The Burdens of Jewish Power
Image by Getty Images
By Jonah Naghi March 14, 2017
When we read the Book of Esther to celebrate Purim, many Jews see it as a classic Jewish story: “they tried to kill us. We won. Lets eat!”
The book of Esther does contain a typical story of Jewish victimhood and Jewish survival: Haman tried to kill the Jews, but then Esther and Mordechai rose up and saved us. However, this is not how the Book of Esther ends. The Book of Esther ends with King Achashverosh giving Mordechai the power to take revenge — and he kills 75,000 people. Indeed, the Book of Esther is not just about Jewish powerlessness, but is in fact about the ethical responsibility of Jewish power.
Time and again, the Jewish narrative has been about victimhood and survival. We rarely talk about the story of our ethical responsibilities when we do have power. Today, we have a sovereign nation, and with the privileges of a nation come the responsibilities of a nation. We now have the power and ethical responsibility to treat all the citizens of the state of Israel equally, including its Arab citizens who make up 20% of Israel’s population. Unfortunately, many Israeli Jews do not see it this way.
A recent poll from Pew Research found that 49% of Israeli Jews agree or strongly agree with expelling or transferring Arabs from Israel. Additionally, roughly 80% of Israeli Jews agree that Jews should receive preferential treatment in Israel.
This neglect comes from the Israeli Jewish mentality that they are still a “minority” trying to survive and thus their needs should be prioritized. As Givat Haviva Institute head Mohammad Darawshe says, the Jews in Israel are a majority who have the mentality of a minority.
Based on my observations when I lived in Israel, the way Israeli Jews see it is that they are living in the one Jewish state, surrounded by 22 Arab states. Looking it at that way, Israeli Jews feel like a minority and allowing the Arabs to live in the one Jewish state alone sounds like a privilege. However, this is a deeply flawed mentality.
Israeli Arabs have a saying: we did not immigrate to Israel; Israel immigrated to us. We are not foreigners; this is our homeland too. Israel’s Arab citizens are not like the Pakistanis in Britain. They are not like the Algerians in France. They are not an immigrant minority. They are an indigenous minority. Thus, living in Israel with their basic civil liberties are not privileges, they are rights. And even though they have their basic civil liberties, such as the right to vote and run in the Knesset, freedom of speech, and free practice of religion, Israel’s Arab citizens are still unequal in many spheres of Israeli society, including socioeconomic status, land ownership, higher education, and the private sector.
This is certainly not to suggest that Zionism and Israel’s foundation as a Jewish state is inherently incompatible with liberalism and democracy. Zionism is a nationalist ideology for the Jewish people, and modern Europe has shown that nationalism and liberal democracy are compatible. Similar to how Israel has a Magen David on its flag, Britain, Australia, New Zealand, Switzerland, Greece, Slovakia, Sweden, Norway, Finland, and Denmark — all of which are considered liberal democracies — have crosses on their flags. Additionally, Germany, Ireland, Finland, Greece, Poland, Hungary, Bulgaria, Slovakia, Slovenia, Croatia, and the Czech Republic –- all also widely considered liberal democracies — have preferential immigration laws for a particular group of people, similar to Israel’s Aliya policy that grants instance citizenship to Jews.
As many nation states in Europe have proven, Israel can be a Jewish nation state while still being a liberal democracy and providing equality for its Arab citizens, but several issues need to be addressed. As Peter Beinart writes in his book The Crisis of Zionism, “Reconciling Zionism and liberal democracy…requires eliminating those inequities that are not inherent in Zionism itself. Being a Jewish state does not require Israel to pursue discriminatory… policies or to spend more on its Jewish citizens than on its Arab ones.”
So when you read or listen to the Megillah of Esther, know that it is not just about Jewish survival and Jewish powerlessness, but also about the ethical responsibilities of Jewish power. From the time King Achashverosh gave Mordechai the power to take revenge to today when we have a nation state, we must recognize our ethical responsibilities when we have power. We are no longer the Jews trying to survive Haman’s wrath; we are now like Mordechai with the power given to him by Achashverosh. We are no longer a powerless minority without a homeland, but indeed a nation of people with power and must take an initiative to integrate Israel’s Arab citizens.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
