Mom! Guess what? I didn’t inherit nothing —
Okay, so maybe I didn’t get your face,
your generosity, your perfect kindness.
That was you in my kitchen this very morning
when Magda refused breakfast (a tad rudely)
and I offered her a nice glass of grapefruit juice
and — it won’t surprise you — she said yes!
Oh lure of the specific! Living poetry!
How you, after dinner, every single night
would offer me a nice piece of fruit
and I would every single night decline.
But you persisted: How about a nectarine?
An apple? A bunch of grapes? A pear? A plum?
And damned if I didn’t take one every time.
—Jacqueline Osherow
There’s a real chance I have it wrong,
the oldest known language written down:
All the songs have already been sung
It sounds apocryphal, but so enticing:
Akkadian? Sumerian? On stone.
There’s a real chance I have it wrong.
Still, it would absolve my noiseless tongue
or at least offer some commiseration
if all the songs have already been sung.
Perhaps it’s why so many bells are rung:
every hour on the hour, a carillon
(I suppose there’s a chance I have it wrong)
helps the air articulate its longing
(The air is longing? I’m not alone? )
for all its songs, already sung.
But why, if I’ve known this all along,
do I keep waiting here, my heart wide open?
There’s a real chance I have it wrong.
All the songs have already been sung.
—Jacqueline Osherow
Jacqueline Osherow’s sixth collection of poems, “Whitethorn,” is forthcoming from Louisiana State University Press in 2011.
The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.