Immortal Bloodsucking Opportunists

Books

COURTESY OF KINO INTERNATIONAL

By Laura Hodes

Published October 21, 2009, issue of October 30, 2009.
  • Print
  • Share Share

Angel Time: The Songs of the Seraphim
By Anne Rice
Knopf, 268 pages, $25.95.

Anne Rice declared in 2005 in the Author’s Note to her novel “Christ the Lord” that her return to Catholicism meant she would no longer “write anything that wasn’t for Christ.” She professed no more vampires, since they reflected a “world that didn’t include redemption.” In her new novel, “Angel Time: The Songs of the Seraphim,” then, Rice creates a new hero, one who seeks redemption with the divine aid of an angel and explores another idea from that same Author’s Note: that the sheer miraculousness of Jewish survival is proof to her of God.

Rice wrote: “I stumbled upon a mystery without a solution, a mystery so immense that I gave up trying to find an explanation because the whole mystery defied belief. The mystery was the survival of the Jews. As I sat on the floor of my office surrounded by books about Sumer, Egypt, Rome… I couldn’t understand how these people had endured as the great people who they were. It was this mystery that drew me back to God. It set into motion the idea that there may in fact be God.”

Rice’s phrasing is telling — she writes of the Jews, “the great people who they were,” not “who they are.” In “Angel Time,” one gets the sense of this vision of the Jews as a once great people, a historical specimen, a people from the past — something as otherworldly as a vampire.

The hero of “Angel Time” is a young man, Toby O’Dare. Once a talented musician saving to study the lute, he becomes a hired assassin after his alcoholic mother murders his little brother and sister. After one assassination, Toby enters a dark depression, at which moment the angel Malchiah appears and gives him the chance to seek redemption by coming to the aid of the Jews in England at a time “when the Christmas pageants have ended and a time of troubles for the Jewry has begun.”

Agreeing to the mission, Toby finds himself transported to medieval Norwich from present-day California, dressed as a Dominican monk. His task is to protect the Jewish Fluria and her husband, Meir, from the townspeople’s charge that they have poisoned their daughter and secretly buried her because she dared to attend church with her friend.

Though Rice has forsworn the world of vampires, she hasn’t entirely left it behind. Toby shares many features with vampires: Both are heroic figures whose personal suffering leads them to accept missions in which they are “required” to murder; both are immortal; both survive through the centuries.

This link between Jews and vampires is evident in Rice’s descriptive passages. In “The Vampire Chronicles,” Rice focused with obsessive detail on portraying the beautiful physical appearance of the vampires: “[t]he vampire’s full black hair, the waves that were combed back over the tips of the ears, the curls that barely touched the edge of the white collar.” Here, that sensuous detail comes in Rice’s description of the physical beauty of Jews: Toby’s Jewish girlfriend was a “lovely dark-haired beauty” with “long black hair and dark eyes”; Meir, the young Jewish man in Norwich, “had slender beautiful hands, and a soft dreamy depth to his eyes,” his “high cheekbones appeared to be polished, so tight was his skin.” Now the Jew, not the vampire, is the otherworldly exotica.

Jews substitute for vampires not only in appearance, but also in their performative identity. In “Interview with the Vampire,” the vampire Louis and the child Claudia are led to Theatre des Vampires, where real vampires act as stage vampires. As Ken Gelder writes in “Reading the Vampire,” their performance onstage reveals vampirism as “a mode of representation, a sign of vampirism, a style or posture…. There is no reality or meaning behind vampirism…. But one can still ‘be’ a vampire because — since there is no reality behind it — acting and being collapse into each other.” Being a vampire is a “pose,” then, a posture, something one chooses to be by acting as one.

In “Angel Time,” it is the Jewish religion that is shown to be “a mode of representation,” a posture behind which there is no reality, a simulacrum. Toby’s idea to save Fluria and Meir is to have Luria’s twin sister, Rosa, come to Norwich from France and convince the townspeople that she is the dead Lea. At first the old man, Eli, the Jewish character whose strict morals seem to derive from his faith, denounces their plan. But at the novel’s end, Eli surprisingly steps forward and puts on a performance before the royal court, declaring that his granddaughter Rosa is actually Lea. He theatrically declares: “‘I would know her were there a thousand Rosas to fill this room and say otherwise. I know her voice. I know her as no one with sight could possibly know her. Are you to challenge my gray hairs, my wisdom, my honesty, my honor!’ He at once reached out for Rosa, who went into his arms. He crushed Rosa to his shoulder. ‘Lea,’ he whispered. ‘Lea, my own.’”

According to Rice, it is not faith that saves the Jewish people, it is a Jewish ability to adapt and perform before a believing Christian audience. Eli is not able to save his high morals, his strict adherence to his Jewish code of ethics, but he is able to save the life of his daughter and her husband. In this novel, survival is deemed more worthy for the Jews than redemption. Here, the Jews are the backdrop to Toby’s heroic quest — the vehicle for his redemption, but not the heroes of their own tale. Even though it is actually a Jew in the story who saves the Jews, it is Toby who seeks and achieves redemption.

For Rice, Jews and vampires are crucial mediums for the power of the text; for both, their “immortality” comes from convincing listeners. Rice’s narrators write or are interviewed and parlay Jewish or vampiric representations into their own narrative seductions. In “Angel Time,” Fluria captivatingly tells her story to Toby for four entire chapters, and sounding like a most experienced storyteller, begins with the words, “I will tell you the whole tale, and maybe in the telling we’ll find the decision, because this is no ordinary tragedy we face, and this is no ordinary tale.” In “Interview with the Vampire,” the vampire’s oral story is so seductive that the interviewer longs to become a vampire. Rice is fascinated by immortal illusion makers (and surely hopes her books can likewise convince and survive).

At the novel’s end, Toby returns to the present, where he writes down his personal story and tells of his experience with the angel. He mentions how he researched the “Jews of Norwich,” and confirmed that Meir was a real person, “[but] the sad history of the Jews in England in the Middle Ages soon came to an abrupt finish in 1290 when all Jews were expelled from the island… what I had come to know was that Little Staint William had the distinction of being the first case of a ritual murder attributed to Jews, a charge that would reoccur over and over again throughout the Middle Ages and after.”

Jews here are a mere historical fact. It’s not that Rice is antisemitic, trying to put forth that Jews are vampires. It’s quite clear here that the age-old charge of blood libel against the Jews is a false one. Yet the novel — and by extension, the author — is really concerned not with the fate of the Jews, but with that of Toby’s Christian soul. Fluria may be a powerful story-teller, but Toby gets to write the last word.

Laura Hodes is a writer and lawyer who lives in Chicago and blogs at www.personalpolitic.blogspot.com.


  • Print
  • Share Share

The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.


Comments
Anne Rice Mon. Oct 26, 2009

I want to thank you for writing this substantive and interesting review of my novel, Angel Time. But I have to tell you, I feel you are basically wrong. i do not see the Jews as exotica, or only as part of history, and I don't think the novel speaks in this way either. When Toby returns to in his conversion to "the Maker," I deliberately resist making the imagery of his return Christian. I meant for his return to belief to be evocative for people of all faiths. ---- Also my interest in Jewish history far transcends any one period, and sees no period as exotic or otheworldly. I sought to make the Jewish characters of this story as palpable and surprising as any of the characters in the book; and indeed Toby returns to re-unite with his own Jewish girl friend from his past and to make an amazing discovery, with which he will have to come to terms in future books. Strong family ties save the Medieval Jewish family in this novel from destruction, not just Toby. Indeed without the Jewish patriarch coming to save his daughter and her husband and his granddaughter, Toby's efforts would have been in vain. And Toby could in no way foresee that the Jewish patriarch would save the day. ---- I sought to illuminate a rich period in Jewish history, to give some sense of how complex was the role of Jews in the Middle Ages, and how important were the great Jewish scholars of that age, and how much Christian scholars turned to them. And you left these things unmentioned. I don't think that was entirely fair. Nevertheless I thank you for your interest in this book, and your thoughts on the matter. And I will certainly ponder your criticisms.

Jonathan Miller Tue. Oct 27, 2009

I have read Ms. Rice's book, Angel Time. It was complex. Some of the Jewish characters were positive and evoked sympathy, and others were difficult and perplexing. The same could be said of the Christian characters in the book. The Jews were portrayed as educated, bright and generally well meaning. But sadly, their circumstances, imposed upon them by the Christian majority, made them somewhat powerless, reflecting the reality of Jewish life in England during this time period--and in the novel they were pathetic. The Christians were for the most part brutish and prone to violence, quite a counterpart to the Jews.

2 more thoughts: 1. The losing of the remaining Jewish daughter to Christianity was painful for Jewish readers. It was reminiscent of the Merchant of Venice, and the stereotype of the old religion being shed for the new. 2. I thought the reviewers' use of the term bloodsuckers and the combining of the vampire image with the image of the Jews was--well--out of line. This book should stand on its own, and not be measured against the earlier vampire genre. A book about Jews in the Middle Ages, and Christians too, is a book about Jews in that time, and not today. What else should a reader expect. Calling that out as a criticism is unfair, IMO. There are real anti-Semites in the world. Anne Rice is not one of them, by a long shot.

Yoine Shagal Tue. Oct 27, 2009

It may be impolitic these days to quote from _The Fearless Vampire Killers_, but “Oy, have you got the wrong vampire!”

Jack Tue. Oct 27, 2009

It seems the lady doth protest too much. In her comment, Ms. Rice writes “...my interest in Jewish history far transcends any one period, and sees no period as exotic or otherworldly” but later writes “I sought to illuminate a rich period in Jewish history....” So, other periods of Jewish history were boring!? Or is it that medieval England is sufficiently distant from our modern world to be exotic?

Stu Tue. Oct 27, 2009

So what does the zombie metaphor symbolize?

Eli Tue. Oct 27, 2009

Zombies are a Christian symbol. Jesus, as King of the Zombies, rose from the dead to walk the earth again and his followers have since been spreading the Zombie culture - mindless hunger for brains. Tasty brains.

Stu Wed. Oct 28, 2009

Which must mean that Muslims are moon worshiping, silver bullet (Coors Light?) hating Werewolves. I guess that makes sense.

Jack Wed. Oct 28, 2009

Zombies and werewolves and Jews! Oh my!

Marty Sun. Nov 22, 2009

One has to be careful and not be too much of a "deconstructionist" (even when approaching modern fiction.) I look forward to reading Angel Time and sit in wonder at "The Maker" calling one back out of darkness (I'm certain she'll get the story straight on the Jews eventually.)

I say let's sit back and enjoy the ride back to "redemption" of Anne Rice (too many of us are back seat drivers...).






    Would you like to receive updates about new stories?














    We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

    Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.