A Jewish high school student from New Jersey was accused of “bullying” and threatened with expulsion by school administrators for posting anti-Israel Tweets, angering pro-Palestinian groups and free speech advocates.
Bethany Koval, 16 of Fair Lawn, New Jersey, known as Benny to her Twitter followers, was summoned to the principal’s office for posting a series of tweets showing her support for Palestine. Koval is Israeli.
Israel is a terrorist force :(. Gaza bombing of 2014 death toll: 2,104 Palestinians innocents to 66 Israeli soldiers https://t.co/GpI0TtofWs— benny (@bendykoval) December 23, 2015
…the Israeli defense minister decided to not only refuse to prosecute the terrorists, but to claim the family ineligible for compensation.— benny (@bendykoval) December 27, 2015
Gothamist reports that Koval was targeted this week because of a specific tweet in which she expressed happiness for a fellow student unfollowing her. She then told another student she would direct message the name of the girl who unfollowed her. To administrators at Fair Lawn High School, this interaction constituted bullying.
im sooooo glad that pro-Israel girl from my school unfollowed me! I’m so FREE now like….. FUCK ISRAEL FUCK ISRAEL FUCK ISRAEL FUCK ISRAEL— benny (@bendykoval) December 27, 2015
@L_Chevere YOU’RE MY FAVORITE LOCAL. I’M DMING YOU THEIR NAMES RN— benny (@bendykoval) December 26, 2015
Koval recorded her conversation with an administrator and posted it on Twitter, along with a signed statement of apology she says she was forced to write.
Ends with “the state law may interpret it differently”, if you couldn’t hear it. pic.twitter.com/fJsl5ygmsy— benny (@bendykoval) January 6, 2016
Apparently a “smug attitude” is trying not to burst into tears. Do you know how bad a HIB report looks? pic.twitter.com/bqNLUmSc6b— benny (@bendykoval) January 6, 2016
Here he intimidates me into making a statement without legal presence. pic.twitter.com/P9q6zzRPcV— benny (@bendykoval) January 6, 2016
I was denied my right to an attorney. I was forced to make a writer statement, but I begged them to revoke it. pic.twitter.com/izgyLANgMJ— benny (@bendykoval) January 6, 2016
After she posted the recording, her followers began posting tweets with the hashtag #StandWithBenny to show solidarity.
Hope your parents support you @bendykoval. Well done standing against oppression & #Israeli#Apartheid. #istandwithbenny#standwithbenny :)— Ronan O’Dowd (@RonanOD) January 7, 2016
@bendykoval Especially Jews should stand up against oppression! Our history is teaching this.— Aaron Stein (@Jew4Peace) January 7, 2016
One follower, Noelle Holden of Gilbert, Arizona, started a Go Fund Me page to pay for Koval’s potential lawyer fees if she is sued by the school for recording the conversation with the administrator. So far she’s raised over $400.
Got the phone back right away, but the phone was searched. They said if I recorded anything I could be sued. https://t.co/pMlN2jQ07V— benny (@bendykoval) January 6, 2016
Please consider donating to help @bendykoval in case she’s sued. Let’s spread the word about her story. https://t.co/GlhupOlR96— noëlle (@musicaIhoe) January 6, 2016
Koval is an active Twitter user. She’s posted over 20,000 tweets to her 6,500 followers. Koval posts about a wide variety of topics including politics, feminism, abortion, and education. She tweets well into the night and has intricate conversations with her followers.
This is not the first time her tweets attracted attention. Her tweet from January 3 was read on air to presidential candidate Bernie Sanders on The Nightly Show with Larry Wilmore.
I really did just tell my history teacher about this. pic.twitter.com/wBw0uNZhSc— benny (@bendykoval) January 6, 2016
Koval planned to attend school on Thursday but according to her Twitter, she went home early.
Just couldn’t make it through the school day. Too much aggression amongst classmates here. Going home now. I’m safe.— benny (@bendykoval) January 7, 2016
Alexander Shalom, an attorney with the American Civil Liberties’ New Jersey branch, told Gawker the actions taken against Koval constitute “probably the most egregious example” of the state’s bullying law being used to stifle protected political speech.
“The school only has a right to regulate conduct when it has an impact on the orderly operation of the school” he said.
New Jersey Teen Accused of 'Bullying' for Anti-Israel Tweets