New York Democratic Candidate Says Israel ‘Is Not A Jewish Democracy’ In Debate

    Democratic congressional candidate Antonio Delgado stunned the crowd when he said during a debate Monday in New York’s Hudson Valley that Israel “is not a Jewish democracy” because of its settlements, the New York Post reported.

    “As currently constructed, you know, Israel is not a Jewish democracy. Those settlements make it so that it can’t be. So, we’ve got to have a two-state solution,” Delgado said.

    Delgado’s opponent, Republican incumbent Rep. John Faso, sounded surprised, according to the Post.

    “Israel is not a democracy? Israel is a strong democracy,” he answered back during the debate in Albany. “It is a vibrant democracy. It has a vibrant free enterprise system. It has a vibrant agricultural system, culture. Israel is a democracy.”

    Delgado said he stood by his statement in a rebuttal.

    “I said it is not a Jewish democracy,” he said. “Meaning that given the fact that we have settlements currently in the region, it is not deemed a nation of Jewish democracy until we deal with the settlements. Until we deal with the settlements we will have that issue.”

    Delgado tried to clarify his remarks in a statement to Jewish Insider: “As I made clear in the debate and in my statements throughout this campaign, I have a deep personal and family connection to the state of Israel. As a member of Congress, I will do everything in my power to ensure it’s security is safeguarded, which is also profoundly in America’s national interest. I am committed to a two-state solution—a Jewish state of Israel and a sovereign Palestinian State—because it is the only way for Israel to fulfill its own aspirations to remain a Jewish democracy for future generations.”

    The race between Delgado and Faso is close — the Wall Street Journal reported on Monday that Faso is in the lead by 1 percentage point.

    “He clearly misspoke, he just screwed up. The Republicans will jump on this,” a Democratic insider told the Post.

    Zionist Organization of America president Mort Klein told the Post that Delgado was “absurdly wrong. Everyone in Israel, including Arabs and Christians,have a right to vote and fully participate in Israeli society including being members of the Knesset.”

    Alyssa Fisher is a news writer at the Forward. Email her at, or follow her on Twitter at @alyssalfisher

    Antonio Delgado: Israel ‘Not A Jewish Democracy’

    Recommend this article

    New York Democratic Candidate Says Israel ‘Is Not A Jewish Democracy’ In Debate

    Thank you!

    This article has been sent!