Skip To Content

Election Day 2008: Morning Minyan, Midday Polling and Midnight Parties

Jewish Surrogates of a Familial Sort

Abington, Pa. — With their hard-fought congressional contest winding to a close, incumbent Democrat Allyson Schwartz and Republican challenger Marina Kats turned to the same campaign strategy on election day: deploying family members.

As in the presidential contest, it was a match-up between youth and experience. Schwartz, a two-term congresswoman, went with experience in the form of her mother-in-law, Rachel Schwartz, 82, who had traveled to the Philadelphia suburbs from Greenvale on New York’s Long Island. Kats, a Russian-Jewish immigrant to America, deployed youth: her 10-year-old daughter Alexandra.

The two surrogates faced off in the morning at the Meadowbrook School, a polling place that is home turf for the younger Kats, who is in the fifth grade there. They amiably compared notes on their respective candidates.

“Where did Allyson Schwartz go?” asked the younger Kats.

“She left already. She voted. She’s not coming back,” replied the elder Schwartz.

“My mom is coming back,” Kats noted.

“I thought she voted already,” Schwartz said.

“The lines were too long. She’s coming back,” Kats explained.

The two campaigners, each bearing a stack of leaflets, offered a study in contrasting styles. Schwartz, a seasoned campaigner decked out in a T-shirt that said “Allyson Schwartz for Congress,” stood her ground and handed out leaflets to passersby, proudly adding: “That’s my daughter-in-law.”

Kats was energetic, but more easily distracted, taking periodic breaks to pat passing dogs, get a donut, talk to a friend or just walk around.

But Kats made an impression. One voter stopped to tell her, “I voted for your mom because you were very convincing in your arguments.” Kats grinned.

Schwartz shrugged and asked, “How do you compete with someone that age?”

— Anthony Weiss

A Big Morning Minyan

Alexandria, Va. — The weekday morning minyan at Agudas Achim Congregation, a Conservative synagogue here, is usually a pretty small affair with 15 or so regular congregants. Yet the parking lot was packed and Valley Drive and other nearby streets were lined with cars when Lynne and Donald Sandler arrived for the 7 a.m. service.

“The number of cars as we walked up was like the High Holidays,” Lynne Sandler said. “I thought it was a good sign.”

Scott Littky, the congregation’s education director, opened the doors for election officials at 4:40 a.m. Within five minutes a passing motorist stopped to ask him when voting began. By 5:15 a.m., a full 45 minutes before Virginia polling sites opened, the parking lot began to fill in and voters began lining up.

“Most times when I open the building, I’m able to vote and fall back asleep,” Littky said.

  • — Brett Lieberman*

Celebration Time

New York, N.Y. — A rush of energy filled the crowd of hundreds that gathered on election night at the Mansion, a Manhattan club. All eyes darted toward the large CNN screen just moments before the polls closed in California, a state with 55 electoral votes. Some people began counting down the seconds until anchor Wolf Blitzer declared Barack Obama the next president of the United States.

One woman began crying, and others cheered and danced as music blasted and the party really got under way.

“When Obama won Pennsylvania, this huge relief came over me, and I’ve sort of had this feeling of impending victory ever since,” said 21-year-old David Brandwein, a resident of the Greenpoint section of Brooklyn and a first-time voter. “It’s sort of surreal.” As Obama rolled up victories in state after state, the excitement intensified.

Some talked about the president-elect as representing the dawn of a new era, a cultural shift from the divisive politics of the past eight years. Others spoke of a new period of cooperation between Jewish and black communities, which once worked together to usher in the civil rights era.

“Jewish voters are excited about having an African-American president,” 24-year-old Alan Cordova said. “This is a new-generation crowd.”

At Times Square earlier in the evening, John McCain supporters were feeling frustrated as Obama headed toward the 270 electoral votes needed for victory.

Sitting among a group of Barnard College students was Stern College sophomore Sima Horowitz, who comes from an Orthodox Jewish background and is an ardent McCain supporter. Though she was still holding out hope that McCain would win, she confessed that she was nervous.

When asked how she would respond if Obama won, she replied, “I’m going to make aliyah, God willing.”

— Lana Gersten

Two New Voters

New York, N.Y. — Plen Safit, 38, entered a voting booth on Manhattan’s Lower East Side with her 4-year-old son, Yonatan, in tow, and cast her ballot for Barack Obama. It was the first time she had ever voted in an American election.

Safit, who was Dutch, just received American citizenship and described her first voting experience as “fantastic.”

Though she and her husband, a dual American-Israeli citizen, have lived in the United States for 10 years, she only decided to apply for citizenship after the 2004 election, when her frustration mounted over having no way to help John Kerry take the White House.

“I wanted to campaign, but I couldn’t vote,” she said. “It didn’t feel fair.”

Now Safit is teaching her son, who was born in America, to be excited about the political process. She said she talks to Yonatan about how Obama will make the world a safer place.

In mock elections at his school yesterday, Yonatan eagerly recounted how he circled Obama’s name on his card “because my mom likes him,” and piled it with the rest of the cards in his class.

“All my friends choosed Obama except one,” he boasted.

— Lana Gersten

‘Coming Out’ on Election Day

Philadelphia, Pa. — Wearing a “Pennsylvania for Obama” button on his left lapel, a Hebrew “Barack Obama ‘08” button on his right lapel, and a broad grin on his face, Burt Siegel looked like a liberated man.

“I decided if I’m going to come out of the closet for Obama, I’m going to do it in a big way,” said Siegel.

The day before the election, Siegel, 65, retired as executive director of the Philadelphia Jewish Community Relations Council, a job that required him to be strictly nonpartisan. Now, with Election Day as his first day of political freedom, he had come in to volunteer at the Obama headquarters in northeast Philadelphia, where he was dispatching cars to drive elderly voters to the polls. The timing, he said, was not coincidental.

“I really wanted to do whatever I could to help the Obama campaign,” he said. “It wouldn’t have felt right to work today when I could have retired a day before.”

Siegel had worked for 35 years at the JCRC, where he worked closely with Republicans and Democrats and had to keep a low partisan profile. As the executive director for the last dozen years, his political profile was non-existent.

“I chose this career and I loved it,” he said. Even so, “It was frustrating. I came from a very political family. I was politically involved from age 21 when I worked on the Johnson campaign.”

Siegel’s wife, Barbara, hasn’t faced the same constraints. In September she organized an event for older Jewish women, “Bubbes for Barack,” in the Siegels’ living room. But even Barbara chafed at some of the restrictions, such as when Burt told her they couldn’t put up lawn signs.

“She’d say, ‘I live here too. I own half the lawn,’” Siegel recalled, chuckling.

But this weekend, a day early Siegel confessed, they broke the taboo.

“Now our lawn looks like neighborhood headquarters,” Siegel said.

— Anthony Weiss

A Red Outpost in New York

Brooklyn, N.Y. — “We’re the only Americans here,” snapped Bernice Pfugl, bantering in a thick Brooklyn accent as she stood with friends outside the Shorefront Senior Center near Brighton Beach’s fabled boardwalk, a center of the Russian-Jewish émigré community. Not only was Pfugl one of the few non-Russian speakers at the polling place, she was also one of the few Obama supporters.

This is McCain country, one of few such spots in overwhelmingly blue New York City.

Why McCain? Well, he is “experienced,” and Obama “speaks a lot,” Nelly and Michael Bershatskaia explained in Yiddish as they emerged from the polls.

Ilena Gindes, speaking in English with an accent from her native Ukraine, said, “We come from the U.S.S.R., and we know what socialism is, and we don’t want to see it happen again.”

Another voter emerged. His choice? “McCain,” he answered. Why? He tugged his black shirt and muttered “Obama black” before his wife pulled him away.

Betty Leibowitz, a lifelong Democrat, made no bones about her feelings: “Obama has the black masses behind him. McCain is all-American, and Obama is not.”

Pfugl, the Obama supporter, did not let that go unchallenged. “You’re talking nonsense. And what about Sarah Palin?” she shot back as she rolled her eyes.

“Well, Palin’s grandparents are Jewish. I read in the Russian paper that they had found their burial place in Lithuania,” Leibowitz responded.

— Marc Perelman

A Down-to-the-Wire Decision

Los Angeles, Calif. — When Sari Ciment, a 37-year-old mother of four, arrived to cast her vote at Congregation Mogen David in Los Angeles’s heavily Jewish Pico-Robertson district, she still hadn’t decided on a candidate.

“I was changing my mind every day,” Ciment said, while pushing her 2-year-old son, Gideon, in a stroller. “I had to decide who was best for Israel, who was best for our country, security, taxes.”

It wasn’t until she stepped into the booth that she made up her mind, she said, but she declined to say whether her down-to-the-wire vote went to McCain or Obama. Her husband, however, had no problem committing to a candidate.

“I voted for McCain,” said Jason Ciment, 39, owner of a web-design business. He added that he did not attempt to sway his undecided wife toward his position.

“In marriage, you pick your battles,” he quipped.

And while Sari Ciment wouldn’t reveal her vote for president, she added, glancing over at her husband: “I’ll tell him later.”

— Rebecca Spence

A House of Soda, Divided

Montville, N.J. — Steve Sanders and his wife, Margaret, both had concerns about Barack Obama’s commitment to Israel, but that did not mean they would vote the same way. Steve pulled the lever for John McCain, while Margaret went for Obama.

Steve Sanders worried that what he called Obama’s “socialistic” tax plan would endanger the company that his grandfather, a Polish immigrant in the seltzer trade, started in 1925.

Margaret, an attorney who specializes in real-estate law, said that she is “a one-issue voter in this election,” going for Obama because she feared that McCain will stack the Supreme Court with anti-abortion judges.

The Sanderses spoke in the offices of their Sea Breeze syrup factory, where the family produces Bosco Chocolate Syrup and Stewart’s Root Beer. The couple belongs to a Conservative synagogue here, and they say that many of their couple friends were split.

“We’re almost all split in a similar way, with the wives being Democrats and the husbands Republicans,” said Margaret of her friends. Two of their children voted for Obama, but their son Josh, who commutes from Manhattan to Montville every day and is poised to take over the business, was still undecided.

“I think in the end I’ll go for Obama, because McCain’s old and I don’t trust Palin to lead the country,” Josh said. “Obama’s attitude toward Jews and Israel isn’t the best, but Palin’s might be the worst.”

— Marissa Brostoff

A Rough Night

Plymouth Meeting, Pa. — By 9:30 on election night, things were already looking glum at the Plymouth Country Club, as members of the Montgomery County Republican Party hung around the buffet table, munching cheese and roast beef and watching tensely as Fox News announced that Ohio had gone to Obama. It had also become clear that Marina Kats, the party’s congressional candidate, was going to lose.

Judy Davidson, the primary organizer of Jewish McCain outreach in the Philadelphia area, had predicted that this would be one of the primary locations where Republican Jews would gather on election night, but a reporter could locate only one, Pam Levy. Even Kats had not arrived.

Though the networks hadn’t called the election, Levy was already resigned to an Obama victory.

“People will see what they’re going to get now,” Levy said. “People will see what he is.”

She said she was particularly worried about Israel.

“I think that Israel is not going to have as strong support in the U.S. as it used to,” she told the Forward.

Davidson, for her part, said by phone that she was forgoing parties in favor of bed, after a long day of canvassing with a case of lingering pneumonia. Despite her disappointment, she sounded a philosophical note.

“For a Jewish person in any country to say, I’ve been part of the process, is amazing,” she said. “It is a privilege.”

— Anthony Weiss

A House of Worship and Voting

Chicago, Ill. — Only slight adjustments were needed to turn the Lake Shore Synagogue into a polling station. Voting machines were placed in front of old Torah scrolls showcased in the synagogue’s lobby, and kosher catering was brought in for the poll workers.

Located in one of Chicago’s older neighborhoods, the crowd at the polling station was mixed, but Jewish voters seemed to be in the majority. As expected, all agreed that Chicago was Obama-land, at least for the Jewish voters.

“Thank God it’s so. I wouldn’t live in any other place,” said Laura Smith after casting her vote. “Tomorrow I’m going to be a very happy person.”

A number of Chicago Jews have served as Obama’s advocates in the Jewish community, vouching for his support for Israel and his long-standing ties with Jewish activists.

“We know him and know the truth,” Smith said. “He’s a great guy.”

— Nathan Guttman

I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.

Now more than ever, American Jews need independent news they can trust, with reporting driven by truth, not ideology. We serve you, not any ideological agenda.

At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and the protests on college campuses.

Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.

Make a gift of any size and become a Forward member today. You’ll support our mission to tell the American Jewish story fully and fairly. 

— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO

Join our mission to tell the Jewish story fully and fairly.

Republish This Story

Please read before republishing

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free, unless it originated with JTA, Haaretz or another publication (as indicated on the article) and as long as you follow our guidelines. You must credit the Forward, retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link in Google search.  See our full guidelines for more information, and this guide for detail about canonical URLs.

To republish, copy the HTML by clicking on the yellow button to the right; it includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to the Forward. It does not include images; to avoid copyright violations, you must add them manually, following our guidelines. Please email us at [email protected], subject line “republish,” with any questions or to let us know what stories you’re picking up.

We don't support Internet Explorer

Please use Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Edge to view this site.