Jewish New Yorkers should be concerned about the monkeypox vaccine rollout
The monkeypox surge is only the latest example of marginalized peoples’ needs being ignored by the government
People wait in line to enter the Chelsea Sexual Health Clinic for a monkeypox vaccine on July 8, 2022 in New York City. Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images
Rena Yehuda Newman July 19, 2022
As I stood outside of a Harlem health clinic, waiting to get a monkeypox vaccine, a Black person approached a registration attendant, asking if he could get an appointment. The attendant told him he needed to register online first.
He’d tried to, he explained, but the website crashed on him at the critical moment of sign-ups, and he didn’t have another hour to keep clicking.
She turned him away as the line of white gay men with appointments grew longer.
That’s how, in predominantly Black and brown Harlem, a queue of white queer men — individuals who worked jobs that allowed them to hit “refresh” for two hours in the middle of a Tuesday — were the only people able to get the shot.
Over social media, the NYC Health Department announced that a small, new batch of monkeypox vaccine appointments would be available online. On July 12, thousands of people logged on to the same (crashing) website at exactly 1 p.m., hoping to get one of the mere 1,250 appointment slots for all of New York City. I spent an hour anxiously refreshing the page to no avail. Luckily, I had a friend on another computer sign me up successfully for a slot — there are currently no monkeypox vaccines available.
In a city that boasts an LGBTQ+ adult population of over 700,000 people, monkeypox vaccination shortcomings are causing alarm during key moments required to stop the spread. As a queer transgender Jew, I feel particularly sensitive to how the state allocates care in relation to bodies, and whose bodies are prioritized by the system to receive care. The monkeypox surge is only the latest example of marginalized peoples’ needs being ignored by the government.
The monkeypox outbreak in the United States is a health crisis that affects everyone, but currently, cases have been spreading fastest among NYC’s queer communities, with gay men at the highest risk of exposure. Monkeypox isn’t a sexually transmitted disease, but it can spread from body contact, exchange of fluids and touching fabrics that have been in contact with an infected person.
New York City was recently allocated 14,500 vaccines — 10% of the national total monkeypox vaccines available, despite having 32% of the country’s cases. The city currently is sponsoring eight pop-up vaccination clinics throughout the five boroughs, but all with extremely limited availability, requiring online sign-ups for appointments.
For New Yorkers, the ways that the city is mishandling monkeypox smack of the same homophobia and fear that haunted the AIDS crisis. When an illness is stigmatized or scapegoated on a particular population, not only is the general public less protected, but inequalities in access to medical care grow even more stark.
In Yom Kippur fashion, who lives and who dies (or becomes seriously ill) is a painfully relevant question — and we cannot afford to treat it as an arbitrary theological thought experiment. All public health officials in the United States should act with an awareness that without specific efforts to get treatment and resources to underserved communities, they’re all going to go to the white and wealthy.
I spend a lot of time thinking about demographics and the ways bodies get sorted by the state. Maybe my Holocaust education started a little too young, but there has always been something vaguely sinister to me about routine scrutinies such as passing through airport security, obtaining a driver’s license and filling out vaccine forms, with checkboxes distilling me into a set of categories. When you are not cisgender, this type of scrutiny and categorization related to one’s body can feel like an echo of the Nazi selections — some bodies being told to go to the left, the others to the right.
It might look just like paperwork, but I often wonder about where the information collected about our bodies goes and how it gets used. It’s no longer a secret that IBM was contracted by the Nazi Party to use its remarkable new information technology to do the work of genocide. With IBM’s punchcards and machines, the Nazis could parse through massive amounts of census data and create lists of Jews for internment, write efficient train schedules, keep track of ghetto statistics and run a fascist war machine with a bureaucratic smoothness the world had never seen.
Systems and algorithms are never neutral. Technology has the ability to connect us to lifesaving information and resources, just as it has the potential to be a tool of great evil. Regardless of conscious intent, it’s often during critical moments like these that the existing prejudices and inequalities in a society magnify, often with deadly results for the most vulnerable.
That’s why it matters that we take a good look at the structures facilitating the issue. After initial COVID-19 vaccine releases crashed every server, we should know better than to contract monkeypox vaccine sign-ups to third-party websites that aren’t prepared for such high volume activity. A lottery or rolling sign-up would’ve been infinitely more equitable, even if imperfect. Vaccine appointments need to be offered during evening hours, too, when those who work during the day can make it.
COVID-19 showed us the truth of the premise at the heart of every justice-based social movement: No one is safe unless we’re all safe. Jewish law teaches us to rebuke our household or our country when wrong’s been done. Jewish history makes that an imperative. Personal responsibility means speaking out against the systems causing damage and doing whatever we can to envision and implement repairs.
Until our cities have learned from the legacy of AIDS and COVID-19, the Jewish taxpayers of America aren’t exempt from demanding more equitable health care for monkeypox vaccines and every public health crisis that comes next.
To contact the author, email editorial@forward.com.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
