Skip To Content

Kosher Barbecue Comes to Crown Heights

Photographs courtesy of Izzy’s BBQ Addiction

New York’s got spots for kosher sushi (Butterfish), kosher tapas (Mason & Mug), even kosher deconstructed BLTs (Pardes).

But aside from food trucks like The Wandering Que, fans of kosher barbecue have had no place to call their own.

That’s about to change. Sruli Eidelman, the self-taught pitmaster behind the hugely popular barbecue pop-up Izzy’s BBQ Addiction is about to open the Big Apple’s first stand-alone kosher barbecue joint.

Pitmaster Sruli Eidelman

When it opens this month, his 600-square-foot Crown Heights space — also called Izzy’s — will feature exposed brick, ceiling fans, diner lamps and a massive Smoke-Master 250RFS stainless-steel wood-burning barbecue pit imported all the way from Texas.

“My barbecue is Central Texas-style, seasoned with a salt and black-pepper rub and smoked over oak and fruit woods like apple or cherry,” Eidelman told the Forward. “But one of the cool things about barbecue in New York City is that we don’t come from any traditions. We can do whatever we want, whether it’s smoked brisket or smoked cholent or smoked kugel.”

Indeed, Eidelman’s takes on kashrut will give Izzy’s menu a creative spin unlike any of New York’s growing number of barbecue joints. Among the smoked goodies planned for the menu, according to Eidelman: sliced brisket, his specialty; chicken; turkey breast; lamb ribs and bacon; and house-cured smoked pastrami.

Carefully curated local beers will be on tap — once Eidelman gets his liquor license. “It’s been one of the hardest things about opening this place,” he said. “But nothing’s better than great barbecue and really great beer.”

Izzy’s will join a handful of kosher-barbecue restaurants around the nation capitalizing on the growing popularity of smoked meats. There’s Milt’s in Chicago, whose offerings include fried green tomatoes and brisket chili; Smokey Joe’s in Teaneck, New Jersey, whose specialties incude lean “Southwestern and Tex-Mex”; and Baltimore’s Dougie’s, which has patented its barbecue sauces.

You could call Eidelman the accidental smoker. A meat-loving Orthodox kid weaned on Food Network porn, he came to recognize that “barbecue and bacon were lacking in the kosher market.” His “aha moment” came at one of Ari White’s Wandering Que pop-ups. “I thought, This is amazing. I have to figure out how to get in on this,” Eidelman said.

While he toiled at a building-supply company by day, he bought hunks of brisket and a gas grill for Frankenstein-like barbecue experiments. “They tasted like shoe leather — awful, disgusting,” he said. So he invested in a proper smoker, took classes with White and “practiced on hundreds of briskets.”

After sharing his smoked meats with friends, Eidelman started posting about his brisket online, and Izzy’s Barbecue Addiction was born as a pop-up delivery business. “That’s when I decided I didn’t like my 9-to-5, and I figured this was something I could open people’s eyes to.”

For his brick-and-mortar space, Eidelman scouted Flatbush, Borough Park and Long Island before choosing Crown Heights, Brooklyn, for its “hippie, yuppie, religious mentality” — and, of course, its proximity to densely Orthodox neighborhoods. “I’m Chabad, and I live in Crown Heights,” he said. “And I think people here can appreciate this style of barbecue.”

What’s next? “I’m just focusing on this place now,” Eidelman said. “But eventually, I could see a few stores if I can figure out how to maintain quality. I’m not pitching it to investors yet or anything, but you have to have dreams.”

Watch Izzy’s BBQ Addiction’s Facebook page for the opening date.

Michael Kaminer is a frequent contributor to the Forward.


Republish This Story

Please read before republishing

We’re happy to make this story available to republish for free, unless it originated with JTA, Haaretz or another publication (as indicated on the article) and as long as you follow our guidelines. You must credit the Forward, retain our pixel and preserve our canonical link in Google search.  See our full guidelines for more information, and this guide for detail about canonical URLs.

To republish, copy the HTML by clicking on the yellow button to the right; it includes our tracking pixel, all paragraph styles and hyperlinks, the author byline and credit to the Forward. It does not include images; to avoid copyright violations, you must add them manually, following our guidelines. Please email us at [email protected], subject line “republish,” with any questions or to let us know what stories you’re picking up.

We don't support Internet Explorer

Please use Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Edge to view this site.