From ‘Star Wars’ to Madonna: 11 times shofars showed up outside shul
The instrument, while lacking in versatility, nonetheless makes the odd non-liturgical appearance
Shofar Image by Getty Images
By PJ Grisar September 12, 2023
Being little more than a husk of keratin from the head of a ram, goat 0r antelope, the shofar is not a very versatile instrument.
Because there’s no real mechanism to alter pitch within the hollow horn, the burden is on the blower, who can modulate tones using his or her lips, teeth or tip-of-the tongue. For this reason, the shofar won’t be joining the regular rotation of your average wind section, or seeing extensive use outside of religious ritual, anytime soon. Still, the shofar has popped up in some interesting places over its extensive history. Here are some of the highlights:
In Madonna’s Kabbalah phase
In 2005, Madonna (who by then was sometimes going by Esther), recorded the song “Isaac,” which sampled “Im Nin’alu” a popular Israeli song based on a 17th century Hebrew poem. The six-minute track made for the album Confessions on a Dance Floor seems designed to pander to the club scene in Tel Aviv, but conjures up a bit of the Days of Awe with some unmistakable shofar blasts in the mix. Madonna, a Catholic girl from Michigan, even brought along kabbalist Yitzhak Sinwani to play the calls when she toured the album in 2006. This makes Sinwani maybe the only person in history to have “auxiliary shofar” on his resume.
In the opening notes of West Side Story
On a narrative level, West Side Story looks like one of the most goyische entertainments ever devised by a group of Jews. Puerto Ricans on one side and Polish-Americans on the other. Knife-fighting under an overpass. These are not the typical recreations of nice Jewish kids. But, when you discover its early conception (it was called East Side Story and featured a Maria that was a Holocaust survivor) you can see why Leonard Bernstein, the scion of Orthodox Russian Jews, evoked the tekiah g’dolah before the opening scuffle between the Jets and the Sharks.
On The Howard Stern Show
The King of All Media has had a number of contests on his radio program over the years — most of them ribald. Among the more surprising ones was a segment called “Blow the Shofar” where callers had to identify popular songs played on the ritual instrument. Recently, longtime Stern staff member Benjy Bronk has been heralding his appearances on the Sirius platform with his personal shofar, making himself even more annoying to Stern’s die-hard fan base.
On HBO
Michaela Coel’s “I May Destroy You” is a gutting drama about Black millennial Londoners working through the aftermath of a sexual assault and, as Karen Skinazi argued, the shofar was the perfect instrument to accompany the series’ spirit of reckoning. “The shofar is a call to action,” Skinazi wrote in her piece on the show’s soundtrack, which also features the Shaar Hashomayim choir performing some of the Rosh Hashanah liturgy. “It stirs us out of complacency, the humdrum of daily life where we move from activity to activity without introspection.”
In Space
The Forest Moon of Endor, the nest of an alien queen and the beach-side cities of civilized apes have all featured the drone of the shofar. The instrument’s early origins in film make a bit more sense. Elmer Bernstein, in scoring Cecil B. DeMille’s The 10 Commandments (the second one, with sound), incorporated the bugle calls that would prove handy to Joshua at Jericho. The same sounds that Bernstein recorded reappear as the teddy-bear like Ewok’s calls to battle in Star Wars: Return of the Jedi. Composer Jerry Goldsmith also leveraged his Jewish upbringing, using the shofar in the scores for Alien and Planet of the Apes.
In classical music
Because the shofar is of no small significance in scripture, Christian composers imagining the Second Coming or events in Jesus’ life have used shofar blares in their orchestrations. English composer Edward Elgar (who wrote everyone’s graduation march, “Pomp and Circumstance”) made room for it in his oratorio The Apostles, though the part is usually played by flugelhorn. In Berlioz’s “Requiem Mass,” shofars sound as a way to portend the end of the world. The instrument itself was played by trumpeter Lester Bowie in the Art Ensemble of Chicago.
In the counterculture and queer community
Punk music may, at its core, be about challenging systems and traditions. But that hasn’t stopped Jewish punk outfits from embracing the proto-trumpet of their ancestors. In a piece for the JTA, author Michael Croland detailed how groups like the Brooklyn-based transgender Jewish punk band Schmekel uses the instrument in their subversive songs. Bram Presser, of Australian comedy punk band Yidcore, regularly includes the aged instruments in the group’s music, and is also known to glug some kosher wine through the horn’s mouthpiece. And while the most famous Jewish punk group of all – the Beastie Boys – never featured that old-school shofar sound, rapper Macklemore, who once appeared dressed up as an unwitting antisemitic caricature, played the horn along to the band’s “No Sleep Till Brooklyn” in a video released to promote his 2013 VMA appearance at Brooklyn’s Barclay’s Center. (We’re still not sure why.)
At the Capitol riot?
While Jewish activists have occasionally sounded the ram horn in peaceful protests, militant groups without Jews have co-opted the ritual object themselves. In the lead-up to Jan. 6, a group was seen participating in a “Jericho March,” blowing their horns in protest of the certification of the 2020 election. One woman had smoke of a hazy origin coming out of hers. The horns were also spotted, and heard, on Jan. 6. Note to non-Jews: could you not?
In avant-garde music
Experimental music luminary John Zorn’s Tzadik records released a 2014 album in which Zorn played alto-sax and shofar. But even Zorn’s commitment to the old ram’s horn pales in comparison to that of Alvin Curran, an American born, Rome-based artist who has been on a 30-year crusade to prove the shofar’s worth as a virtuoso instrument. His project, “Shofar” (for which an album, “Shofar Rags” was produced by Zorn’s label) partners the flatulent bursts of his kudu horn with electronic noise, the whir of air-slicing bullroarers and the groan of corrugated cardboard tubes. It’s not exactly easy listening and it may not convince you that the shofar is ready for prime time, but it’s certainly entertaining.
In a jazz giant’s classical cantata for racial harmony
Pianist and composer Dave Brubeck used a shofar call in his 1968 piece The Gates of Justice, which aimed to connect white Jewish and Black Christian communities by drawing from biblical texts, the speeches of Martin Luther King, Jr. and the sounds of Gospel and cantorial music. Brubeck, who was Catholic, wasn’t able to get a shofar player for most performances or even the cantata’s two official recordings, where a French horn was subbed in. But, when Gates of Justice was performed in February 2023 at UCLA, a student trumpet player opened the piece with a shofar from Brubeck’s personal collection.
By a shell (with shoes on)
In a sad (but adorable) moment in 2021’s Marcel the Shell with Shoes On, the titular tiny protagonist plays “Taps” on a piece of spiral macaroni that looks not unlike a Yeminite kudu shofar. Indeed, while Jenny Slate, who voices Marcel and co-wrote the screenplay, is evasive about the friendly hermit crab shell’s yiddishkeit, in an episode of the SmartLess podcast, she was quite direct about his choice of instrument. “In my culture we call that a shofar,” Slate said.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse..
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
