The death of small business is a tragedy for Jewish community and democracy
1933 Macy’s Display: The works of three of Edith Halpert’s artists —Charles Sheeler, Stuart Davis and Edward Biberman. Image by Smithsonian Institution
“Small-scale commercial production is, every moment of every day, giving birth spontaneously to capitalism and the bourgeoisie…wherever there is small business and freedom of trade, capitalism appears.”— V.I. Lenin
A great connoisseur as well as sworn enemy of the free market, Vladimir Lenin might smile a bit if he witnessed what is now happening to small businesses in the current Covid-19 pandemic. Even before, America was experiencing falling rates of business formation as well as declining homeownership, particularly among the young. The share of GDP represented by small firms had dropped from 50 to 45% since the 1990s.
Now the current pandemic, and the policies being applied to contain it, are creating a perfect storm that could devastate millions of already struggling businesses. Millions of little firms have been forced to shut down, with some likely not to open before the summer, if ever.
The longer the shutdown continues, the tougher things could become for many of the estimated 30 million small businesses that employ roughly half of all Americans. The prospects are particularly bleak for restaurants, small retail establishments and “personal service” establishments like salons and gyms whose primary selling point against larger firms has been their scale and familiarity with customers. According to the JP Morgan Institute, 50% small businesses have a mere 15 days of cash buffer or less. If the shut down lasts much longer, as many as three-quarters of independent restaurants simply won’t make it. In the end, once the fog of the pandemic dies down, we are likely to see a great deal more empty storefronts and many of our beloved local businesses abandoned. And the body count is expected to include high profile names such as Nieman-Marcus, Rite-Aid, AMC Theatres. J. Crew and 24-Hour Fitness.
In contrast, this pandemic could usher in a golden age for efficient, technology-savvy firms like Amazon, as well as better capitalized chains such as McDonalds or Chick-fil-a, which have shifted well to online platforms and are better positioned to return to full business after the disruption. If the shut down lasts much longer, expect your local taco stand to be replaced by the likes of Taco Bell or Chipotle and the family Chinese spot by Panda Express.
“Feudalism with Better Marketing”
Small business has been a critical element in America’s remarkable record of ethnic uplift. In America and other western countries, suggests historian Ellis Rivkin, “the fate of the Jew and of Judaism came to hinge on the capitalist revolution” as feudal barriers disappeared. Over the past century other newcomers — Italians, Chinese, Indians, Cubans, Africans to name notable examples — have focused on small business to advance into the middle class. In recent years entrepreneurship has risen most notably among immigrants and, increasingly, women, eager to make their bid for independence and self-sufficiency.
The loss of small firms over the past decade has done much to alter the unique character of many of our great cities. Ethnic shopping districts, like the once vibrant Polish neighborhoods in Chicago, have all but lost their shops and customer base. In New York the once ubiquitous delicatessens and Greek-owned diners are becoming endangered species. The City Journal notes that in Gotham, once home to small, independent restaurants, larger restaurant groups have begun to “dominate the culinary scene.”
Yet these concerns are not just those colored by nostalgia for the scent of urban streets past. It is also, perhaps even more so, about the slaughter of suburban small businesses. After all, this is where the ethnic Americans of all stripes have concentrated — 80% of all residents of the country’s big metros reside and work in suburbia.
Here the damage includes not only Main Streets but also large shopping complexes and strip malls, the centers that architect Tim Cisneros calls “the immigrants’ friend.” Now many of these malls face bankruptcies as tenants can no longer pay rent. Even before the pandemic, Center Square Investment Management estimated that 44% of current mall retail space will be either shuttered or repurposed over the next five to seven years.
This is not merely a plea for the little guy, but also a warning about the future. Many of the businesses with Jewish founders started small — Home Depot, The Gap, Costco (originally Price club), the Limited, the Simon Properties and Westfield Corp. mall developers, Broadcom. They later became larger, and many have played a key role in the philanthropic lives of their home cities and the Jewish community. With the decline of the economy, particularly with a long lockdown in key locales, prospects for small businesses to get bigger have diminished. Most face not a bright future, but what the Harvard Business Review calls “an existential threat.”
Today’s economy does not favor risk taking outsiders. It prefers those already “insiders”,like well-financed large restaurant chains that are better equipped to adjust to on-line formats and future social distancing regimes. For most smaller firms— the Panda Expresses of tomorrow, if you will— the future seems bleak. The National Restaurant Association estimates that more than 8 million restaurant employees have been laid off or furloughed since the beginning of the coronavirus outbreak in March. This represents more than two-thirds of the 12 million employees that were working at the nation’s eating and drinking establishments in February.
Even more than the big chains, the long-term victors will be the big tech giants. Even before the pandemics, firms such as Microsoft, Facebook, Apple, Amazon and Google and Netflix possess market power either together or solely, that covers as much as 80 to 90% of key markets like cellphone operating systems, computer programs, on-line shopping and search.
The pandemic seems likely to bolster their already rapidly growing stranglehold over both the stock market and the economy. Once seen as dominated by risk-taking entrepreneurs starting in a garage and backed by credit card debt, tech has becomes defined by corporate concentration, what one Silicon Valley wag labeled “feudalism with better marketing.”
The pandemic will likely accelerate this process. With jobs scarce, these firms now enjoy ever greater ability to recruit tech talent no longer looking for startups. Like Main Street businesses, small entrepreneurial tech firms are losing out to their giant competitors or forced to accept subordinate status.
The biggest threat
More maddening for small business people is seeing funds flow to owners of luxury real estate, hedge funds and brokerages. The Indian-born owner of our local UPS franchise said that while bailouts are going to major corporations, his business was turned down for a loan. Small restaurants have been allowed to struggle while funds are diverted to better funded, better connected business like the Ruth Criss and Potbelly chains , which have access as well to Wall Street’s money. Many big firms like Papa John, KFC, Wendy’s needed the money since they spent so much of their cash on “buybacks” of their own stock, and now are asking taxpayers to fill their self-inflicted cash shortages.
What’s at stake is not just a change in the business landscape, but the social disaster that the collapse of small businesses could bring. After all it is the local businessperson who is most likely to support the soccer or baseball team in your town. And in ethnic communities— Jewish, Chinese, Indian, West Indian, Latino— it is the entrepreneur who funds the local church, temple, and school that serves their communities. To be sure, large companies donate as well, but their operatives often are temporary residents of towns and communities; their primary loyalties are to their firms, not their neighbors or ethnic group.
This has always been particularly critical for Jews, who in their long history, have learned the benefits of communal self-reliance. “Seeest thou a man diligent in his business?” asks Proverbs (22:29) “He shall stand before kings.” In our history it has been the entrepreneurs —- the Rothschilds, Bronfmans, Lauders, Lowys, Adelsons, Marcus’— who have provided critical support for such things as the State of Israel, Jewish education and the battle against anti-Semitism.
Now that support is threatened as business prospects fade. Jewish philanthropy, like that of others, is in free fall, and the old-line money cannot by itself stem the tide. Right now the JCCs and other Jewish organizations are bracing for major cutbacks. To survive this economic downturn, Jewish organizations, synagogues and schools need more than legacy money— they require the contribution and energy of those still on the way up. An entrepreneurial bloodbath will become a communal disaster.
Yet we should not forget that devastating small business is not just about the fate of our economy or our philanthropy. It is also about the nature of our society and the durability of our Republic’s institutions. Throughout history, as Aristotle noted, independent proprietors have been the driving force for self-government and republican order. Aristotle also warned about the dangers of an oligarchy that would control both the economy and the state. Ultimately, ever greater consolidation of wealth played a major role in undermining Greek democracy and the citizen-led Roman Republic. When the small proprietor declines, as in ancient Greece and Rome, and now in America, we see the irrepressible rise of oligarchy.
This suggests for political and social as well as economic reasons, it is imperative to find ways to help Main Street survive. A country dominated by a small group of mega-corporations and an ever more intrusive state may retain the forms of a republican democracy, but will become essentially ever more feudal, repressive and constrained.
Joel Kotkin is the Presidential Fellow in Urban Futures at Chapman University and executive director of the Urban Reform Institute. His next book, The Coming of Neo-Feudalism, will be out from Encounter late this spring. You can follow him on Twitter @joelkotkin
A message from our Publisher & CEO Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
