Jay Michaelson, in his column dated Nov. 28th, slanders Orthodox Jewish organizations for their support of President Elect Trump’s nominee for Secretary of Education — Betsy DeVos — because we dare to support policies promoting “school choice.”
We at OU Advocacy have consistently supported funding for quality public schools; we just think fairness dictates that some resources go to non-public schools as well. In New York City alone, 13% of K-12 students are in non-public schools yet they only receive 1% of the state’s education budget. We don’t believe that supporting school choice and supporting our public schools need to be mutually exclusive.
While Michaelson and I could have a substantive debate about the merits of school choice proposals and the contours of the Establishment Clause, his descent into diatribe suggests he wouldn’t be interested.
Michaelson assails “some foolish Orthodox Jewish organizations,” which I suppose includes the Orthodox Union, calling us “modern-day Esaus exchanging the birthright of American democracy for a bowl of voucher porridge.”
Michaelson seems to believe that a constituency group pursuing its self-interest is un-American, even though the founders describe in the Federalist Papers deliberately setting up a system of government designed to harness precisely such energy in the service of democracy.
Moreover, Michaelson seems to be unable to comprehend that we support school choice not only out of self-interest and a sense of fairness described above, but also on the basis of other principles — including that parents should be empowered to guide their children’s education at that doing so shouldn’t be a privilege only for those with high income.
Nathan J. Diament
OU Advocacy Center
Orthodox Organizations Have a Right to Support Betsy DeVos