aware that I was taking my place in a chain of tradition.

My bat mitzvah experience, however, was not the norm. Unlike most, I actually loved attending Hebrew School. My mother holds a degree in Hebrew from UCLA and my father is a rabbi. I was reared in a home where Judaism was a living, breathing, celebrated essence of who we were and how we lived. I, too, am a rabbi and I strive to create a home modeled after the one in which I was so blessed to grow up. So my experience, both personal and professional, borders on unique.

The current conversation about bar and bat Mitzvahs is an important one. And one that, understandably, is filled with tension. Like so many challenges in Jewish life, there is not one “right” answer. At least, there is not one answer that will satisfy everyone. Nor, I would suggest, has there ever been one.

While we like to romanticize the Jewish community of past eras, we would be remiss in thinking that we have ever been a homogenous people. From our outset, we have rarely agreed on how best to live a Jewish life. The Talmud is rife with disagreements among our Sages. What we learn by their example, however, is not only that there are different approaches to any concern but that we must respect those who hold varied opinions.

Jewish Law holds that one reaches the age of commandment at 13 (for boys) and 12 (for girls). Just as American citizens reach the age of majority upon the 18th birthday, nothing else is required for an individual to be considered ritually responsible than reaching the requisite age.

But bar (or bat) mitzvah has come to mean something else. Rather than becoming a bar mitzvah, the focus is on having a bar mitzvah: being called to Torah, chanting the Haftarah, leading part or all of the service, and delivering a drasha or speech as the culmination of years of study and preparation and in the presence of one’s community. There can be something inherently powerful about a young person on the cusp of adulthood being empowered to serve as the service leader as well as a teacher of Torah. There have been far too many times, though, that I have sat through a service and questioned the value of what was essentially a phonetic recitation. And wondered about community at services that were not held at the normal worship times. Or the desire for a Havdallah service when it is clear that no one in the family was familiar with the actual ritual that concludes Shabbat.

Some synagogue cultures take this focus to the extreme. In addition to turning the entire worship experience over to the celebrant and his or her family, some synagogues encourage a number of speeches to be delivered about the bar or bat mitzvah. I have attended services that included speeches by two Hebrew School classmates, the B’nai Mitzvah tutor, the Board of Trustees representative, the rabbi and both parents. Extolling the achievements and bestowing accolades that seem far more appropriate for a candidate on the path towards beatification and rather hyperbolic when describing the average 13-year-old.

If the focus is not on the service-leading aspect, it might be seen as a tribal rite of passage that indicates the emergence of one now ritually responsible for his or her actions. If we expect our students to count towards a minyan , we must teach them the Mourner’s Kaddish. If we expect them to count towards a mezuman , we must teach them Birkat Hamazon. Let’s make certain that our efforts are in concert with our expectations.

To say that there is only one valid way to become a bar or bat mitzvah is to deny the current religious climate. It would behoove us, as a people, to recognize that there are various ways to enter into adult Jewish life.

Your Stories

  • "I push wagons, I work with a shovel, I turn rotten in the rain, I shiver in the wind; already my own body is no longer mine: my belly is swollen, my limbs emaciated, my face is thick in the morning, hollow in the evening; some of us have yellow skin, others grey. When we do not meet for a few days we hardly recognize each other."Primo Levi, "Survival in Auschwitz"

  • "This holiday we take for ourselves,
 no longer silent servers behind the curtain, 
but singers of the seder,
 with voices of gladness,
 creating our own convocation,
 and leaving ‘The Narrow Place’ together."E.M. Broner

  • "The idea of opening the door is that we hope Elijah might actually be there this year – that we might actually have done enough to change the world to have had him arrive. And, if we don’t have even the tiniest bit in us that thinks he might be there, that thinks we have tried our hardest to bring around a messianic time, with no hunger, no war, no conflict, no pain – if we don’t believe that we have tried to end those broken parts in the world – well, then I tell my students – don’t do any of it."Rabbi Leora Kaye

  • "The whole seder, for me, is the tension between two statements: We say, 'We were slaves to Pharaoh in Egypt and now we’re free,' but before that, we pick up the matzoh, we invite the hungry in and we say, 'This year we are slaves, next year may we be free.' We are the most fortunate, liberated Jews in history. But on the other hand, there are lots of things that enslave us."Rabbi Arthur Green

  • "To tune of "Mack the Knife": "Enter Haman ben Hamdasa, /And he’s claimin’, he’s an Agagite. /Better look out, oh Hadassah/For that Haman—he’s an Amalekite./And though Haman, he’s in power now, That old Mordy, will not bow down. /Haman’s ego, it takes a powder now. And just like that—Amalek’s in town!""By Rabbi Jan Uhrbach

  • "Do you know that every shepherd/ has his own tune? / Do you know that every blade/ of grass has its own poem?/ And from the poem/ of the grasses,/ a tune of the shepherd/ is made./ How beautiful and/ pleasant to hear/ this poem!"Reb Nachman of Breslov's Likutei Moharan

  • "Tu B'Shvat is more than a New Year for Trees -- it is a call to action. To observe Tu B'Shvat isn't to read and pray, but to do, to plant, to place one's hands in contact with the Earth....While we may mark Tu B'Shvat as a Jewish Earth Day once a year, we are responsible as Jews to act as environmental stewards every day."David Krantz - Aytzim: Ecological Judaism

  • "Donniel Hartman said the miracle of Hanukkah is not just that the oil lasted 8 days; it’s actually that it lasted more than one. Would we have said, 'Dayenu,' (to mix metaphors,) if it had lasted two days? Would we have had a holiday? Probably, yes. The idea that we as a Jewish community, even in our darkest moments, hold out the hope that a candle is going to keep burning, I find very powerful."Rabbi Rachel Ain

  • "“We would all argue vehemently and work tireless against assimilation. But the Hellenists and we Reform Jews didn’t assimilate. We acculturate, and by doing so, provide a portal for continuity unavailable to those who continue a quasi-ghettoized existence with all the ramifications thereof, good and bad. The irony, rarely mentioned by those who use the Hanukah story to justify Orthodoxy, is that the Maccabees (Hasmoneans) lasted a century and a half before they disappeared, having taken on Greek names as High Priests and Kings. And Rabbinic Judaism, the first ‘reform’ movement, birthed all of us.”"Rabbi Peter J. Rubinstein

  • "I find it refreshing to go from carrying the decomposing lulav and etrog in our hands in procession for 7 days (save for Shabbat), to carry absolutely nothing on Shemini Atzeret, to then carry a Torah on Simchat Torah. It’s like Judaism’s way of saying… ‘What you are carrying with you on this journey — Torah, lessons, stories, values, covenant, a connection with a higher power and history — all of the intangibles, you carry them with you on the tangible, tentative, twisting path of life."Rabbi Paul Jacobson

  • "Shemini Atzeret is conceptually an attempt to maintain the holiday relationship with God without any specific rituals. In modern times it has been become eclipsed by the joy and dancing of Simchat Torah. This speaks to the difficulty in a pure relationship without concrete modes of expression. It could be a reminder that our close relationships exist even when we don't exchange presents or cards."Rabbi Yosef Blau

  • "Sukkot is the reminder that it doesn't take two days or even two years to go from darkness to light. It might take an entire lifetime to get there and you have to constantly walk with the belief that it's possible."Rabbi Sharon Brous

  • "Yom Kippur: God is our judge. Sukkot: God is our shelter. Yom Kippur: you sit cooped up for endless hours. Sukkot is about space and breath. Yom Kippur, it’s all about, ‘What have I done?’ And Sukkot is, ‘What can I do in the world?’"Rabbi Naomi Levy

  • "The Rabbis in the Talmud spoke of the necessity of both sinai and oker harim, that is both those who collected traditions that were handed down and also those who literally “overturned mountains.” Essentially, the one group would not survive without the other. It is in the radical interpretations of the given traditions, and in the broad and fluent knowledge of the traditions that one is able to create radical new interpretations."Dr. Aryeh Cohen

  • ""I have never felt that repentence, prayer, and tzedakah would change my fate. Rather, I feel that through honest reflection, refinement, and a sense of responsibility, I do have incredible power to affect the decree for others.""Cantor Ellen Dreskin

  • "Teshuvah does invite us to begin again, but not from the beginning. Part of what it means to be human is to learn how to begin again and again – from right where we are, right in the messy middle of things. The Torah, according to an ancient midrash, reminds us of this truth by opening the story of creation itself with the letter Bet…Even when we have rolled the parchment scroll as far back as it will go, the letter Bet meets us there -- insisting that this story cannot be told from the very beginning. No story can. Beginnings elude us."Rabbi Sharon Cohen Anisfeld

  • "This year our theme at Temple Emanuel Beverly Hills is “If not Now, When?” and we asked congregants to tweet their responses to #innwtebh or to fill out cards filling in the blanks :“If not now, when will I….” We will prepare these ‘intentions for the year” in a similar way, as a power point presentation scrolling quietly on the screen facing the congregation as individuals come forward silently in front of the open ark before neilah."Rabbi Laura Geller

Your Video(s):
    Your Image(s):

      Screen name will be displayed if your story is published.

      Email address will always be kept private.

      Recommend this article

      The New Meaning of the Bar and Bat Mitzvah

      Thank you!

      This article has been sent!