Politics v. Defense: Hamas Backfire, Shin Bet Purge by the Forward

Politics v. Defense: Hamas Backfire, Shin Bet Purge

Image by Getty Images

Hamas police on the Gaza-Egypt border, September 2013 / Getty Images

Ideology continues to trump security in the Netanyahu government’s approach to combating terrorism. As Hamas struggles to maintain its November 2012 cease-fire with Israel in the face of increasing rocket fire, mostly by al Qaeda-linked Salafi jihad factions, Israel responds by bombing Hamas facilities.

In addition to jihadis, the secular Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine has been responsible for a small proportion of the rocket fire. The front fired several rockets at the Negev from Gaza earlier in January, including two fired toward Ariel Sharon’s funeral January 13. Israel retaliated January 22 by assassinating a PFLP leader identified as responsible for the rockets, Ahmed Al-Za’anin.

The latest incident began late Thursday, when an unknown group fired a rocket that landed in field outside the Negev town of Netivot. Defense Minister Moshe Yaalon declared Friday morning, as he has donerepeatedlyover the past year, that Israel considers Hamas responsible for all such attacks. The Israeli military retaliated later on Friday by bombing two terrorist installations, a rocket factory in the northern Gaza Strip and a weapons storage facility in the southern strip, that the army later confirmed were both Hamas facilities.

Hamas responded Saturday by withdrawing its rocket prevention units from the field. Initial Israeli responses interpreted the action as Hamas “giving a green light” to stepped up rocket attacks. But by Saturday night, as there had been no further rocket fire, Israeli sources began suggesting that the Hamas troop withdrawal was intended as a message to Israel to direct its fire toward those responsible, rather than punishing Hamas for actions it has been trying to prevent.

During the month of January some 20 rockets were fired at Israel from Gaza, equal the total for the entire preceding 11 months.

The developments come on the heels of a disturbing January 26 report that Prime Minister Netanyahu has been shaking up the hiring and promoting practices at the Shin Bet internal security service in order to create an agency that produces the intelligence he wants. The report, by Haaretz military analyst Amir Oren, says that as a result of the effort, the Shin Bet now has “three out of its four senior officials coming from a religious background and radiating sympathy for a worldview that opposes diplomatic compromise that would involve the evacuation of settlements.”

Oren claims that the shakeup follows Netanyahu’s frustration that he can’t get the IDF’s Military Intelligence Directorate (or MI) to produce the intelligence he needs to fend off Secretary of State John Kerry and justify an attack on Iran. Military Intelligence, like the rest of the military, insists on strict professionalism both in its assessments and in its personnel decisions, unlike the Shin Bet, which is under the prime minister’s personal supervision. Oren writes:

Moreover, Oren reports, the politicization of the service runs deeper into the ranks:

Oren doesn’t say so, but there are two other factors behind the Shin Bet shakeup. One is Bibi’s decision to replace at one time the heads of all three branches of Israeli security, the military, the Mossad foreign intelligence agency and the Shin Bet domestic security service. The incumbents, respectively Gabi Ashkenazi, Meir Dagan and Yuval Diskin, had successfully opposed the prime minister’s efforts to win cabinet approval for an attack on Iran in 2010.

The replacements weren’t much better. In December 2011 Mossad replacement director Tamir Pardo publicly rebutted one of Netanyahu’s main arguments for an Iran attack—something even Dagan hadn’t dared to do while in office—telling a gathering of Israeli diplomats that Iran is “not an existential threat to Israel.” The following April, IDF replacement chief of staff Benny Gantz went one better, telling Haaretz that Iran is led by “very rational people” who won’t necessarily take the risky step of building a nuclear weapon.

The one replacement that has worked out well for Netanyahu is Shin Bet director Yoram Cohen, the first Orthodox Jew ever to head one of Israel’s major security agencies.

A second factor that’s undoubtedly added a sense of urgency to the shakeup is the appearance of all the previous Shin Bet directors in the 2012 documentary film “The Gatekeepers,” attacking the continuing Israeli hold over the West Bank as corrosive to Israeli democracy and urging a two-state solution. Outtakes from the film were used to produce a five-part miniseries on Israeli television in the spring of 2013, letting the ex-directors make their arguments at greater length.

Persons close to the Shin Bet say the experience of working with and against Palestinian activists in the field naturally builds an understanding of Palestinian motives. “You become a sort of leftist,” one of the directors said in the film.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect those of the Forward.


J.J. Goldberg

J.J. Goldberg

J.J. Goldberg is editor emeritus of the Forward, where he served as editor in chief for seven years (2000-2007).

Politics v. Defense: Hamas Backfire, Shin Bet Purge

Your Comments

The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. All readers can browse the comments, and all Forward subscribers can add to the conversation. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, The Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not and will be deleted. Egregious commenters or repeat offenders will be banned from commenting. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, our spam filter prevents most links and certain key words from being posted and the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.

Recommend this article

Politics v. Defense: Hamas Backfire, Shin Bet Purge

Thank you!

This article has been sent!