A Long Island synagogue’s renovations uncover a massive work of art
At the High Holidays, many Merrick Jewish Centre congregants will get a first look at a forgotten treasure
The sculpture uncovered at the Merrick Jewish Centre in Merrick, New York Photo by Brad Kolodny
The massive mirrored wall in the lobby of the Merrick Jewish Centre struck many in the congregation as outdated. More than 14 feet high from floor to ceiling, and 12 feet wide, it worked for the Long Island synagogue when it was installed about three decades ago. Then it seemed modern, and gave the illusion of a much larger space.
But tastes change, and this spring, the congregation’s leaders, as part of a larger renovation project, decided to take the mirror down.
Behind it was a layer of sheetrock, and behind the sheetrock was a work of art some congregants did not know existed, and others had mostly forgotten.
“I was both stunned to see what we had been concealing for decades and confused as to why we permitted it to happen in the first place,” said synagogue president Howard Tiegel.
What was revealed was a relief sculpture, made primarily out of concrete, divided into 16 prefabricated sections, each depicting a three-dimensional abstract shape or a Jewish symbol.
Gray predominates, but the eight human figures — each posed climbing or reaching — are black or brown. There’s some damage in a few places where studs attached the sculpture to the sheetrock.
As the High Holidays approach, many of the synagogue’s 600 congregants will step into the freshly carpeted and wallpapered lobby, and get a first look at the 62-year-old sculpture.
They will likely wonder about the piece — who created it, and what will happen to it now. The first question is easier to answer.
Art history
At the bottom in the center the work is the creators’ signatures and the date it was made: “Nocito – Schwartz 1960.”
George Nocito was a sculptor and academic who came to prominence in the mid-20th century and specialized in bas relief. He died in 1977.
His partner in the Merrick Jewish Centre project was Bert Schwartz, who died in 1993 and whose kinetic works include “The Dancing Rabbi” and “The Judo Dancers.” One of his bronze sculptures, depicting six heads of President John F. Kennedy, each with a different facial expression, stood in front of a luxury Queens apartment building until Schwartz and residents in 1966 decided it was unsuitable for the site.
“Nocito and Schwartz drew on several 20th century artistic styles — symbolism, expressionism, and cubism – but have created something highly original” at the Merrick Jewish Centre, said Samuel Gruber, an American art and architectural historian who is president of the International Survey of Jewish Monuments, a nonprofit dedicated to conserving historic Jewish sites.
He called the work “unique,” and said it should be preserved. The generation after the generation that installed the sculpture likely found it dated, he said. “But the pendulum swings and there is now much interest and appreciation of the work of midcentury artists.”
Merrick Jewish Centre is just beginning to ponder the future of the artwork, which would be difficult to move. Its leaders plan to reach out to Gruber’s group and the Jewish Historical Society of Long Island for guidance.
Tiegel hopes the piece will be appreciated by the congregation as it was two generations ago.
“This art is part of the nearly 100-year history of our congregation and community and should be seen and restored in the days to come,” he said.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse..
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
