Meeting With Mitchell, Netanhayu Vows To Honor Israel’s Commitments
Likud Chairman and Prime Minister-designate Benjamin Netanyahu on Thursday told the special U.S. envoy to the Middle East, George Mitchell, that as Israel’s prime minister he will honor all commitments or international obligations taken on by previous Israeli administrations.
This remark is unusual for Netanyahu, and the event marks the first time he voiced such a sentiment since the Feb. 10 elections. Apparently, Netanyahu aims to communicate a message to the U.S., and to Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni, of his moderate approach to the peace process with the Palestinians.
Netanyahu is currently negotiating to form a government with Kadima, whose chairwoman, Livni, has made the final-status talks a condition for her entry into the coalition. Hence Netanyahu’s statement was seen as a nod toward her as well as Washington.
During their Tel Aviv meeting, Netanyahu told Mitchell, who has been tasked with jump-starting flagging peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians, that “after the government is established, I will reassess Israel’s foreign policy,” Netanyahu told his American colleague. “My government will continue to advance the peace process with the Palestinians in its own way.”
“We will honor all of Israel’s international commitments and won’t take any actions that violate them,” the Likud leader added, but did not specify to which commitments he was referring.
Israel’s central commitments in regard to the Palestinians include the Road Map, limiting West Bank settlement construction, removal of illegal outposts and especially the Annapolis declaration, in which Israel pledged to work toward former U.S. President George W. Bush’s vision of two states for two peoples.
During his meetings with Israel’s leadership on Thursday, Mitchell heard from Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, from Livni and from Netanyahu himself that should a Palestinian unity government be established, it would have to comply with the conditions set by the Quartet of Mideast peace negotiators – the U.S., The United Nations, the European Union and Russia – that include recognizing Israel, honoring previous agreements and abandoning terror.
Mitchell stressed that the U.S. administration remains committed to the Quartet guidelines. “There is no change in our position, and will remain as such even if a Palestinian unity government is established,” he said.
The Mitchell-Netanyahu meeting also focused on American efforts to reconcile the two rival Palestinian factions ¬ Hamas, which rules the Gaza Strip, and Fatah, which rules the West Bank. Netanyahu argued that inter-Palestinian reconciliation might further radicalize both the West Bank and Gaza, and should therefore not be encouraged. Unless Hamas changes its positions, he warned, such a reconciliation is liable to destroy any chance for peace.
In response, Netanyahu told Mitchell that “an internal Palestinian reconciliation may bring about further escalation in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, and therefore must not be encouraged. As long as Hamas doesn’t change its stance it could sabotage any chance for a peace process.”
The meeting was the first between Netanyahu and George Mitchell since Netanyahu was tapped to lead Israel’s next government. Netanyahu later said the meeting had been good and that the two planned to meet again.
The administration of U.S. President Barack Obama has dispatched Mitchell to the region for the second time in its first month, reflecting the administration’s resolve to end the decades-old conflict between Israel and the Palestinians. Hillary Clinton is due in the area next week for her first visit since being appointed the new U.S. secretary of state.
Mitchell hopes to re-energize stalled talks, but Netanyahu wants to promote Palestinian prosperity instead of Palestinian statehood. Netanyahu also is committed to expanding Jewish settlements in the West Bank, while Mitchell has urged a settlement freeze since 2001. The Palestinians reject Netanyahu’s approach.
Mitchell arrived in Israel on Thursday from Turkey and headed straight into a meeting with Livni before sitting down with Netanyahu.
In Ankara, he said predominantly Muslim Turkey’s friendship with Israel gave it a unique opportunity to help achieve Middle East peace – a reflection of Washington’s desire to see the two U.S. allies mend ties frayed during Israel’s recent offensive in the Gaza Strip.
Mitchell’s remarks reflect the U.S. desire to see Turkey and Israel maintain close relations despite a dispute between the two U.S. allies after Turkey accused Israel of using excessive force in an offensive against Hamas that took a heavy toll on Gaza’s civilians.
“As an important democratic nation with strong relations with Israel, [Turkey] has a unique role to play and can have significant influence on our efforts to promote comprehensive peace in the Middle East,” Mitchell said after meeting Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan.
Turkey has long been Israel’s closest ally in the Muslim world, and has tried, along with Egypt and France, to mediate for peace in the Middle East.
In January, at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, Erdogan reprimanded Israeli President Shimon Peres over civilian casualties during the Gaza war and walked out of a panel discussion.
This month, a senior Israeli general reportedly accused Turkey of killing Armenians in 1915, and of oppressing Kurds and occupying Cyprus. Turkey protested, and Israel’s military said the general’s remarks did not reflect Israel’s official view.
“It is important for us now to look forward and to work together to build a secure, prosperous future for all of the people of this region,” Mitchell said.
On his first trip to the region last month, Mitchell promised a vigorous push for Israel-Palestinian peace but publicly offered no glimpse into how the Obama administration planned to proceed. A U.S. official said Mitchell was not expected to make any public policy statements this time, either.
Such statements might await Clinton’s visit or be put off until Netanyahu forms a government.
Despite his own hawkish leanings, Netanyahu knows the international community would like to see a moderate coalition lineup. But his efforts to woo moderate parties that would trade land for peace have not been going well.
Livni’s Kadima Party and Barak’s Labor Party have rejected his overtures, in part because of his opposition to peacemaking. Netanyahu’s alternative is to team up with other nationalist and religious parties in a narrow alliance that could easily break apart over conflicting domestic agendas or international pressure to make concessions to the Palestinians.
One of Mitchell’s immediate goals in the region is to shore up a shaky, informal cease-fire that ended Israel’s bruising offensive against Gaza Strip militants last month. Egyptian officials have been trying to mediate a long-term truce between Israel and the Islamic militant Hamas group that rules Gaza.
Low-level violence has marred the Jan. 18 cease-fire. On Thursday, militants fired two rockets at southern Israel and Israel later sent aircraft to raid southern Gaza, targeting smuggling tunnels near the border with Egypt. No injuries were reported in the rocket attacks or the air strike.
In his talks with Israeli officials and with Palestinian leaders on Friday, Mitchell is also expected to focus on the need to rebuild Gaza after the Israeli offensive and efforts to reconcile feuding Palestinian factions.
The Palestinians hope to raise $2.8 billion at an international donor’s conference in Egypt on Monday, where the U.S. is expected to pledge $900 million.
The success of reconstruction efforts will depend largely on Israel’s agreement to reopen border crossings into Gaza to let through building materials and other equipment and commodities. Israel blockaded its borders with Gaza after Hamas militants overran the territory nearly two years ago, prying them open only to let in limited humanitarian supplies.
Truce talks recently deadlocked over Israel’s insistence that Hamas release a long-held Israeli soldier before border crossings are opened.
A power-sharing deal between Hamas and the moderate West Bank government of Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas is also seen as key to reconstruction efforts. Many in the international community shun the violently anti-Israel Hamas and won’t send money directly to it.
In a report obtained by The Associated Press on Thursday, Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad asked donors to channel aid first and foremost through his West Bank government.
Hamas and Fatah representatives have been meeting in Cairo this week for Egyptian-mediated talks. But earlier rounds of reconciliation efforts failed, and the two sides remain bitterly divided nearly two years after Hamas overran Gaza.
Mitchell, a former Senate Minority leader from Maine, had great success in brokering an agreement in Northern Ireland, and was dispatched to the Middle East in 2001 to pen a report on the outbreak of the second intifada. The document, dubbed the “Mitchell Report,” included recommendations for confidence-building measures for each side. However ultimately both Israel and the Palestinians failed to implement these recommendations, and the report was subsequently shelved.
The envoy visited Israel in January, where he spoke with Olmert about the situation in Gaza.
Mitchell’s first trip abroad as Obama’s Middle East envoy also took him to the West Bank, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, France, Egypt and Britain.
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning journalism this Passover.
In this age of misinformation, our work is needed like never before. We report on the news that matters most to American Jews, driven by truth, not ideology.
At a time when newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall. That means for the first time in our 126-year history, Forward journalism is free to everyone, everywhere. With an ongoing war, rising antisemitism, and a flood of disinformation that may affect the upcoming election, we believe that free and open access to Jewish journalism is imperative.
Readers like you make it all possible. Right now, we’re in the middle of our Passover Pledge Drive and we still need 300 people to step up and make a gift to sustain our trustworthy, independent journalism.
Make a gift of any size and become a Forward member today. You’ll support our mission to tell the American Jewish story fully and fairly.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
Join our mission to tell the Jewish story fully and fairly.
Only 300 more gifts needed by April 30
