In Druze Genes, a Look Back at the Distant Past

Researchers Say an Insular Levantine Community Offers a Key To Understanding Ancient Migration Patterns

Secretive Sect: The Druze don’t intermarry, and they don’t discuss their religion with outsiders, but in their genes Israeli scientists have discovered secrets that shed light on an important chapter in human history.
GETTY IMAGES
Secretive Sect: The Druze don’t intermarry, and they don’t discuss their religion with outsiders, but in their genes Israeli scientists have discovered secrets that shed light on an important chapter in human history.

By Nathan Jeffay

Published August 19, 2009, issue of August 28, 2009.
  • Print
  • Share Share

Who knew that Israel’s Druze had been holding a key to understanding an important dimension of human history?

A new examination of the DNA of this small and insular Levantine group — which follows a secret religion and hardly ever intermarries — has brought us one step closer to better understanding how the world’s various populations came to be living where they are.

An international research group led by scientists at the Technion-Israel Institute of Technology released a study last year that found that Israel’s Druze population has a remarkable diversity of mitochondrial DNA, a type of genetic material that is passed down virtually unchanged from mother to daughter.

In most parts of the world, local populations each have a limited variety of mitochondrial DNA. But among Israel’s Druze, who number 120,000, researchers found an unprecedented variety, including strains that are generally found only in specific geographic locations as far flung as the Far East.

“We believe that the Druze are a relic of the population of people who lived here perhaps 10,000 or 15,000 or more years ago — before any of the population groups we know about — and that these people were one of the sources for the people of the planet,” said Dr. Karl Skorecki, a professor of medicine at the Technion who headed the study.

Historians have long believed that the ancestors of much of the world’s population migrated from northeastern Africa. The Middle East is believed to have served as a way station on this original human migration. From there, families and clans migrated to different parts of the world, each taking with them their distinct DNA. This account of migration explains why different kinds of DNA are more or less common in different parts of the world.

What was missing until Skorecki’s research was evidence proving that many of the forms of DNA now found around the world were once concentrated in the vicinity of this “migration station.” Skorecki — who describes himself as an “archaeologist” who “digs” through DNA to discover the past — called the Druze a “genetic sanctuary” of a long-gone age.

Dr. Fuad Basis, one of the report’s co-authors and director of public health services at Haifa’s Rambam Medical Center, used the analogy of a greenhouse to explain the findings. “This shows that the Druze community is, in my opinion, a kind of greenhouse where there are all different types of ‘plants,’ or in our case, DNAs,” said Basis, who is himself Druze.

Basis said that in the future, researchers wanting to study different DNAs may well approach Druze communities instead of conducting international research projects.

Although the researchers took samples almost exclusively from Israeli Druze, Skorecki said he believes that if surveys were conducted in Syria and Lebanon, the other main population centers for the world’s Druze — thought to number 1 million to 1.5 million — the results would be similar.

One reason for Skorecki’s confidence is that, while Druze marry cousins, keeping the bloodline within clans, most clans are transnational, and among them matches are made between cousins of different countries. This means that modern political borders have limited relevance when discussing Druze genetics, as Druze populations from different countries draw on a common gene pool.

The Druze do not discuss their faith and beliefs with outsiders. It is known, however, that they consider their faith to be a non-ritualistic interpretation of the three monotheistic religions — Judaism, Christianity and Islam — and that they venerate various prophets, including Jethro, the father-in-law of Moses.

Skorecki became well known internationally in 1997 when he discovered a patrilineal DNA link between Jews from around the world who claim to be kohanim, or priests. This discovery confirmed that there is truth to the claim that modern-day kohanim are descendants of a single male ancestor. Skorecki’s reputation as one of the leading Jewish population geneticists was cemented in 2006 when he led a team of researchers that found that 40% of Ashkenazic Jews are descended from just four “founding mothers” who lived in Europe 1,000 years ago and were likely of Middle Eastern origin.

As with his research on Jewish origins, Skorecki’s work on the Druze gives credence to an oral tradition. While Jewish oral traditions claim a common origin in the Middle East, Druze oral traditions hold that the Druze come from diverse stock.

While the Druze religion was officially established in the 11th century, oral tradition maintains that the Druze people was in existence many thousands of years before and is composed of remnants of numerous ethnic groups. To the delight of Druze community leaders, who cooperated with Skorecki’s research, the study’s findings are consistent with that understanding of Druze history.

“This teaches us to respect and take seriously oral traditions that religious groups carry and not to treat them lightly as some are tempted to,” Skorecki said.

For Basis, Skorecki’s Druze colleague, the finding was more than academic. “I’m not going to hide it from you that I was scared about the results. If they would have been different, what could I have done? I would have been worried,” Basis said. “Happily, the Druze community was very proud of the results.”

On a more practical level, confirmation of the Druze community’s genetic diversity could help guide counselors who deal with genetic diseases. For some ethnic groups, characterized by a high degree of genetic homogeneity, doctors take a community-wide approach to genetic counseling. For example, screening for Tay-Sachs and other genetic diseases is promoted across Ashkenazic Jewry.

But for the Druze community, which has a diverse genetic makeup and in which marriage tends to be within clans, different clans are vulnerable to different diseases. “This shows that genetic counseling for the Druze should be directed to clans or villages instead of community-wide,” Skorecki said. The findings, he said, are beginning to shape health care provision by Israel’s Ministry of Health.


  • Print
  • Share Share

The Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, the Forward requires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, the Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.


Comments
David Wed. Aug 19, 2009

It's a little disturbing that Israel is taking so much interest in the Jewish, Palestinian -- and now Druze -- genome. Already Jewish fundamentalists have used these results to "prove" that today's Palestinians are really Jews who converted to Islam rather than leave their land, or to defend the connection between Ashkenazi Jews and the Middle East. This study "proves" the opposite -- that the Druze come from numerous elsewheres. What connects all these research interests is the attempted legitimization of Israel as the rightful owner of the land. "Blut und Boden" is exactly what this genetic research is about.

Ryan Wed. Aug 19, 2009

haha David you dont know how wrong you are my friend... Take a look at this documentery please its only 10 minutes long but will show you the truth about your "Israel"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EATEeKJcTA

Miss_X2 Fri. Aug 21, 2009

This article contradicts what is known about mtDNA population genetics as it applies to the Druze. 27% of them are mtDNA haplogroup X, they are not as diverse as it appears from this article. I am of European ancestry and yet my mtDNA matches those from the middle east, including Druze, not Europeans. If you have a need to know about DNA science, please read about it at university websites, not here.

Benjamin Fri. Aug 21, 2009

Politics does not prove or disprove science. The connection between Ashkenazi Jews and the Middle East is defended because it exists, above and beyond political concerns. Is research connecting Native Americans to Asia all about "Blut und Boden"? How about Gypsies to India? Translating a contentious term into German is not enough to render it taboo, I'm afraid. Human beings do have blood and do live on the soil.

Rabih Thu. Aug 27, 2009

As a lebanese Druze myself, I have always wondered about the stories my 99 year old grandmother used to tell.. She called places with biblical /strange names as if they are still modern. She assumed everyone knew what she was talking about.. could that be one of the signs of our ancient origin??

Ramy Fri. Sep 4, 2009

What an interesting article. Being Druze myself this solidifies what we have always been told in our oral history. Fascinating. Thank you.

DruzeRocker Sun. Nov 29, 2009

To Miss_X2:

You forgot the fact the the Druze people are of mixed origins, and not of a single and defined race. The Druze people do exist as a secret community, right from the beginning of creation and before their official exposure/emergence in 1017 A.D. In addition, Druze people also have a European heritage.

Ponto Tue. Jan 5, 2010

I don't care for Skorecki and his research, if that is what it is called.

He is the person who started the most racist and religiously bigoted notion that haplogroup J1 has something to do with Jews and their priestly caste. Jewish men are anywhere from 12% to 19% J1, a real big deal. It means more than 80% of Jewish men don't belong to J1, it is a minority haplogroup among them. As far as the priestly caste of Jewish men is concerned, about 60% of them happen to be J1. Again, big deal. Yemeni men are over 70% J1 of their total population, not just imams or any religious caste among them. Finding J1 in Jewish priestly caste men is just a coincidence, has nothing to do with Jews in particular or priests. The higher percentage in Jews could be due to bottlenecks in Jews with more J1 Jews of the priestly caste surviving to procreate. Lots of explanations. But instead, we have had to endure ravings about mythohistorical figures like Aaron, Abraham and Shem being J1. Come on folks, get a life. Even the Muslims have jumped on the bandwagon, now Muhammad is J1, despite the fact the J2 and E1b1b are reasonably high among Saudi Arabians. The whole thing has gone from a hypothesis based on findings in Jews and Jewish priestly caste to being a liturgy and dogma of truthfulness.

So I think Skorecki is more of a flim flam artist than any credible scientist.






    Would you like to receive updates about new stories?
















    We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

    Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.