Tel Aviv — The round-faced boy given the unusual first name of Rabbi by his Filipino parents was born 11 years ago in Israel and has never known another home.
He speaks only Hebrew and has never traveled to the Philippines, but along with some 1,100 other children of foreign workers without work permits in Israel, the boy faces possible deportation along with his family.
“I feel Israeli in my heart and in my soul,” said the boy, Rabbi Eliazar Cruz.
His parents initially came to Israel legally, as caretakers for elderly clients, but overstayed their visas.
“The Land of Israel is my land,” Rabbi said. “But these days I stay mostly at home, inside. I don’t want to be caught outside and asked by the police where my parents are and deported.”
In late July, a government order to deport the children and their families as part of a larger expulsion of migrants was delayed for three months by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the last minute under pressure from the public, local human rights groups and even President Shimon Peres.
Still, the question of government policy on the issue of the Israeli-born children of foreign workers, most of whose parents entered the country legally but stayed after their work permits expired, remains unresolved.
Like other countries in the industrial world, Israel faces the dilemma of how to deal with the families created on its soil by the foreign workers it invites in. But Israel, which has no immigration policy for non-Jews, finds itself in uncharted territory.
“On the one hand, Israel encouraged foreign workers to come for short-term stays and participate in the labor market in fields where there were not enough workers,” said John Gal, a professor of social work at Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
“But there was no contingency for them staying and raising families here,” he said. “So Israel is now faced with a situation where we have children of workers born here but who lack citizenship or clear status.”
Sabine Hadad, a spokeswoman for the Interior Ministry, said deporting illegal residents is a matter of law enforcement.
“These people have broken the law and they know that,” she said of foreigners who overstayed their visas. “The law needs to be applied.”
Instituting a policy that allows the parents of children born in Israel to stay in the country permanently also would open a route for illegal immigrants to stay in Israel forever: simply have a child here.
In the meantime, some 2,000 children of foreigners have come of age in Israel. They speak fluent Hebrew, attend Israeli schools and have joined youth movements. Some have even served in the military.
In 2006, a one-time government ruling gave 900 of the children permanent residency status. Those whose futures are now in question are the 1,100 others.
“I’m not Jewish, but I am Israeli,” said a teenager whose parents came to Israel from Turkey.
The boy was speaking at a meeting of such children Tuesday at the offices of the Hotline for Migrant Workers, which is one of the main organizations lobbying against deportation.
Israeli rights groups also take issue with what they call the government’s revolving-door policy of forcing foreign workers out of the country and then bringing in new workers instead of just keeping those who are here and want to stay.
Most of the country’s foreign workers are from the Philippines, Thailand, Colombia, China and Africa. The vast majority work as caregivers for the elderly or physically impaired.
After the second intifada began in 2000, large numbers of permits were issued to bring in foreign workers in agriculture and construction to replace Palestinian workers.
In announcing the decision to halt the deportation orders for the children and their parents, Netanyahu’s office released a statement explaining the administration’s stance on illegal residents generally.
“The never-ending flow of illegal residents into Israel during the last few years has led to a situation whereby the percentage of illegal residents in the country is one of the highest in the world, relative to the local population and the number of employees in the job market,” the statement said. “This fact increases unemployment among Israelis and significantly alters Israel’s internal demographics.”
Harel Kohen, an aide to Yaakov Katz, the lawmaker who heads the Knesset’s committee on foreign workers, said that taking a firm line on foreign workers illegally in Israel is about preserving the Jewish character of Israel.
“We need to ensure they do not stay in Israel, otherwise Israel is at risk of having its own people assimilated,” he said. “We could lose our Jewish identity.”
The Interior Ministry says there are some 300,000 illegal migrants and approximately 70,700 legal foreign workers in Israel.
Education Minister Gidon Sa’ar is drafting legislation that would prevent the deportation and imprisonment of minors aged 3 to 18, along with their parents and siblings. Sa’ar also proposes outlining conditions in which permanent-resident status can be granted to children integrated into Israeli life.
Israel’s daily Ha’aretz endorsed such a bill in a recent editorial.
“A nation that has experienced expulsion orders and refugee status is not allowed to expel the children of refugees and turn its back on the distress of children who want to become part of the country,” the editorial said.
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.
Copyright © 2013, Forward Association, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Claims Conference Chief Knew of $57M Holocaust Fraud Probe Earlier 
Top Dog: Who Makes the Best Kosher Hot Dog in America?
Why Do Jews Intermarry at a Much Higher Rate Than Others?
End Orthodox Monopoly on Jewish Marriage in Israel
Boston Bombers Pal Slain in Florida Eyed in 'Jewish' Triple Murder
You've successfully signed up!
Israel's importation of foreign workers had very predictable consequences, given America's experience with slaves, and Europe's with Turks and formerly colonized Algerians, Moroccans, and others. Now it must deal with the consequences in a human way, not simply by mobilizing its "Oz squads".
I hope Israel does not treat immigrants the way the United States does. Our current system is based on the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 (IIRIRA) which has had devastating consequences. For 8 years my boyfriend has been fighting the Feds for the right to stay out of detention and to remain in the only country he has ever known. Mike has lived here legally since he was 2 years old as a Lawful Permanent Resident.
In 1978 when Mike was 18, he was foolish enough to accept a stolen $50 8 track tape deck from his buddy; Because of IIRIRA, in 2001 Mike was retroactively classified (on an expunged misdemeanor) as an aggravated felon for purposes of removal.
IIRIRA was designed to expedite immigrant removal yet Mike's been fighting this thing for 8 years.
DOJ has four government attorneys crafting arguments for the opposition. Mike is a pro se litigant - representing himself. This is like shooting a rabbit with a tommy-gun.
IIRIRA gives extremely broad powers to govt administrators, severely limits judicial review, makes a mockery of the Constitution, wastes a lot of taxpayer dollars and terrorizes its victims. Surely there must be solutions to immigration issues that do not cause suffering.
Many blessings to you and thank you for your coverage, Follow me on twitter @leareiter
Enough with the sob stories.What about the illegals who committ crimes why don't liberals care about the victims.Illegals drive down wages for the low income also.Every nation US,ISRAEL included have a right and duty to control who is in their land.I am sick of pressing one for english two for spanish.Did ISRAEL force foreign workers to have children of course not.Guest workers and illegals are free to take their children back home with them.Since this isn't pc not doubt i will be deleted.
Richard is a bit harsh. He was obviously, like most of us who read The Forward, was born into some privilege (compared to those from Developing Nations) and can comment from a position of comfort. The Israelis themselves like Americans, do not value what is termed pejoratively in Hebrew as "black work" They do not want to accept ultimate responsibility for children born into Israel of non Jewish parents. This is the problem with a Jewish State. I would rather see a more Israeli identity develop that includes ALL people living within the Greenline. The Jewish thing had ended up being a little too akin to the Nuremberg Laws and hence anachronistic.
Grape Nuts why not just allow the palistinian refugees to return and become citizens of ISRAEL. Because what you propose will result in ISRAEL ceasing to be ISRAEL.Africa would make a mad dash for ISRAEL and look how SOUTH AFRICA,RHODESIA turned out.
Unless you subscribe to supernatural thought, nothing lasts forever. At some point Israel may stop being Israel. But sadly this will be Israel's own doing. It has become an avaricious people engaged in promoting cheap foreign labor, land grabs and absconding resources such as water from underground aquifers in the West Bank. There is a reason why many Israelis leave for the West. The state of being in many Western nations is easier to handle. I know this from personal experience.
I have a revolutionary idea. Why don't we encourage them to become Jewish? Or at least let them attend synagogues, as long as they don't say anything which is against Judaism. This concept is very old- it is called Ger Toshav.
Dave,
Some descendants of immigrants to Israel immediately following WWII did not have a Jewish mother. The children were brought up to be thoroughly Israeli in terms of culture and obligations to the State. They do not see it any other way even though they do not practice any religion.
One can encourage the current immigrants to convert but according to which tradition? And how genuine is such a conversion? Children born to immigrants in Israel tend to become very Israeli without Rabbinical engagement.