Paul Simon vs. Bob Dylan, Who’s Greater?

As One Releases a New Album and the Other Enters His Eighth Decade, We Compare Incomparables

I Am Just a Poor Boy, Though My Story’s Seldom Told: Paul Simon (right), playing New
Orleans in 2010, and Bob Dylan(left) performing at the 2011 Grammy awards, are iconic American
singer/songwriters who have defined the musical landscape of our time.
Getty Images
I Am Just a Poor Boy, Though My Story’s Seldom Told: Paul Simon (right), playing New Orleans in 2010, and Bob Dylan(left) performing at the 2011 Grammy awards, are iconic American singer/songwriters who have defined the musical landscape of our time.

By David Shasha

Published May 25, 2011, issue of June 03, 2011.
  • Print
  • Share Share

In a recent interview in Rolling Stone magazine Paul Simon remarked that he was miffed by comparisons between him and Bob Dylan:

“He’s telling you the truth and making fun of you at the same time. I sound sincere every time. Rock and roll has a lot to do with image. If that’s not your strength, people find fault with the work.”

This short quotation gets to the crux of a perennial battle between two titans of American music. Dylan remains the central figure among serious rock intellectuals. His sometimes impenetrable and always cryptic work is seen as having a heft and cultural cachet often denied to Simon, whose songs communicate directly to the listener. But, while Dylan seems to scoff at confession and musicology, Simon has worn his heart on his sleeve and taken seriously his musical craft.

In the issue of Rolling Stone dedicated to Dylan’s 70th birthday, a list of his 70 greatest songs is presented, with his signature song, “Like a Rolling Stone,” leading the parade. The difference between Dylan’s most praised songs and those of Simon rests in the profoundly divergent approaches each deploys in dealing with the human condition. Dylan mythologizes, goes meta-critical, while Simon — even in his new CD, “So Beautiful or So What” — makes everything personal and anecdotal. For Simon, “I” refers to Paul Simon the songwriter or similar personae; for Dylan “I,” where it appears, refers to the spirit of the time.

Dylan’s signature song “Like a Rolling Stone” is a cruel taunt that opens the possibility of compassion, but does so by leaving its fictional protagonist at the mercy of the great songwriter. “How does it feel to be on your own?” Dylan sneers, coining the phrase used by Martin Scorsese for his documentary on the singer, “with no direction home /Like a complete unknown.” Dylan’s stock-in-trade is not American humanism, but a form of American nihilism. Sincerity in his poetry is often transformed by anger into scorn, even if that scorn is directed at the privileged. Dylan represents the darker side of the Hippie Generation — the baby boomers who indulgently squandered the gains of the New Deal.

And this point is critical: While Dylan manipulated the protest song movement for his own ends and quickly left when he became a big star, Simon took the idea of humanity seriously. Penetrating character studies like “Richard Cory,” “The Boxer” and “Duncan” were derided by critics, but resonated deeply with many listeners. While Dylan was wrapped in mystical musings, Simon was trying to make sense of the world around him. In classic songs like “Bridge Over Troubled Water” and “America,” he addressed the most intimate and pressing issues in society. From the idealism of the 1960s social movements to the disillusionment of the early 1970s, Simon sought to engage honestly and directly with the personal and political realities of regular Americans.

Simon’s songs were written in the spirit and tradition of the Tin Pan Alley masters he revered. Over the course of time he absorbed many styles that reflect the depth and originality of American and other musical traditions. Beginning with the simplicity of the Dylan-esque folk song, Simon absorbed American, African, Latin American and Reggae influences in a way that showed off world music well before such a thing was mainstream.

Those of us who play guitar know that a Simon song has many strange chords while the standard Dylan song has three simple chords and a melody that varies little from beginning to end. Dylan creates an aura, a mystique, to draw the listener into his world, but once the listener has entered that world, Dylan seems to feel little need to communicate in a direct way. Simon takes the opposite stance: His lyrics are simple and direct. His aim is to bring together song and listener, not in a mystical way, but in an emotional and rational way.

Over the years, Simon has meticulously honed his craft. Legendary for his many drafts of a song, he often spends years working on an album before releasing it. He has released fewer albums than contemporaries of his stature and has not been afraid to embrace the new. The cultural diversity that he has embraced and his profound respect for human experience have led him to produce a truly humanistic oeuvre.

On “So Beautiful” Simon has produced a typically low-key assessment of the current difficulties we face as a society. Its songs touch on themes of life, death, militarism, belief and love — the struggle of living at a time of great uncertainty. The characters in these new songs, as has been the case in his work for many years, are shown in their full complement of human existence. People struggle to earn a living, find peace and contentment and love, try to do what is right and good, and are often stymied by the chains of convention and the depredations of the cruel and greedy.

A typical Simon song is a response to aggression and cruelty: an attempt to empower regular people who are beaten down by the everyday indignities of a crazy world. There are allusions in the new songs to the civil rights movement of the 1960s, to the current financial calamity, to America’s seemingly endless wars and to the dread of life and death. God and religion, too, make their appearance on the CD in a quiet but profound way.

This is the expression of a mature writer seeking to penetrate the tragedies we face as human beings and examine who we are through our fears and frustrations. It is a cry against the cruelties of war and the excruciating tribulations that people face when they lose their bearings. But rather than turn to derision, Simon deals delicately with the human condition and turns critically to the many socio-political forces that look to harm our well-being.

And that is the key to the genius of Paul Simon: the confluence between an honest reckoning with life as we live it in our daily existence and the hard work of creating memorable popular art. Deeply tied to the old Jewish immigrant experience, where children were exhorted to make the most of themselves through study and hard work, Simon’s art questions the meaning of life and seeks answers to the perennial philosophical questions, as it thirsts for new and innovative ways of musical expression.

From the fresh-faced excitement of the early rock music of the 1950s, from doo-wop to Elvis and The Everly Brothers, to the folk music of the early 1960s and the protest of the Counterculture, to the explosion of traditional American styles like gospel, jazz, zydeco and beyond to African mbaqanga and Brazilian fado, Simon’s recordings have vigorously embraced musical forms. This embrace shows he is a restless adventurer who is hungry to learn and explore — eagerly embracing the opportunities his immigrant forbears would have wished for their children.

Simon is a quintessential New York Jew whose compassionate humanity is the very core of his being. While Simon’s simplicity and pathos are often dismissed, his liberal humanism has aged extremely well by comparison with the values of other artists. Dylan, for example, has continued into self-mythology or, with his recent Christmas album, self-parody.

Dylan and Simon are both transcendent cultural figures, but earnest Simon has not allowed himself to lose his empathy. Both are compelling writers who entertain as they teach. They are the last two of this generation of songwriters and we should not take them for granted. Bob Dylan is a man on a never-ending mission. Paul Simon is a man bent on achieving redemption and on sharing with audiences his personal struggles to illuminate profound questions of life and living.

David Shasha has written for the Huffington Post and publishes the weekly newsletter of the Center for Sephardic Heritage in Brooklyn where he is director.

The Jewish Daily Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, The Jewish Daily Forwardrequires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, our spam filter prevents most links and certain key words from being posted and The Jewish Daily Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.

Find us on Facebook!
  •'s Allison Benedikt wrote that Taglit-Birthright Israel is partly to blame for the death of American IDF volunteer Max Steinberg. This is why she's wrong:
  • Israeli soldiers want you to buy them socks. And snacks. And backpacks. And underwear. And pizza. So claim dozens of fundraising campaigns launched by American Jewish and Israeli charities since the start of the current wave of crisis and conflict in Israel and Gaza.
  • The sign reads: “Dogs are allowed in this establishment but Zionists are not under any circumstances.”
  • Is Twitter Israel's new worst enemy?
  • More than 50 former Israeli soldiers have refused to serve in the current ground operation in #Gaza.
  • "My wife and I are both half-Jewish. Both of us very much felt and feel American first and Jewish second. We are currently debating whether we should send our daughter to a Jewish pre-K and kindergarten program or to a public one. Pros? Give her a Jewish community and identity that she could build on throughout her life. Cons? Costs a lot of money; She will enter school with the idea that being Jewish makes her different somehow instead of something that you do after or in addition to regular school. Maybe a Shabbat sing-along would be enough?"
  • Undeterred by the conflict, 24 Jews participated in the first ever Jewish National Fund— JDate singles trip to Israel. Translation: Jews age 30 to 45 travelled to Israel to get it on in the sun, with a side of hummus.
  • "It pains and shocks me to say this, but here goes: My father was right all along. He always told me, as I spouted liberal talking points at the Shabbos table and challenged his hawkish views on Israel and the Palestinians to his unending chagrin, that I would one day change my tune." Have you had a similar experience?
  • "'What’s this, mommy?' she asked, while pulling at the purple sleeve to unwrap this mysterious little gift mom keeps hidden in the inside pocket of her bag. Oh boy, how do I answer?"
  • "I fear that we are witnessing the end of politics in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. I see no possibility for resolution right now. I look into the future and see only a void." What do you think?
  • Not a gazillionaire? Take the "poor door."
  • "We will do what we must to protect our people. We have that right. We are not less deserving of life and quiet than anyone else. No more apologies."
  • "Woody Allen should have quit while he was ahead." Ezra Glinter's review of "Magic in the Moonlight":
  • Jon Stewart responds to his critics: “Look, obviously there are many strong opinions on this. But just merely mentioning Israel or questioning in any way the effectiveness or humanity of Israel’s policies is not the same thing as being pro-Hamas.”
  • "My bat mitzvah party took place in our living room. There were only a few Jewish kids there, and only one from my Sunday school class. She sat in the corner, wearing the right clothes, asking her mom when they could go." The latest in our Promised Lands series — what state should we visit next?
  • from-cache

Would you like to receive updates about new stories?

We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.