Majority of Jewish voters open to partial arms embargo on Israel
An Election Day poll showed that American Jews remain strong supporters of liberal policies and Democratic politicians, even as they worry about pro-Palestinian demonstrations
Israeli soldiers patrol along the Israel-Gaza border area in October. A majority of American Jews said they support an offensive weapons embargo against Israel until Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu agrees to an immediate ceasefire in exchange for the release of Israeli hostages. Photo by Getty Images
By Arno Rosenfeld November 7, 2024
More than a year after the Oct. 7 Hamas attack, most American Jews are broadly supportive of Israel but harshly critical of its leadership and prosecution of the war on Gaza, according to an Election Day exit poll released on Thursday, even as they expressed deep concerns about antisemitism related to protests against the war.
Among the notable findings: 62% of Jewish voters would support the United States withholding shipment of some weapons to Israel until Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu agrees to an American proposal for an immediate ceasefire. Ratings for Netanyahu himself hit an all-time low, with 63% of those surveyed saying they had an unfavorable view of him, up from 59% in 2022, and 66% said they would like to see U.S. sanctions against far-right ministers in his cabinet.
The finding on the withholding of weapons is notable because placing any conditions on American aid to Israel has long been a red line for leading Jewish groups including the one that sponsored the poll, J Street. (J Street has recently called for a review of arms shipments, while still opposing any legislative restrictions on aid to Israel.) Antiwar protesters have over the past year called for a full arms embargo; the poll tested a narrower notion, in which defensive weapons like the Iron Dome missile defense system would still be provided but offensive ones like the 2,000-pound bombs used in the Gaza war would not.
Asked about such a partial embargo, 35% said they would strongly support it, and another 26% said they somewhat favored the idea, while 38% were opposed.
The questions were asked of 800 Jewish voters nationwide as part of a biennial election survey conducted by GBAO Strategies on behalf of J Street, the liberal pro-Israel lobby. It found that Vice President Kamala Harris won 71% of the Jewish vote and former President Donald Trump 26%.
While support for Harris dropped from the 77% of Jews who supported President Joe Biden four years ago, according to prior GBAO polls, she maintained the same share of the community’s vote as past Democratic candidates Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton.
“Despite this traumatic year, it didn’t impact political beliefs and values,” said Jim Gerstein, who conducted the survey. “We’re back to a baseline measure of where Democrats perform.”
One major shift was Trump’s support among the Orthodox, which Gerstein said make up about 9% of the Jewish electorate: 86% voted for him this year, the poll found, up from 59% in 2020.
The survey also found that 87% of American Jews believed “opposing Israel’s right to exist” is antisemitic — though 90% said it is possible to be critical of the Israeli government while remaining “pro-Israel.”
The survey also found that “the future of democracy” and abortion were top issues for Jews. Israel and antisemitism ranked lower, but above healthcare, guns and taxation.
On antisemitism, 94% of Jewish voters said that praising the Oct. 7 Hamas terrorist attack on Israel was antisemitic, but 71% said it was not antisemitic to criticize how Israel was conducting the war in Gaza and 59% said that it was not antisemitic to accuse Israel of war crimes.
The poll also included a question about AIPAC’s political endorsements, which included some pro-Israel Republicans who voted against certifying the 2020 election. More than 71% of Jewish voters said they did not approve of this, providing ammunition for J Street’s running feud with the pro-Israel juggernaut and underscoring what Jeremy Ben-Ami, the group’s president, said was evidence that American Jews care about much more than whether a politician backs Israel.
Ben-Ami said the survey’s findings showed widespread opposed to right-wing policies in both the U.S. and Israel. “Both of these movements pose a fundamental threat to democracy, to our freedom, to our rights,” he said at a news conference Thursday.
Pinning down the Jewish vote
On the breakdown of Jewish votes for Harris and Trump, the GBAO survey landed between results that have circulated since Tuesday of two other major exit polls. One commissioned by a consortium of national news outlets polled voters in 10 swing states and found 78% of Jewish voters backing Harris, while a Fox News analysis of the Associated Press VoteCast poll, found 66% support for Harris among Jews.
Both of these polls were broad surveys of Americans that broke out Jews as well as other religious and racial groups. Neither was meant to specifically study American Jews and therefore did not conform to best practices for ensuring that the sample of Jews accurately reflected what is known about the community’s demographics from other studies.
The GBAO poll matched the responses it received from 800 self-identified Jewish voters by denomination and other factors that tend to impact politics, likely making it a more reliable survey. Gerstein noted that while he works for Democratic campaigns, he had consistently touted the quality of his Jewish exit poll even when it showed his candidates performing worse among Jews than other exit polls.
A fourth exit poll conducted by the Honan Strategy Group in Pennsylvania on behalf of two Orthodox Jewish groups claimed to have found that Harris earned only 49% of the Jewish vote in that state and Trump 42%. Maury Litwack, who organized the poll, did not respond to a request for the full results or methodology Thursday, making it impossible to evaluate the quality.
GBAO also did a Pennsylvania survey of 400 Jewish voters, and found 75% of them voting for Harris versus 23% for Trump. The Fox News exit poll analysis said 74% of Jews in the Keystone State backed Harris.
A message from our Publisher & CEO Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
