Nonprofits Mull Staff Shortages

Study Probes the Dearth of Development Professionals

By Rebecca Spence

Published November 10, 2006, issue of November 10, 2006.
  • Print
  • Share Share

After years of working with some of the most promising organizations in the rapidly expanding field of Jewish nonprofits, the staff at one of America’s largest Jewish family foundations noticed a disturbing trend: While dynamic and creative groups were cropping up everywhere, injecting Jewish communal life with renewed passion and commitment, the people needed to keep those very organizations going — the fund-raisers and development professionals — were in noticeably short supply.

Without talented professionals to refill their coffers, the organizations responsible for revitalizing Jewish life could easily falter, and ultimately fold, professionals at the Charles and Lynn Schusterman Family Foundation concluded.

“We began to think about what we could do as an organization to help create an environment in which there were a greater number of fund-raisers,” said the foundation’s executive director, Sanford Cardin.

So what could they do? Find out what was driving the problem in the first place, said Cardin.

Last winter, the foundation commissioned Amy Sales, a social psychologist who directs the Fisher-Bernstein Institute for Jewish Philanthropy and Leadership at Brandeis University, to conduct a study that would lay out the scope of the problem and attempt to get to the bottom of why so few quality Jewish fund-raisers are to be found.

The result of six months of work by Sales and Nicole Samuel, a research analyst at the institute, is compiled in “Developing the Developers,” a 23-page academic paper — set to be released at an April symposium sponsored by the Schusterman Foundation — that examines the various factors that contribute to the shrinking pool of what are known as “FRD” — fund raising and development — professionals in Jewish or ganizations.

Sales explained the questions that served, in a sense, as her point of departure: “Is it that people aren’t coming into the field? Is it that they aren’t staying in the field? [Or] is it that the field isn’t attracting the best and the brightest?”

The conclusions that the study comes to, said Sales, offer no easy answers.

What the analysis found “didn’t have the simplicity that a problem-solver would hope for,” she said. “The problem is along the entire career path, it’s both recruitment and retention, and it’s at the entry points, mid-points and at the highest levels.”

What this means, Sales explained, is that there is enormous competition at all levels of the profession, and Jewish nonprofits aren’t just competing with other Jewish groups. The dearth of quality fund-raisers, she said, is endemic to the entire field of nonprofit organizations. As a result, the study found, organizations like B’nai B’rith and Hillel are competing with museums, universities and medical charities like the American Cancer Society to garner and retain top development talent. The information is not all new, Sales said, but it is the first time it has all been compiled in one place. Researchers conducted interviews with 13 experts on fund raising; reviewed all existing literature on the field published in the past 16 years, and looked at current postings for fund-raising jobs in the Jewish community.

A research assistant in her mid-20s was even tasked with seeking out an entry-level development job. “We almost lost her to one,” Sales said, with a laugh.

Part of the problem, said Sales, derives from the fast-paced proliferation of Jewish non-profits in recent years. Essentially, she explained, the demand for effective fund-raisers has far outpaced the supply. According to the study, between 1990 and 2003, 36 new organizations opened up, while only four closed their doors — an overall increase of 8%.

Moreover, the study found, high demand for development professionals has spawned high turnover rates. And in the Jewish sector, overall job satisfaction is actually lower than in the broader field. A 2005 study cited in the report found that a third of those working at Jewish organizations were open to going to a new organization, and for the most part, they were interested in working in the larger non-Jewish world. In terms of competition with other Jewish groups, nearly half of the development professionals had been offered positions at other Jewish organizations in the past two years.

Another factor in the equation is the disproportionately high number of women working in the nonprofit field. In Jewish organizations, the percentage of women in development jobs reaches up to 80%. But despite this predominance, men still hold two-thirds of the top-ranking fund-raising positions. And in general, women are paid far less for their work than their male counterparts.

But, said Sales, other “feminized” profes- sions like nursing and teaching that have been considered low-status as a result of being dominated by women, have had success with altering perceptions of their field. Fund raising can change its image too, she suggested.

Other solutions to the multi-pronged problem, said Sales, are debatable. While some say that great development professionals can be produced with the right training, others say that it is an innate skill-set that people simply have or don’t have. Sales said she tends to agree with the latter view.

“I came down on the side of saying it’s about finding really good individuals who we can mentor and motivate as opposed to it being about getting people into programs,” she said.

And ultimately, said Sales, no one foundation can tackle the problem on its own. As a result, the Schusterman Foundation is planning to host a conference this spring in New York to publicize the paper’s findings and engage people in a discussion.

“It’s possible,” said Sales, that “foundations and philanthropists could determine in some collaborative way that they want to address the issue.”

Find us on Facebook!
  • "1. Sex. She had it. She liked it. She didn’t make a big deal of it." What were your favorite Elaine moments on Seinfeld?
  • "Mamie Eisenhower had one, and if you came of age during the 1950s, chances are you had one, too. I’m referring to the charm bracelet, that metallic cluster of miniaturized icons that hung from, and often strained, the wrist of every self-respecting, well-dressed woman in postwar America." Do you have charm bracelet memories? Share them with us!
  • How the Gaza War started — and how it can end:
  • This could be the first ancient synagogue mosaic to feature a non-biblical narrative.
  • "Suddenly we heard a siren, but it was very faint. We pulled the kids out of the pool, and then we heard a big boom."
  • Why the bloody onslaught in Gaza is built on politics and lies: Read and share this explosive insight from J.J. Goldberg.
  • The crisis in Israel caught two interns — an Israeli and a Palestinian — far from home. Guess what? They're still friends.
  • The gang's all here!
  • "Neither the 'blood feud' nor the 'honor killing' theory of Abu Khdeir's murder ever made sense — and their manufacture constituted a blood libel against all Palestinians." What do you think?
  • Why hasn't the Zionist Organization of American condemned the revenge killing of Mohammed Abu Khdeir?
  • Why recognize an independent Kurdistan now?
  • So. Many. Nazi. Jokes.
  • Once a symbol of peaceful cohabitation, the Jerusalem light rail is now a prime target for violence.
  • "My wife and I are observant Jews who are heartbroken about the fact that both of our children married non-Jews. My daughter married out first, and is now raising non-Jewish children and grandchildren and even celebrates Christmas. As for my son, he is more observant than my daughter, but still a few years ago I found out he was living with a non-Jewish woman for nine years. She is not a stable woman, emotionally or physically, and now she is pregnant and will not convert. I do not visit my children in their homes, but am pleasant when they visit us. My wife says I need to move on and welcome their partners in our home. So where to from here?"
  • These women have encountered unusual mikveh experiences and survived to tell the tale: "Among them are the adventurous vacationer who battles sharks and surfers to dunk in the freezing waters of the Indian Ocean, the mikveh attendant who is an aspiring opera star, and the late night mikveh goer who gets locked inside."
  • from-cache

Would you like to receive updates about new stories?

We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.