Synagogue arson suspect posted satirical antisemitic cartoon on day of the attack
What we know about Stephen Spencer Pittman, who faces federal charges for the attack on Beth Israel Congregation
Surveillance footage shows a suspect pouring gasoline in the Beth israel Congregation in Jackson, Mississippi, on Jan. 10, 2025. Courtesy of FBI
By Louis Keene, Benyamin Cohen and Andy CarvinJanuary 12, 2026
Stephen Spencer Pittman, who has been charged with setting fire to Mississippi’s largest synagogue, recently launched a website promoting “scripture-backed fitness” and shared a satirical cartoon about Jews on Instagram the day of the arson attack.
Pittman, 19, was charged Monday in the Jan. 10 arson of Beth Israel Congregation in Jackson, Miss., which he targeted because it was Jewish and described as a “synagogue of Satan,” according to an FBI affidavit. The affidavit included images of a text message conversation with his father showing Pittman went by his middle name.
St. Joseph Catholic School, Pittman’s alma mater, posted a photo of him in November 2023, with congratulations on his decision to attend Coahama Community College. St. Joe’s, as it’s known, has confirmed that Pittman is the suspect charged in the fire.
Social media accounts appearing to belong to a Spencer Pittman in Madison, Miss., a city about 15 miles north of Jackson, and a website registered to Pittman show a deep interest in Christian evangelism and physical fitness. He regularly posted quotes from the New Testament and images of himself exercising or playing sports.
The website, www.onepurpose.us, is laden with Bible references, including seemingly Judaic ones. Its homepage prominently features the Hebrew tetragrammaton representing God’s name, and calls on young men to transform their lives through a “Temple plan” of exercise and Bible study. It used a Hebrew word, heichal, to refer to sanctuary.
Pittman’s Instagram account took a darker turn in recent days.
Two days ago he reposted an animated video of a woman seeing a Jewish caricature holding moneybags and exclaiming, “A Jew in our backyard!” before pushing the figure into a swimming pool and adding, “You’re getting baptized right now.”
The video is a clip from the animated sitcom Drawn Together, a satire of cartoons and reality television that aired on Comedy Central from 2004-2007. Divorced from context, it loses some of its messaging. The creators of the show, Dave Jesser and Matt Silverstein, are Jewish. The character Princess Clara, attempting to baptize the character in stereotypical Jewish garb, is a sendup of Disney princesses and is an outspoken bigot whose behavior clashes with minority housemates in the show. (Princess Clara is voiced by Jewish actor Tara Strong.)
It was unclear whether Pittman posted the video before or after the arson attack, which occurred Jan. 10 at around 3 a.m.
Before that, most of his posts were about baseball, which he played at Coahoma Community College. It appears from an Instagram post about three weeks ago that Pittman had stopped playing baseball. In a post from Dec. 19, Pittman wrote, “Peace out to the game that made me ascend.”
He was the team’s starting center fielder at the end of last season. The school has deleted Pittman’s page from its website.
Pittman, who is in federal custody, remains hospitalized with burns it’s believed he received as a result of the arson. He was appointed a public defender on Monday, who appeared with him via videoconference for a preliminary hearing. He is expected to be released from the hospital on Wednesday, his lawyer said. The next hearing in the case is scheduled for Jan. 20.
According to WLBT 3, a Jackson-based TV news station, after a federal judge asked Pittman during the hearing if he understood his rights, Pittman responded, “Yes sir. Jesus Christ is Lord.”
Law enforcement is still investigating the attack, and additional charges may be filed. If convicted on the current charges, Pittman could face up to 20 years in prison.
Calls to Pittman’s lawyer and to his family were not returned Monday.
Clarification: This story was updated with context about the cartoon reshared by the suspect.
PJ Grisar contributed reporting.
