Skip To Content

Support the Forward

Funded by readers like you DonateSubscribe
The Schmooze

Why is Beanie Feldstein leaving ‘Funny Girl’ early — and why is Lea Michele taking her place?

Feldstein posted a cryptic statement to Instagram explaining that the producers ‘decided to take the show in a different direction.’

Beanie Feldstein seemed like a good fit for the Broadway revival of “Funny Girl.” If anyone could try to fill the shoes of larger-than-life Jewish stars Fanny Brice and Barbra Streisand, Feldstein, who has made her reputation as a comic actor who is loud about her Judaism, seemed like a good bet.

Unfortunately, the reviews that rolled in were less than glowing. And now, Feldstein is stepping down, two months before she was due to finish in the role. (Lea Michele, of “Glee” fame, is taking her place beginning on Sept. 6; standby Julie Benko will be filling the gap. Jane Lynch, who played Mrs. Brice, will be leaving the show as planned; she will be replaced by Tovah Feldshuh.)

“Once the production decided to take the show in a different direction, I made the extremely difficult decision to step away sooner than anticipated,” Feldstein wrote in a Notes app statement posted to her Instagram account; the comments on the post are closed.

Feldstein did not specify what the show’s new direction is, nor did she share any other details about what led to her decision. Only three weeks ago, she posted excitedly about her return to the show after having COVID-19, noting that she would be performing until Sept. 25.

Admittedly, the star has had a bumpy ride in “Funny Girl.” She missed a string of performances while in COVID quarantine, and the show was only nominated for one Tony Award, which some saw as a snub. 

But it’s hard not to imagine that the real deathblow was the reviews, nearly every single one of which called the actor out for her weak singing voice and lack of maturity

Speculation has run amuck since Feldstein’s announcement. The contrast between Feldstein, who is queer and plump, and Michele, who is classically beautiful — has led to speculation that Feldstein was bullied out of the role for not being enough of a sex symbol.

The real Fanny Brice. Photo by Getty Images

Fanny Brice, it should be noted, was not famed for her looks — in fact, there’s a number in “Funny Girl” called “If a Girl Isn’t Pretty” all about how hard it is to make it in show business as a woman if you’re not a pageant winner. Streisand, known in part for her distinctive nose, is also not exactly a traditional beauty. So it would be doubly ironic for Feldstein to be pushed out for not being a beauty queen, though it would certainly not be the first time in show business that happened.

Michele also was raised Catholic — though her father is a Sephardic Jew — while Feldstein is outspoken about her Jewishness, something that defined both Brice and Streisand.

Still, Feldstein’s personal qualities seem unlikely to be a major factor. The production’s leaders knew who they were casting. And it’s likely Michele was chosen for her experience with the show — she played Fanny Brice on “Glee” — and her powerhouse belting ability more than her looks. (It’s worth mentioning that, as far as physical appearance goes, Feldstein and Michele have been featured on the cover of fashion magazines such as InStyle and Teen Vogue. Both also have star power and devoted fan bases.)

Instead, the problem may just be the show itself. “Funny Girl” is hard to revive, given that its success was largely dependent on Barbra Streisand’s charisma and voice. The story, following a heavily fictionalized version of Fanny Brice’s life and turgid romance with crook and gambler Nick Arnstein, is not the most inherently compelling. Its draw has only waned as memory of its subject, Fanny Brice, has faded along with the Borscht Belt. 

A New York Times piece on the difficulty of reviving the show quoted Barbara Hogenson, the literary agent representing the show’s librettist, on how few producers were willing to pick up the musical. “Having had Barbra Streisand in that role almost froze the musical,” she explained. “People were very cautious because of the possibility of comparison.”

This prediction has come true; while most critics admitted that Feldstein was charming and likable, no one can help but compare her to Streisand. And it’s unlikely that anyone will ever live up to Babs — not even Rachel Barbra Berry.


Republish This Story

Please read before republishing

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free, unless it originated with JTA, Haaretz or another publication (as indicated on the article) and as long as you follow our guidelines. You must credit the Forward, retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link in Google search.  See our full guidelines for more information, and this guide for detail about canonical URLs.

To republish, copy the HTML by clicking on the yellow button to the right; it includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to the Forward. It does not include images; to avoid copyright violations, you must add them manually, following our guidelines. Please email us at [email protected], subject line “republish,” with any questions or to let us know what stories you’re picking up.

We don't support Internet Explorer

Please use Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Edge to view this site.