Your guide to the disinformation plaguing the 2020 campaign
An image of the chromosomes of the vinegar fly from the 1919 book “The Physical Basis of Heredity.” Image by Thomas Hunt Morgan
By Molly Boigon October 6, 2020
Welcome to FAHRENHEIT 411, a special newsletter on disinformation and conspiracy theories ahead of the 2020 presidential election. It is produced in partnership with the Institute for Strategic Dialogue, a London-based think tank that studies extremism, and written by Molly Boigon, an investigative reporter at The Forward.
A Wikipedia article about “genetic studies on Jews” was among the most shared links in antisemitic online spaces at the end of September, used to spread disinformation about Jews’ role in the slave trade, Islamophobic tropes and other conspiracy theories, according to ISD.
ISD researchers found that at the end of last month, users in hateful corners of Twitter, Facebook, Reddit and YouTube posted more than 660 times about Jews, and that some users shared the Wikipedia article and pointed to a section that suggests Jewish men and Arab men have shared paternal ancestors.
In one instance, a user reposted the article twice on Twitter on September 24 after first using it to argue that the role of Europeans in perpetuating the slave trade was overstated, since some Jews enslaved Black Americans and, according to the social media users, are not European due to their shared ancestry with Arabs.
A YouTube user posted a video on October 1 that quoted the article in discussing a theory adopted by the Black Hebrew Israelites that Jews are not really descended from the biblical Israelites.
Another post on September 23 did not include a link to the Wikipedia article but discussed its findings claimed that “bestiality” could explain the genealogical similarities between Arabs and Jews.
The posts, according to ISD extremism researcher Ciaran O’Connor, reflect a blend of different types of hatred, including both Islamophobia and antisemitism. Posts attempting to minimize white peoples’ role in the slave trade are also typically white supremacist.
Researchers also highlighted that “it’s the online users who drive the narrative around the article,” since in 2018, a viral Facebook post linked to the article as evidence for why there should be peace between Jewish Israelis and Muslim Palestinians.
The article’s most referenced section discusses studies from the early 1990s and early 2000s that found there was common paternal heritage between Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews and between Israeli Jews and Palestinian Muslim Arabs.
ISD also noted a rise in anti-Muslim disinformation online last week.
Congresswoman Jan Schakowsky Image by Molly Boigon
Rep. Jan Schakowsky, a Democrat from Illinois, circulated draft legislation last week aimed at shoring up rules enforcement at social media companies to prevent hate speech and privacy violations.
Molly Boigon: Why do you think it’s so hard to set ground rules for social-media companies?
Jan Schakowsky: Early on, we wanted to encourage entrepreneurship and we wanted to encourage the development of the whole sector, and so social media companies were set free from liability in many ways. But now we are finding that consumers are feeling anxious about the Internet—whether or not they are in control of their own information, is this going to be a place where violence can be stoked, where extremism has a home.
We want in the legislation that we’ve just sent out as a discussion draft by staff to make sure that the social media platforms and the online marketplaces establish, maintain and make public written terms of service. It’s really a pretty modest idea that any failure to do that would result in what we would call in an unfair and deceptive practice.
Boigon: Is the issue in your mind that the written terms of service are not sufficiently strict, or that they’re not enforced?
Schakowsky: Certainly that they’re not enforced. Most social media companies, I think, have terms of service that, if they were enforced, would certainly improve the environment on the internet. I think that’s an interesting question on whether or not a final bill ought to have some minimum requirements, but right now, in the draft that we have sent out, we have really talked about establishing, maintaining and making public as opposed to evaluating those terms of service.
Boigon: Can you talk a little bit more about why hate speech is an issue of consumer protection?
Schakowsky: We want to empower these regulatory agencies—while in this case it’s the Federal Trade Commission, I’m also interested in the Consumer Product Safety Commission for example—to clarify their authority to act on these issues of extremism and product safety.
We know, and the FBI says, that QAnon actually is engaged in terrorism as a continuing terrorist threat, so this is real. This is not an abstract idea. It can cause real harm. Plus, we have found a situation where the platforms do not take account of products that are brought into this country or made in this country that are dangerous. We want to set some parameters here so that they can’t hide behind a liability shield.
Boigon: What would you say to people who think this type of legislation would be an infringement upon free speech?
Schakowsky: There’s been a lot of complaints from both sides. A major ranking Republican member on my subcommittee said that the real problem is that there’s suppression of speech from the right, and people on the left have said that too. But I think there are some very clear lines that are not going to be hard to draw. There are some very clear cases.
Boigon: What does accountability look like?
Schakowsky: There can be fines. Facebook woke up a little bit from the $5 billion fine that they got [for violating consumer privacy]. Whatever the enforcement mechanisms are, they have to be meaningful to these companies that are so big and making so much money and focusing far less on consumer protection than on profit protection.
DISINFORMATION ROUNDUP
News outlets this week covered increasing disinformation about the legitimacy of mail-in voting. Trump’s Covid-19 diagnosis also generated false stories from both the left and the right. And Donald Trump Jr. may have known in advance about a video accusing Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar of voter fraud. ISD noted the spread of that video in its analysis of anti-Muslim content this week.
Tracing the disinformation campaign on mail-in voter fraud
“We recognized the narrative that Donald Trump starting spreading earlier this year was going to play a significant role in the turnout and legitimacy of the 2020 election.” Read more.
Trump and COVID-19: Facebook, Twitter and YouTube race to contain disinformation about president’s diagnosis
“Fact-checkers have already knocked down the hoax that an airborne command center was readying for an invasion before the announcement. They also debunked another that claim that an episode of “The Simpsons” showed Trump in a coffin.” [Read more(http://click1.e.forward.com/omfsstrzznwdnnvsdklgvdmgptdklltlwgkntrqktwjkw_wgddgwjsz.html).
Project Veritas Video Was a ‘Coordinated Disinformation Campaign,’ Researchers Say
“A deceptive video released on Sunday… which claimed through unidentified sources and with no verifiable evidence that Rep. Ilhan Omar’s campaign had collected ballots illegally, was probably part of a coordinated disinformation effort, according to researchers at Stanford University and the University of Washington.” Read more.
The Forward’s coverage of disinformation and conspiracy theories
We wrote about the Proud Boys taking President Trump’s “stand by” comment at the debate as a “call to action,” a Proud Boys chapter in Israel and a report from the Anti-Defamation League that found that Jewish incumbents were bombarded with antisemitic tweets over the summer.
HATE TRACKERS, WEEK OF SEPT. 23 – 30
ISD has developed a tracker that scrapes the web for hateful posts across social media platforms. Researchers categorize hateful users based on their ideological motivations and use keywords to examine their conversations. All of the entities are manually reviewed by ISD analysts. To read more about ISD’s methodology, click here, and to see their entire analysis for the week, click here.
Explore how hateful messages and pages changed from last week to this week.
QAnon:
Related messages decreased to 18,133 this week from 18,247 last week.
Top 5 Ascendant Communities:
+69% Far-right
+42% QAnon
+5% Anti-Hispanic
+4% Misogynist
+2% International influencers
Molly Boigon is an investigative reporter at the Forward. Contact her at [email protected] or follow her on Twitter @MollyBoigon.
A message from our Publisher & CEO Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
We’ve set a goal to raise $260,000 by December 31. That’s an ambitious goal, but one that will give us the resources we need to invest in the high quality news, opinion, analysis and cultural coverage that isn’t available anywhere else.
If you feel inspired to make an impact, now is the time to give something back. Join us as a member at your most generous level.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
