'Suspended for Singing' Teen Falls in Israel TV Talent Show Finale

Golden-Voiced Ophrir Ben-Shetreet Comes Up Short

courtesy of the voice

By Forward Staff

Published March 24, 2013.

The Orthodox teenage girl who was suspended from school for appearing on an Israeli TV talent show lost in the finale of the contest.

Ophrir Ben-Shetreet, whose school punished her for performing in front of men, made it to the last round of ‘The Voice,’ a popular reality talent show.

She lost to Lina Makhoul, an Israeli-Arab of Christian parentage, despite belting out a stellar version of Leonard Cohen’s ‘Halleluyah.’

The 17-year-old senior was said to have violated the halachic prohibition known as kol isha. But many women were outraged that she was punished.

Makhoul, 19, from Acre bested her three competitors in the final and will receive a record contract and a scholarship to attend music school.

On stage during the special on Saturday night, Makhoul said she had been the victim of racism by the general public during the season’s filming, but that she had also received many warm reactions. “But the majority rules, right?” she said to the thousands of audience members, who responded with cheers and applause.

The final was made up of two rounds: The first included singing by the four contenders: Rudy Beinsin, Dana Tzelakh, Ofir Ben Shitrit, and Makhoul, as well as a round of duets with the contenders’ mentors, who were, respectively, Shlomi Brakha and Yuval Banay, Sarit Hadad, Aviv Geffen, and Shlomi Shabat. At the end of the round, two contestants were eliminated.

In round two Makhoul and Ben Shitrit faced off for the prize. Makhoul preformed Leonard Cohen’s “Hallelujah” while Ben Shitrit sang Ishfiut Zmanit’s “Hakaitz Haakharon” (“The Last Summer”).

“Thank you for listening, believing, taking part, and putting the music first,” Makhoul thanked the viewers after her victory was announced.

With Haaretz

For more, go to Haaretz



Would you like to receive updates about new stories?






















We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.