Debbie Hill by the Forward

The secret to their success? “Our coexistence.”

Image by Debbie Hill

This article is adapted from The Branch, a monthly podcast exploring individual relationships between Jews and Arabs, Israelis and Palestinians. The Branch is produced by Hadassah and created by Dina Kraft, a journalist based in Tel Aviv. Sign up here to listen to episodes and be notified when new episodes are published.

As Ali Ottman, the charismatic Arab captain of the Bnei Sakhnin soccer team, plows down the field in his neon green cleats. His friend, Harel Sela, the Jewish assistant coach, observes and takes mental notes on his playing from the sidelines.

Sela, 35, has the lithe build of a professional soccer player he once was himself. He and Ottman and the other players — a mix of Arab and Jewish citizens and some international players — have an easy, friendly rapport.

The coaches and players come together with an especially deep sense of purpose and mission because of all that the team represents, according to Ottman. That coming together, he said, is the key to its power.

“We work as a team. The secret of our success at Sakhnin since we have been playing in the higher leagues is our co-existence,” he said.

The secret to their success? “Our coexistence.”

It’s a pre-season practice game and the team is in high spirits: They played so well last season that they advanced into Israel’s top league. As the most successful Arab team in Israeli soccer, returning to the premier league for them holds special meaning. The team represents not only the city of Sakhnin itself, in the heart of the Galilee, but has come to be a source of pride and identification for Israel’s entire Arab sector, some 20% of the country.

A successful team in Israel’s most popular sport, fans say, helps give them a sense of belonging, of mattering, as minorities in the Jewish state.

As one fan said, winning and winning big “puts them on the map,” with all the layered meanings that expression holds for a country where maps have been at the center of a century’s worth of strife.

The team name Bnei Sakhnin, in Hebrew, as it most often goes by, or Abna Sakhnin, its Arabic name, means “Sons of Sakhnin.” Ottman is just that. The 33-year-old was born and grew up here and has been playing soccer for as long as he can remember. As a young boy he would go to sleep hugging a soccer ball, his parents told him. Bnei Sakhnin was his first love. At the age of 16, he watched on in 2004, electrified, when the team made Israeli soccer history by being the first Arab team to win the state cup.

Ottman, who plays right-back, is a leader who knows how to bring all the team’s players together, commanding respect and a lot of affection, Sela said.

Among Sela’s jobs is to study up on the opposing team’s strengths and weaknesses, so his players are as prepared as possible when they meet on the soccer pitch. Before every game, he sends them videos of the players they will each oppose.

He also fits each player with wearable sports-performance trackers and then analyzes the data points the GPS devices collect, such as their heart rate and how many times they touch the ball in a game.

Sela’s nickname on the team, “Baraka,” which means blessing in Arabic, was given to him by one of the Arab players. He’s bashful about it, but the players credit him for helping the team improve.

Sakhnin does not have the same money, facilities or star players of other teams — it did not even have its own stadium until after it won the 2004 state cup — but it has moxie. That’s fed by a deeply loyal following of fans, including Jewish fans from neighboring towns and villages in the Galilee.

There’s always a big turnout for games at Doha Stadium, named for the capital of Qatar after its government contributed millions of dollars to its building. It’s the only building in Israel built by an Arab country. It was considered a gesture of soft diplomacy between two countries that do not have official ties.

There’s always an especially big turnout there when Bnei Sakhnin plays its rival team, Beitar Jerusalem. Within Beitar’s fanbase are a group associated with the extreme right wing in Israel. They are notorious for their racist chants like “Death to Arabs” against Arab players.

But other Beitar fans have spoken out against them and efforts by the team’s management, including the current owner, to stamp out their behavior has met with some success.

Ottman’s response has been to speak out. “We need to throw racism off the field,” he said. “We are all after all, human beings. We need to appreciate everyone.”

Bnei Sakhnin has played so well in the pre-season that they are now one of the top two teams in the league.

Ottman and Sela say they are laser-focused on the task ahead: winning together.

Dina Kraft is a journalist, editor and educator. Currently based in Tel Aviv she is a correspondent for both Haaretz and The Christian Science Monitor.


Dina Kraft

Dina Kraft

Dina Kraft is a journalist based in Tel Aviv, she writes for The Christian Science Monitor and The Los Angeles Times where she reports on Israeli and Palestinian politics, culture and society. She can be reached at and on Twitter @dinakraft.

The secret to their success? “Our coexistence.”

Your Comments

The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. All readers can browse the comments, and all Forward subscribers can add to the conversation. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, The Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not and will be deleted. Egregious commenters or repeat offenders will be banned from commenting. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, our spam filter prevents most links and certain key words from being posted and the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.

Recommend this article

The secret to their success? “Our coexistence.”

Thank you!

This article has been sent!