BuzzFeed Identifies Alleged ‘Blackmailer’ In Paul Berman Essay

A days-old media mystery appears to have been solved — but plenty of questions remain.

In an article posted Friday, BuzzFeed identified the writer Eric Alterman as the “well-known professor” and “columnist at a liberal magazine” whom Tablet columnist Paul Berman alleged was trying to blackmail him.

Berman wrote Monday that he was the subject of a blackmail campaign by someone who was threatening to release “erotic correspondence” he had exchanged with another person. BuzzFeed identified Alterman as the unnamed subject of Berman’s piece. Alterman, a columnist for The Nation and a professor at Brooklyn College, acknowledged to BuzzFeed that he had emailed Berman, but denied that the emails were meant as blackmail.

“The emails in question were not written for the purpose of ‘blackmail’ as Paul well knows,” Alterman said. “They arose from a deeply personal matter between us. Paul omits all the relevant details because they reflect so poorly on his character.”

Alterman and Berman have known each other for decades, and shared similar politics until the early 2000s.

Contact Josh Nathan-Kazis at or on Twitter, @joshnathankazis.

This story "Buzzfeed: Eric Alterman Is Paul Berman’s ‘Blackmailer’" was written by Josh Nathan-Kazis.

Recommend this article

BuzzFeed Identifies Alleged ‘Blackmailer’ In Paul Berman Essay

Thank you!

This article has been sent!