Speech Reflects Chabad Split

By Jennifer Siegel

Published July 15, 2005, issue of July 15, 2005.

A prominent Chabad-Lubavitch rabbi delivered a speech in Brooklyn this week lambasting his movement’s leadership for not aggressively fighting Israel’s plan to dismantle settlements in Gaza and the northern West Bank.

“When I read that the Lubavitch took a position that we’re not to get involved, it went against everything I know,” said Rabbi Avraham Hecht, 83, at an anti-disengagement event held Sunday night at the Jewish Children’s Museum, located across the street from Chabad’s worldwide headquarters in Brooklyn’s Crown Heights area. “How stupid can these people be? This is deportation, not disengagement. Even the Nazis didn’t do it this way.”

Hecht’s recent speech was part of a program hosted by the Pikuach Nefesh organization, a Lubavitch group that opposes the disengagement. About 60 Chabad rabbis, many of whom had traveled to New York to visit the rebbe’s grave last weekend to mark the 11th anniversary of his death.

Hecht did not endorse violence in response to Israeli policy, although the rabbi suggested it was likely that some settlers would respond with violence. “But,” he said, “do we want that — that one Jew should kill another Jew?”

The rabbi’s pointed criticism of Chabad’s institutional leaders highlighted current tensions within the movement. While opposition to Israel’s disengagement plan is widespread within Chabad, the central leadership — which directs the rabbis who perform outreach around the world — has avoided organizing an official campaign against it.

For an expanded version of this story, visit www.forward.com.



Would you like to receive updates about new stories?






















We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.