Skip To Content
Fast Forward

Who deserves to win Super Bowl LVI? Jewish fans weigh in

LOS ANGELES (JTA) — On the surface, there is nothing explicitly Jewish about Super Bowl LVI.

Unlike recent years, there are no Jewish players in the big game. There will be no Ali Marpet blocking for Tom Brady, no Julian Edelman reeling in a remarkable catch from Tom Brady. (It won’t even feature Tom Brady, a rare occasion for the past decade.)

But Sunday’s game between the host Los Angeles Rams and the Cincinnati Bengals still feels Jewish. In part, that’s because the teams represent two of America’s most storied Jewish communities. 

Los Angeles is home to America’s second-largest Jewish population, behind only New York City, and includes the largest enclave of Israelis outside of Israel. Eric Garcetti, who was elected in 2013 and is leaving his post soon to become U.S ambassador to India, is the city’s first Jewish mayor. 

Then there’s Cincinnati, the home of some of the earliest American Jewish institutions.

The American Israelite, the longest-running English-language Jewish newspaper still publishing in the U.S., was founded in Cincinnati in 1854. The first association of American synagogues, the Union of American Hebrew Congregations — which is now the Union for Reform Judaism — formed there in 1873, followed by the first Jewish institute of higher education, Hebrew Union College, which opened in 1875. Before it moved to the East Coast, the popular kosher food producer Manischewitz was founded in Cincinnati.

Today Los Angeles is also home to an HUC campus, making Sunday’s game a rare chance for two partner Jewish academic institutions to heckle each other.

In fact, an ice cream wager hangs in the balance: The losing campus has agreed to send 12 pints of its city’s best ice cream to the victor campus. Cincinnati would send Graeters, while LA would send Wanderlust. Rabbi Jonathan Hecht, dean of Hebrew Union College’s Cincinnati campus, said there is no competition in that department.

“If this thing were to be settled on the quality of the ice cream, Cincinnati has already won!” he said.

Beyond HUC, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reached out to Jewish fans of the two teams to ask a simple question: Why does your team deserve to win? More specifically, what is the Jewish reason your team should hoist the Lombardi Trophy when all the confetti clears at SoFi Stadium?

Here are some of the most impassioned responses, lightly edited for length and clarity.

**Rabbi Jonathan Hecht, ***dean of Hebrew Union College’s Cincinnati campus*

You asked why the Bengals deserve to win? 

Well, that’s easy: Judaism is a religion based on a deep and abiding faith in the coming of the Messiah. We have been waiting years and years, and even though the Messiah might tarry, we still believe that day will come!

The Bengals reflect that hope in a deep and profound way. 

You see, Cincinnati is, perhaps, the place from which the messianic age will begin.

Why not? American Reform Judaism got its start here in 1873 when the Union of American Hebrew Congregations was established in Cincinnati. Hebrew Union College was founded in Cincinnati in 1875. The first woman to become a rabbi in America, Rabbi Sally Priesand, was ordained in Cincinnati in 1972. Cincinnati gave the world machine-manufactured matzah.

So, why shouldn’t the Cincinnati Bengals win the Super Bowl, bringing us one step closer to the messianic age? Why shouldn’t our team’s victory be the event that helps usher in a new era in world history? If not for the world, then at least for the NFL.

The Bengals have come from behind again and again. We have proven to the world that those with courage, hope and faith are rewarded.

LA is a lovely place, and Rams do produce shofarot, but LA fans will no doubt sound the shofar this year to announce that the time of the Cincinnati Bengals has arrived!

**Rabbi Joshua Holo, ***dean of HUC’s Los Angeles campus*

Whence do we know that a “Ram” denotes the messianic age? As it says in the Book of Joshua (20:8): “And across the Jordan… Ramoth in Gilead from the tribe of Gad.” 

Just as Joshua crossed the River Jordan, so too, in 1946 the Rams, first among all sports teams, crossed the River Mississippi, in fulfillment of God’s decree.

Carried back into captivity “by the Rivers of Babylon” (Ps. 137:1), they sat and wept in the city of St. Louis. Do not read the Rivers of “Babylon” but rather the “Mississippi.” 

“St. Louis” is numerically equivalent to “Babylon,” and “Los Angeles” (numerically equivalent to “Zion”) refers to voices of the Ministering Angels who will rejoice upon the high place, the Ramoth, to welcome the returning exiles as though upon the creation of the world.

Jennifer Caplan, assistant professor of philosophy, Towson University

The Bengals are the clear choice for casual Jewish fans looking to root for one of the teams. I give you the following arguments:

  1. Jews understand being an underdog, and the Bengals are the ultimate underdog. They have never won a Super Bowl, and just a year ago had the third worst record in all of football. The Rams, on the other hand, have won the whole enchilada thrice [twice before the NFL merged with the American Football League in 1970], and were in the playoffs two of the last three years, including a trip to the Super Bowl in 2018.
  2. Lunar New Year has brought us into the Year of the Tiger. That, in and of itself, should be taken as a sign, but few groups of people have seen more copies of the Chinese zodiac on restaurant placemats than American Jews.
  3. While Los Angeles has a rich Jewish history, it cannot hold a candle to Cincinnati’s importance to American Judaism. Isaac Mayer Wise himself called Cincinnati a city meant for “bold plans” and “grand schemes.” One could argue that the entire spirit of American Judaism was born on the banks of the Ohio River.
  4. Finally, and perhaps most compellingly, the ram is the sacrificial animal par excellence. When Abraham doesn’t sacrifice Isaac what does he kill instead? A ram. What does God say should cover the Tabernacle? Ram’s skin. What horn becomes a shofar? A ram’s horn. Yes, rams are undeniably important in Jewish life, but since the earliest days of the law they are to be killed, burned, cut up, eaten, and turned into ritual objects. Tigers, on the other hand, do not appear in the Torah but their cousin the lion is the very symbol of Judah, so we can assume tigers would have been a similar symbol of strength. Because Tigers are awesome.

Bruce Phillips, professor of Sociology & Jewish Communal Service, HUC/University of Southern California

For me as a demographer, the Rams are very Jewish because they arrived in LA in 1946, along with 700 new Jewish families. 

When I was growing up, the Rams were the only major league team in the city — more than a decade ahead of the Lakers and Dodgers. Moreover, those teams brought their Minneapolis and Brooklyn references with them. The last trolleys you could dodge in LA were decommissioned shortly after the (Trolley) Dodgers got here and the few lakes we have in LA are small and artificial. 

Of course, the Rams departed for St. Louis in 1995, but there’s a Jewish angle there too. When owner Caroll Rosenbloom died and left the team to his second wife, the non-Jewish Georgia Frontiere, she skedaddled out of town as soon as she could, taking the Rams with her. That move, arguably, was a casualty of intermarriage. 

Welcome home, Rams.

Rabbi Chase Foster, rabbi for engagement and learning, jHUB Cleveland

My beloved Cincinnati Bengals have tormented me and my fellow die-hards for nearly 40 years (31 can be rounded to 40 because I said so) in the Wilderness of Terrible and Close-Enough-To-Give-You-Hope-To-Squash-It Football. 

We wandered through The Lost Decade of the ’90s, Carson Palmer’s deliverance to the operating table by our hated rival, and Andy Dalton’s tenure that feels very King David-esque — red hair and questionable decision making included. 

Today, on the precipice of glory, I have been led to emotions and ethical situations that I know not how to express or easily discern. What is it like to feel pure joy over my sports team? Should I help the guy sitting in front of me at Paul Brown Stadium light his victory cigar despite this clearly being a no-smoking venue? How do I celebrate without becoming That Unbearable Sports Fan at work? Will my Jamarr Chase jersey smell if I wear it every day throughout the playoffs? Does washing said smelly jersey affect the game’s outcome? 

Regardless, I will be preparing for the Super Bowl this Shabbat by learning and reading Exodus 29, in which we sacrifice two rams, one for each half of domination.

**Jeff Fishman, ***founder of JSF Financial and *recognized kosher tailgater

The Rams deserve to win to right a terrible wrong. 

The Rams were previously owned by a wonderful Jewish family, the Rosenblooms. Carroll Rosenbloom, later in life, fell in love with a character named Georgia Frontiere, whom he ultimately married. Soon after they were wed, Carroll mysteriously drowned off the coast of Florida

Within a year, Georgia and her new husband Dominic Frontiere took over the team and fired Carroll’s son, Steve Rosenbloom, as the team president. She then soon decided to take a large fee to relocate the team to St. Louis, where they played for 25 years. 

Sundays in LA were bleak for 25 years as an entire generation suffered with no local football team to support. This unfortunately led to some fans supporting teams from other places, both near and far. In other words, football fans in LA were stranded in exile for 25 years. 

Then, our hero, Stan Kroenke, bought the team and relocated it back to its rightful home in Los Angeles. Kosher tailgates began to thrive again and the LA Jewish population could come together to cheer and celebrate their long beloved Rams!

**Mike Cohen, ***Bengals fan*

Obviously the Bengals deserve to win the Super Bowl as we’ve wandered the football desert for 40(ish) years. It’s our time. 

The post Who deserves to win Super Bowl LVI? Jewish fans weigh in appeared first on Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.

Now more than ever, American Jews need independent news they can trust, with reporting driven by truth, not ideology. We serve you, not any ideological agenda.

At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and the protests on college campuses.

Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.

Make a gift of any size and become a Forward member today. You’ll support our mission to tell the American Jewish story fully and fairly. 

— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO

Join our mission to tell the Jewish story fully and fairly.

Republish This Story

Please read before republishing

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free, unless it originated with JTA, Haaretz or another publication (as indicated on the article) and as long as you follow our guidelines. You must credit the Forward, retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link in Google search.  See our full guidelines for more information, and this guide for detail about canonical URLs.

To republish, copy the HTML by clicking on the yellow button to the right; it includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to the Forward. It does not include images; to avoid copyright violations, you must add them manually, following our guidelines. Please email us at [email protected], subject line “republish,” with any questions or to let us know what stories you’re picking up.

We don't support Internet Explorer

Please use Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Edge to view this site.