We’re Now Locking Our Synagogue’s Doors. It’s Not Because of Linda Sarsour.
Image by Getty Images
It’s a decision I prayed we would never make. We’ve talked about for months. But, at this point, even I won’t argue with it.
From now on, our shul will keep its doors locked at all times. Even during davvening.
A locked door is the last thing a person should find at a synagogue. A locked door is a barrier to prayer. A locked door corrodes our sense of community. A locked door is anathema to the timeless Jewish value of hachnasat orchim – not just “welcoming” guests but, in the Hebrew, literally gathering them in. I am angry that we’ve come to this decision.
But I’m not angry with my board. They have an obligation to protect our community. They are worried about our safety. They are scared.
And rightly so. They read the news. They see what is happening in their country.
They know that last month, in Kentucky, an armed white supremacist named Gregory Bush tried to enter First Baptist Church of Jeffersontown, a predominantly African-American church, during a midweek service — but found the door locked.
He went to a supermarket instead, and killed two black grandparents.
And, of course, they know about the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh. They know that, on Shabbos morning, 11 Jews were slaughtered while davvening — also by a white supremacist.
So you might imagine that, as synagogues all over the country make agonizing decisions about how to protect ourselves, about how to balance our timeless values with the need to feel safe and be safe, we would also be talking about the murderous scourge of white supremacy.
But scanning the headlines of Jewish periodicals like this one, that’s not the conversation you find. In fact, if you didn’t know about the Tree of Life massacre, you might think that the greatest existential threat to the Jewish people was something called the Women’s March. And that it was the leaders of the Women’s March who had killed 11 Jews in prayer.
That is, of course, not the case. My board just made the decision to lock the doors of our shul during davvening times – and, in fact, at all times. But they didn’t do it because of Linda Sarsour. Or because of Tamika Mallory. Or even because of Louis Farrakhan, his obvious sexism, homophobia, and grotesque and venomous Jew-hatred notwithstanding.
They voted to lock our doors because of Pittsburgh. They did it because an armed white supremacist shouted, “All Jews must die!” — and shot up a shul.
Robert Bowers, the Tree of Life murderer, is not a Muslim. He hates Muslims. His social media profile did not quote a surah from the Quran.
It quoted the Book of John. From the Christian bible.
“Jews are the children of Satan (John 8:44),” it read.
This text is used by something called Identity Christians to argue that people of color are “mud people,” Jews are “imposters,” and that white Europeans are the “true chosen people.”
Violent extremists exist in all religious traditions, including Islam and, for that matter, Judaism. But in the United States, the majority of religious extremists who have hunted Jews have been Christian.
In this country, the greatest danger to Jews is not the Womens’ March. The greatest danger to Jews is not Islam. The greatest danger to Jews is Christian white supremacy.
The shooter at Tree of Life synagogue quoted the book of John. The shooter at the Greater Kansas City JCC in 2014 wrote a newsletter, quoting the same text. “Let the blood of our enemies flood the streets, rivers, and fields of the nation, in Holy vengeance and justice,” he declared to his followers. “The Jews are our main and most formidable enemies, brothers and sisters. They are truly the children of Satan, as Christ tells us in St. John 8:44.”
And the shooter at the Los Angeles JCC in 1999 was also an adherent of Identity Christianity, telling the FBI in his confession that he wanted his shooting to be “a wakeup call to America to kill Jews.”
All white. And all Christian.
Our synagogue membership includes many wonderful interfaith families with Christian spouses and parents. I am proud to partner with numerous Christian pastors from a diverse array of denominations. I have taught in their buildings and they have taught in ours.
But they are the first to admit that some of their fellow Christians have given in to the temptation of Jew-hatred. They are the first to admit that there is anti-Semitism in the Christian bible. And they challenge that anti-Semitism in their preaching and teaching.
So why do some Jews and Jewish institutions have trouble doing the same? Why do they focus their attention on Muslims and Islam rather than the people doing American Jews actual physical harm? Is there anti-Semitism among the leaders of the Womens’ March? I have no doubt. There is anti-Semitism among all non-Jews. We live in a culture plagued by anti-Semitism, a culture plagued by racism and misogyny and homophobia.
But it is the anti-Semitism of Christian white supremacy that has consumed Jewish blood in this country. So no, I am not angry with my board for deciding our doors need to be locked. But I am angry that, after a Christian white supremacist committed the bloodiest attack on Jews in American history, we’re fighting about Muslims. I am angry that we are talking about the Women’s March, and refusing to talk about the men whose hate of Jews has put them behind the barrel of a gun.
And I am disappointed that American Jewish leaders are seemingly unwilling to face the truth of the actual danger of extremism in the white Christian world, choosing instead to focus their ire on women of color.
Why is that? Does it feel safer to challenge already-marginalized Muslims than have hard conversations with our Christian neighbors? Does it feel safer to criticize black and brown people than take on white supremacy?
As the rabbi of a shul that now locks its doors, I can tell you that it doesn’t make me feel any safer.
Rabbi Mike Rothbaum is the rabbi of Congregation Beth Elohim of Acton, Massachusetts.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse.
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
