It’s five months before my 48-year-old, tree-hugging, hippie sister’s wedding, and my mother and I are in my girlhood bedroom in Wilmington, Del., talking about tradition, family and, most important, bridal wear.
“People ask me what Beth is going to be wearing, but I don’t know,” Mom says, as she smoothes plastic over her mother-of-the-bride outfit — a long black skirt and a white-sequined jacket. “Now I don’t even care if she wears white. These days, even pregnant brides walk down the aisle in white.”
“She’ll have a dress,” I say.
“And what about a veil?” Mom continues, asking me in my capacity as the traditionally observant Jewish daughter. “It seems ridiculous for her to wear one.”
“I’ll check with my local rabbinic sources,” I reply lightly, while surveying Mom in the mirror above my 50-year-old dresser.
Although Mom still retains some of her youthful beauty, I can see that the stress of being a septuagenarian wedding planner is getting to her. Decisions on dresses and veils were a lot easier the last time she planned a daughter’s wedding — mine: white, traditional, 30 years ago.
But a moment later, as she goes on to ask me, “So why do you think they’re finally getting married?” I realize that what Beth will wear for this occasion is not the major pre-nup question weighing on Mom’s mind.
“Oy,” I mutter silently, knowing that she is not merely seeking my explanation as much as a “Sign on the dotted line” commitment from her elder, Modern Orthodox daughter that her younger, free-spirited, pagan daughter is actually, at least in this case, throwing nonconformity to the wind.
Understandably, too, I think, since Beth and her fiancé, Diego, are not the standard, “We’re getting married in middle age for health insurance reasons” couple, but “left-coast” performers and bliss-followers who have generally been allergic to convention. They first met at the 1997 Rainbow Gathering, an annual countercultural event featuring peace, love, music and semi- to full-frontal nudity.
Nine years later, when Beth called to say that Diego had gotten down on one knee and proposed to her at that year’s Rainbow Gathering, the news rocked our family with the force of Jimi Hendrix’s “Purple Haze” at Woodstock. But we quickly moved forward, bypassing Zen-like acceptance and heading straight for “Age of Aquarius” meets “Wonder of Wonders” exuberance — especially after Beth said she wanted an East Coast Jewish wedding, complete with a rabbi, a hupah and a blintz-laden smorgasbord.
Selfishly, perhaps, I was also pleased that I would no longer have to continue fielding Mom’s previous “Is Beth getting married?” line of inquiry, which had been going on for several years — ever since Beth brought Diego home to meet the family and my parents learned that her handsome, ponytailed, mandolin-playing boyfriend, known in Rainbow circles as “King of the Gypsies,” was actually a Jewish boy from the Midwest.
“Is it serious?” Mom would ask, and I’d respond with, “Yes, but don’t buy a dress yet.”
And since Beth and I are good friends as well as sisters, I knew that it was a serious relationship — but I didn’t think we’d actually be shopping for wedding dresses for either a decade’s worth of Rosh Hashanahs or a few dozen Mercury retrogrades.
“They’ll have to wheel me down the aisle if she ever gets married,” Mom, long a proponent of the “It’s not good for people to be alone” philosophy, would declare to me ruefully.
Yet fortunately, 10 years later, Mom is not only fully ambulatory, but also striding confidently through conversations with Kitty the florist and Steve the caterer.
Here in my old bedroom, though, I can sense the layers of emotion in Mom’s voice and realize that I not only can, but want, to ease her anxiety about my sister’s return to her Jewish roots for this major life event. Although I can’t provide a guarantee, I can at least tell her not only what she needs to hear, but also what is, as my late paternal grandmother, Bubbe R., used to say, “the God’s honest truth.”
“They’re getting married for you.” I say. “Diego’s parents are no longer alive, and he really wants a family. And he loves you and Dad.”
Mom nods, seeming satisfied, and 20 weeks and 20 questions later (“Maybe you could get Beth to put on a little blush that day?” Mom asks in one phone call), we all assemble at my parents’ synagogue.
Beth looks gorgeous, shimmering in creamy, San Francisco consignment shop satin. and Mom kvells her way through a crowd that includes hippies, mimes, Hadassah ladies and assorted family.
Before we sit down to sing the Sheva Brachot (seven blessings) as performed at the end of my own wedding in this very same room, I think about the blessings of maturity. Although Beth and Diego could have gone with Plan A and gotten married under the Northern California stars with their neighbor Sunshine as the officiant, they instead chose to let Mom make them this big, fattening Jewish wedding — featuring not only peace, love and music, but also five different flavors of cheesecake.
This is a true gift, I believe, as is my relationship with Mom, which has, like a fine non-Manischewitz type wine, gotten richer and better with age.
“You’ve done good,” I go over to say to her, which is something I unfortunately wasn’t capable of telling her at the end of my own wedding.
“Oh, please,” Mom says. But she is smiling.
Marla Brown Fogelman is a freelance writer living in Silver Spring, Maryland. Her work has appeared in The Washington Post, Moment, and Parents, among other publications.
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.
I am friends with Beth and Diego for many years from Rainbow Gatherings. Beth has always honored her Jewish roots with me, as have Diego. They are awesome shining lights in this world. I'd like to believe that Jerusalem Camp, the Jewish center at Rainbow Gatherings, where beth and Diego give a concert everyyear, had some influence in their embracing their Jewish roots.
It saddens me that of all the myriad things that could be said about Rainbow Gatherings, all you could talk about was nudity. It's like saying that Judaism is about Madoff. It's worse than a distorion. But I guess discomfort with how HaShem created us is still endemic. Remember, HaShem's original intention was to hang out with a bunch of naked vegetarians in a forest.Mazal tov, Beth and Diego! Your ever loving brother, Moish
You've got to be kidding. You read this whole article and that's what you took out of it? This piece was written with a light touch, but, in case you missed it, the author also characterized the Rainbow Gathering as featuring "peace, love, music". She also painted a picture of a loving family, a daughter and son-in-law who married rather traditionally out of love for parents', two sisters who are also "good friends", and family members who, while they might not fully understand each other's life style choice, nonetheless, maintain loving relationships.
I think this last point is what will resonate with many in the Jewish community. Many American Jewish families encompass a variety of traditions, life styles, and religious choices.
Rabbi Geller, please lighten up. This is a beautiful tribute to a family and a story about loving relationships. I think you need to get in touch with your inner sense of humor.
Hey, Rabbi Geller,
If HaShem's original intention was to hang out with a bunch of naked vegetarians in a forest, after seeing a photo of you I can see why he changed his mind.
What a wonderful article. The writer shows that simchas for Jewish families begin with a birth and continue for many years...be they b'nai mitzvah and include thought out serious minded "rain-beau-tiful" Jewish adults who respect tradition and honor parents. Mazel Tov to all involved and for The Forward for putting such a story in its first edition of 2010. A good way to start that year.
I attended this beautiful wedding, and am so happy for the entire family, which has fed the souls of many in our community. But what I found most compelling in this story are the strong family relationships, which mirrors (in many ways) my own. Beth has always been a very strong person who cut her own path, but was patient enough to find the man who (in love) wanted to please her parents, by way of this Jewish wedding. Some force is surely blessing them all!
This is a beautiful article about relationships: sister to sister, mother and daughter (times two), and adult parents as they relate to the man who truly loves their daughter. What is remarkable is the respect and love demonstrated by all of these family members who have chosen very different lifestyles centered around differing views of spirituality. That's what Faith and Lou Brown do: they foster close bonds and create community. I feel incredibly blessed to be a part of their synagogue community, which can more accurately be described as their extended family.
Marla--Your article is sweet and wonderful. I can only imagine how your parents "kvelled". On your sister's part as well as Diego's it demonstrated tremendous "kavod" for your parents and for their Jewish heritage. Keep up the great writing.