‘Subgate’ Conflict of Interest Scandal Roils Israel — and Germany Too by the Forward

‘Subgate’ Conflict of Interest Scandal Roils Israel — and Germany Too

Questions over the purchase of German submarines that started with media reports of a potential conflict of interest involving Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s lawyer have mounted in the last 10 days, spurring investigations in two countries.

At one level the issue is straightforward: Israel wanted to replace some of its aging submarines and maintain its military edge against potential threats like Iran, so it ordered three new submarines, costing $1.5 billion, from Germany’s ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems, with delivery in about a decade.

The first sign of a hiccup arose when Israeli media pointed out that the intermediary on the deal, Israeli businessman Miki Ganor, had retained Netanyahu’s personal lawyer, David Shimron, to act on his behalf in the transaction.

Netanyahu and Shimron have denied any impropriety. Shimron said he never discussed the deal with the prime minister so as to avoid any conflict of interest, and Netanyahu has given his full backing to his lawyer, who is a distant relative.

But ThyssenKrupp now says it was not aware Ganor had engaged anyone else on the deal and is carrying out an internal investigation to establish whether any rules were broken.

“In Israel, ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems works exclusively with Mr Ganor as a sales partner,” the company said in a statement. “Our sales partners are contractually obligated to consult with ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems before engaging sub-contractors. This has not happened.

“We do what we always do as part of our process: if we get indications of irregularities, we fully check and clarify the facts.”

In Israel, the authorities have seen fit to investigate, too. In a statement last week, the Justice Ministry announced that the attorney general had ordered police to look into the submarine contract as well as an agreement for ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems to build four patrol ships for Israel.


“Following new information received from the police and in view of other developments,” the ministry said on Nov. 23, “the attorney general has ordered an investigation to be carried out by police concerning various aspects of the affair.”

Shimron has welcomed the inquiry, saying he is confident it will clear him of any conflict of interest.

Ganor, who according to Israel’s Channel 10 is set to earn around 10 million euros from the deal, has kept a low profile.

At this stage, there are no indications the contract is in danger of collapsing or that it is going to have political fallout for Netanyahu, who is nearly two years into his fourth term as prime minister.

But Israeli transparency advocates want a clear and thorough public inquiry to put everyone’s mind to rest, especially when it comes to the 2009 decision to appoint Ganor as intermediary, replacing a retired brigadier general who handled all previous deals with Germany and was dubbed “Submarine King.”

And they also want to understand why ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems was given the contract to build the four patrol vessels, which will police Israel’s offshore gas facilities, rather than the Ministry of Defence issuing a tender.

“This is a really big deal, worth billions of shekels,” said Maozia Segal, chairman of Ometz, a group that campaigns for clean government and has handed authorities allegations of corruption in the past, leading to investigations.

“If it’s fishy, it should be checked. We don’t know who knew what and when and why certain decisions were taken. There are serious concerns, and they deserve a national inquiry.”

‘Subgate’ Conflict of Interest Scandal Roils Israel — and Germany Too


Your Comments

The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. All readers can browse the comments, and all Forward subscribers can add to the conversation. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, The Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not and will be deleted. Egregious commenters or repeat offenders will be banned from commenting. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, our spam filter prevents most links and certain key words from being posted and the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.

Recommend this article

‘Subgate’ Conflict of Interest Scandal Roils Israel — and Germany Too

Thank you!

This article has been sent!