Skip To Content
JEWISH. INDEPENDENT. NONPROFIT.

Support the Forward

Funded by readers like you DonateSubscribe
Back to Opinion

As an Israeli, I cannot describe the disgust I feel about annexation

This is one of many pieces The Forward is running on annexation. Read another point of view here and here.

Israel was established in order to create a safe haven for the Jewish people. I was born here, and this is my home. I fought for my country during the Yom Kippur war, in the battle on Mount Hermon in the Golan Heights. My grandparents settled in this land more than a hundred years ago, with the dream of creating a vibrant and just society. The occupation of the West Bank destroys this dream. The impending annexation will fully shatter it.

Until Palestinians are free, Israel can never be free.

Elie Avidor

Elie Avidor

I often visit Palestinians in the Jordan Valley and in other villages in Area C, the area of the West Bank controlled by Israel. I have seen the way Israeli settlers harass the local Palestinian community. Even worse, the Israeli Civil Administration and the Israeli army rarely defend the Palestinians, instead making their simple lives miserable by adding regulatory pressure and sometimes inflicting violence themselves.

I cannot express the disgust I felt a few weeks ago, standing in front of a large fifty-acre olive grove, in which all of the trees had been uprooted. This was done by a settler from Revava, a settlement that had expanded to the edge of a small Palestinian community called Haris. The owner of the land closest to the settlement, Amjad Sultan, told me that he had been pressured to sell his land to the settlers, but he refused. While Amjad was celebrating the end of a month-long fast during Eid el Fitr, the holiest Muslim holiday, an Israeli excavator uprooted all 200 olive trees in his grove.

It reminded me of how as children we would bring coins from our allowance to school every Friday to donate to planting trees throughout Israel. It is unbearable to think that a Jewish settler could carry out the extreme act of destroying an olive grove in order to put pressure on its owners. And this was before annexation was declared.

After annexation, taking land from Palestinians could turn into a strategy to rid Area C of its Palestinian residents. It’s excruciating to see my country inflict such pain.

Israel refuses to acknowledge the West Bank as an occupied area, even though the land and its people are controlled by the Israeli military and live as victims to the whims of young soldiers, and settlers’ violence. But there can be no dispute about the way Israel treats the Palestinians in the West Bank.

One day, I was sitting with Eid Zakura from Rashash, a Jahalin Bedouin community of some 13 families in the hills above the Jordan Valley. I listened to Eid describe how the settlers, the Israeli Civil Administration and the Israeli army, each in their own way, and together, are putting an end to the Bedouin life the Jahalin have known for centuries. In the past, during the summer when food was scarce, Eid would walk with his herd of goats about five miles from their community so they could graze on the little grass available during those hot months. But now, Israeli settlers, with the help of the army, have limited those regular herd rounds to a mere one mile out.

The army also prevents the Bedouins from getting water from their cisterns, claiming that they are too close to the army base. The army even forbids the Bedouins from collecting rainwater. So the community has to buy water, paying three times the price we pay for water in Tel Aviv.

How can the Bedouin culture survive under such pressure?

And now, Israel plans to move from brutal occupation to outright annexation. For Eid, the worst part of the coming annexation is the unknown. All the open land in the area could be annexed, so he has no idea if he will be able to remain in Rashash, or if he will have to settle in a nearby village, where he and his community would have to give up their history, culture and way of life. It would be a devastating transition.

The map of the planned annexation shows a deliberate attempt to avoid contiguity in the areas controlled by the Palestinians. Major roads that crisscross the West Bank will be accessible only to Israelis, with some additional roads and tunnels planned to connect the scattered Palestinian areas. This is not an effort to solve a conflict between two peoples; instead, it recalls the Bantustans of South Africa: tiny states located within a larger state, and completely dependent on its larger neighbor.

The annexation plan is expected to cover only the land and not the people. Palestinians will not be given Israeli citizenship, equality or basic civil rights. The Israelis will be governed by Israeli law, and the Palestinians will be governed by a still undefined legal system.

This is Apartheid: the complete segregation of two peoples.

As a human being, and a proud Israeli, I cannot accept that this is what the leadership of my country offers the Palestinians as a way forward.

Elie Avidor is a leader of Combatants for Peace, a nonviolent movement working for Peace, freedom and equality in Palestine and Israel. He lives outside Tel Aviv and runs the “Center Group” of Combatants for Peace – the grassroots effort focusing on issues around Jerusalem and Bethlehem areas.

Engage

Republish This Story

Please read before republishing

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free, unless it originated with JTA, Haaretz or another publication (as indicated on the article) and as long as you follow our guidelines. You must credit the Forward, retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link in Google search.  See our full guidelines for more information, and this guide for detail about canonical URLs.

To republish, copy the HTML by clicking on the yellow button to the right; it includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to the Forward. It does not include images; to avoid copyright violations, you must add them manually, following our guidelines. Please email us at [email protected], subject line “republish,” with any questions or to let us know what stories you’re picking up.

We don't support Internet Explorer

Please use Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Edge to view this site.