Elon Musk doubted biblical miracles but loves Mel Brooks
Elon Musk in Germany in 2020. Photo by Getty Images
By Benyamin Cohen September 11, 2023
When Elon Musk was growing up in South Africa, his mother would take him to the local Anglican church, where she was a teacher. “It did not go well,” writes historian Walter Isaacson in a highly anticipated new biography of Musk due out on Tuesday.
Musk’s mom, Maye, would share stories from the Bible, and Musk would question each and every one. When he was told the story of the parting of the Red Sea, for example, his response was: “What do you mean, the waters parted? That’s not possible.”
“When she told the story of Jesus feeding the crowd with loaves and fishes, he countered that things cannot materialize out of nothing,” Isaacson writes. Musk also recalled taking Communion, and wondered if eating “the blood and body of Christ” was “a weird metaphor for cannibalism.”
Isaacson adds, “Elon came to believe early on that science could explain things and so there was no need to conjure up a Creator or a deity that would intervene in our lives.”
Isaacson, a professor at Tulane University and the award-winning author of biographies about Steve Jobs, Albert Einstein, Leonardo da Vinci and Benjamin Franklin, shadowed Musk for two years and interviewed his family, friends and adversaries. The Forward obtained a copy of the book ahead of its release. Isaacson declined a request for an interview.
Kanye controversy
The 670-page doorstopper of a book chronicles the life and career of Musk, the world’s richest person, a pioneer who infiltrated challenging industries — electric cars, space travel, rural internet access, solar power — and leapfrogged other companies with transformative advancements. A large section of the book examines his hostile takeover of Twitter, the online platform that now goes by X.
Less than three weeks before Musk officially took over the social media platform in October 2022 and gutted the team that battles misinformation on the site, Kanye West, the rapper and fashion mogul, tweeted that he would be “going death con 3 on the Jewish people.” Twitter banned West, who would spend the remainder of 2022 going on various antisemitic tirades.
Isaacson writes that the saga taught “Musk a series of lessons about the complexity of free speech and the downsides of impulsive policymaking,” adding that, “the issue of content moderation dominated Musk’s first week at Twitter.”
Musk reinstated West’s Twitter account this summer.
Musk and West, who now goes by the moniker Ye, had been friends dating back to at least 2011, when Musk gave a tour of his SpaceX factory to West. The two also attended a 2022 party in Miami to celebrate the release of West’s Donda 2 album. At the party, Musk dialed into a work conference call, and left his phone camera on, “unintentionally allowing” his team to “witness the party in the background.”
Musk and West “had certain traits in common,” Isaacson notes, “including being unfiltered, and they were both thought to be half-crazy, though in Ye’s case that description would eventually seem to be only half-right.”
The book’s index includes sections on “maniacal sense of urgency,” “unrealistic deadlines,” “demon mode,” “impulsivity” and “stress-induced stomach pains.”
ADL a no-show
What you won’t find in the book is a discussion of Musk’s obsession with the Anti-Defamation League. When Musk took over Twitter, in addition to disbanding Twitter’s safety team, he allowed back on neo-Nazis and antisemites. At the time, the ADL called for advertisers to boycott Twitter.
As antisemitic content proliferated on the platform in the ensuing months, the ADL has been at the forefront of reporting such posts and trying to get users banned. Musk characterized these efforts this month as “aggressive” and “trying to kill this platform,” and suggested he would file a $4 billion lawsuit against the ADL, blaming the organization for his company’s financial woes.
But in an MSNBC segment Monday, the Rev. Al Sharpton asked Isaacson about the ADL attacks and the proliferation of hate speech on X.
“I certainly think he’s wrong to be attacking the ADL because that’s not the problem he has with Twitter,” Isaacson told Sharpton. “The problem he has with advertisers is they don’t like being in an environment that you just described, that’s toxic, that has people in it that way, so advertisers have backed off. It’s not the fault of the ADL.”
Musk’s decision to open X to “more free speech” and “more dissenting speech” has resulted in “more speech of people who are on the fringe, and people who can be toxic at times. He’s even sometimes engaged with them,” Isaacson said.
He added: “We shouldn’t amplify those who are the haters. And I hope eventually Linda Yaccarino, who he got to be CEO of X, and himself, they’ll go back to saying, ‘We’ve got to not amplify people who are putting up really toxic and hateful things.'”
A campaign to ban the ADL, led by a far-right activist, flooded Twitter in recent weeks. The ADL said it was “unsurprised yet undeterred” that “trolls have launched a coordinated attack on our organization.” Musk endorsed the effort.
A fan of Mel Brooks, but maybe not of Larry David
On a lighter note, the book also reveals that two of Musk’s favorite movies are Mel Brooks productions: Spaceballs and Young Frankenstein.
Elsewhere in the book, Isaacson recalls the wedding of Ari Emanuel, the Hollywood superagent, where Musk was seated at the same dinner table as Larry David, the Curb Your Enthusiasm creator who officiated the wedding.
“Do you just want to murder kids in schools?” David asked Musk.
“No, no,” Musk responded. “I’m anti-kid murder.”
David explained to Isaacson the background: Musk’s “tweets about voting Republican because Democrats were the party of division and hate were sticking in my craw. Even if Uvalde never happened,” David said, referring to the mass shooting at a school in Texas, “I probably would’ve brought it up, because I was angry and offended.”
Attacks on a Twitter gatekeeper
The book also documents a “barrage of homophobic and antisemitic attacks” on Yoel Roth, an Israeli-born, left-leaning Democrat who headed Twitter’s trust and safety department. Roth tried to warn Musk of the consequences of removing content moderation practices on Twitter, which led to an 80% drop in ads within Musk’s first month of ownership, according to the book.
At first Musk supported Roth’s efforts to stem trolls and bots flooding the platform with racism and antisemitism, but gradually Musk became hostile to Roth’s approach. At some point, Musk tweeted a screenshot of a paragraph from Roth’s University of Pennsylvania doctoral dissertation titled “Gay Data,” suggesting that Roth supports pedophilia. A tabloid then published Roth’s address, which resulted in so many threats that Roth was forced to leave his house and go into hiding. He ultimately sold the property.
____
Forward reporter Beth Harpaz contributed to this story.
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
Now more than ever, American Jews need independent news they can trust, with reporting driven by truth, not ideology. We serve you, not any ideological agenda.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and the protests on college campuses.
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
Make a gift of any size and become a Forward member today. You’ll support our mission to tell the American Jewish story fully and fairly.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
Join our mission to tell the Jewish story fully and fairly.
