Orthodox Concerns on Obama Birth-Control Plan

By JTA

Published June 18, 2012.

The Orthodox Union in formal comments expressed its concerns on pending Obama administration regulations mandating employer-sponsored health plans for contraceptives and sterilization.

The comments filed Monday with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services express concerns over the regulations’ exemption of houses of worship but not other religious entities such as schools, hospitals and social welfare program providers.

“If the First Amendment’s pair of clauses guaranteeing the right of ‘free exercise’ and prohibiting ‘establishment’ of religion stand for anything, they stand for the protection of citizens against government compulsion to act contrary to conscience and for prohibiting government officials from parceling out religious protection subjectively,” the OU said in its comments.

In a news release, OU executive director for public policy Nathan Diament said the “deepest concern” is “the notion that the federal government will create two tiers of religious organizations with each receiving different apportionments of religious liberty protection.”

“We fully appreciate that on this issue, President Obama is trying to delicately balance competing concerns, and that he recognizes the importance of religious liberty and further recognizes the crucial role religious institutions play in American society,” Diament said. “But we respectfully disagree with how the President and the Secretary of HHS have decided to strike the balance. We hope he will change the policy.”

The Orthodox Union raised the matter in a meeting with Obama on June 5, making clear that the Orthodox Jewish objection was not to contraceptives coverage but to government interference in the management of institutions owned by religious groups.

The federal government opens proposed regulations to commentary for a period through publication in the Federal Register.



Would you like to receive updates about new stories?






















We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.