What’s up with the anti-Semitic imagery in British cartoons this week?
Labour MP Ed Milliband Image by Getty Images
Two political cartoons published this week in the UK have shown that anti-Semitic imagery is alive and well in the British imagination.
Christian Adams’s drawing for the Evening Standard (the newspaper edited by the former Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osbourne) depicts the new Labour Party Leader, Sir Keir Starmer, welcoming back former Labour leader, Ed Miliband, to his shadow cabinet team.
Miliband, who is Jewish, is drawn in profile, with an over-exaggerated hooked nose while clutching a bacon sandwich. This refers back to the infamous incident when, on the campaign trail, he was photographed eating such a sandwich as a cack-handed attempt to woo the British electorate.
That is a cartoon of Jewish MP Ed Miliband with a hooked nose eating a bacon sandwich and you actually printed that you massive twat https://t.co/BB8tRl6qoj
— Martin Abrams? (@Martin_Abrams) April 7, 2020
Following an outraged response, Adams chose to defend the cartoon by posting a picture of Miliband’s profile with the words, “Dear everyone. Here’s Ed Miliband’s nose. #cartoon #Caricature.”
Dear everyone.
Here’s Ed Miliband’s nose. ?#cartoon #Caricature pic.twitter.com/QmOPUmRNYv— Christian Adams (@Adamstoon1) April 7, 2020
The responses to this tweet were predictably angry. They heavily suggested that Adams was guilty of the sort of anti-Jewish propaganda that one would find in the Nazi publication Der Sturmer.
What was missed, though, is that Miliband, presumably, chose to eat the bacon sandwich surely to show how down-to-earth he is. By consuming this staple of the British breakfast diet, it was meant to convey he was just an ordinary bloke.
However, the stunt backfired and attracted a storm of hilarity. The tabloid newspaper, The Sun, not known for subtlety, plastered it on its front page, together with a slew of porcine-related puns: “Save our Bacon”; “This is the pig’s ear Ed made of a helpless sarnie,” and “Don’t swallow his porkies.”
At the time, British-Jewish commentator, Keith Kahn-Harris, pointed out how The Sun’s reaction had more than “a whiff of antisemitism about it.” He wrote, “There is a long history of taunting Jews by associating them with pigs.” For example, the Judensau, which depicted Jews in an unholy, and often obscene, relationship with a sow.
Of course, Jews are forbidden from consuming pork and even the most ignorant person probably knows this. But perhaps what is less well-known is that the association of a well-known Jewish figure with a pork product continues such anti-Semitic slurs.
At the same time, whether Miliband knew it or not, perhaps his decision to eat the sandwich was motivated by a deep-seated desire to pass, to overcome the hindrances of his Jewish (and hence “foreign” and “not-quite-British”) birth. Much Jewish media from “The Jazz Singer” onward has depicted Jews eating bacon as a means to rebel, to reject their immigrant roots, and to be accepted into the mainstream. In fact, a whole British movie, “Leon the Pig Farmer,” was devoted to this topic.
The second cartoon, by Steve Bell, appeared in The Guardian It shows Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab, who is currently deputizing for hospitalized Prime Minister, Boris Johnson.
Steve Bell on Dominic Raab leading the UK in PM’s absence – cartoon https://t.co/E0p2glU4Cx
— The Guardian (@guardian) April 7, 2020
He is drawn with an oversized pair of horns and a cloven hoof for a hand beneath which runs the tagline, “Greatest Of All Time.”
Like the pig, the association of Raab, whose father was Jewish, with a goat also carries anti-Semitic baggage. An eighteenth-century woodcut, again from Germany, shows Jews riding around on goats (and pigs) with the Devil.
By depicting Raab in this manner, the cartoonist has also given him Satanic connotations, another anti-Semitic accusation with a long history. Jews have been accused of being in league with the Devil or even the Devil incarnate. Through the Middle Ages and early modern period, Jews were demonized as sorcerers and ritual murderers.
The cloven hoof also suggests the deformity of the Jewish body, particularly the foot, rendering them unfit for service as foot soldiers in the infantry of the armies of the newly established nation states of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
Bell’s cartoon, though, has attracted less ire perhaps because the goat connection is less well-known, as is Raab’s Jewish heritage. Or maybe it’s because, unlike bacon, goats are at least kosher.
A message from our Publisher & CEO Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
