Is It Ever Appropriate To Compare Modern Crises To The Holocaust?
Graphic by Angelie Zaslavsky
By The Scribe June 19, 2018
In the United States, we’re currently facing a crisis: Trump’s latest policy move has resulted in thousands of children being separated from their families and kept in large cages. While it’s undeniable that the situation is terrible, there’s a debate in the Jewish community about whether or not it’s appropriate to compare the atrocities in any way to the Holocaust.
The Anti-Defamation League released a video in which children hidden during the Holocaust share just how terrible family separation policies are:
WATCH: Children separated from their parents during the Holocaust speak out about the trauma it has caused. How can anyone defend such inhumane policies? https://t.co/YjxQzAQ2s8 #FamiliesBelongTogether pic.twitter.com/QqavaIcZai
— ADL (@ADL_National) June 19, 2018
And Forward columnist Elad Nehorai says we have bigger things to worry about than the appropriate use of the term:
As a Jew, I find it much more offensive that some of my fellow Jews are more upset about Holocaust comparisons than about the actual atrocities happening in our country.
— Elad Nehorai (@PopChassid) June 18, 2018
But there are some who find the comparisons to the Holocaust offensive, or just a bad idea:
One of the many reasons Holocaust analogies are a bad idea is that they let the bigots turn the debate into one over whether the analogy is correct, when the policies are in fact evil *regardless* of whether they are anything like the Holocaust. https://t.co/tfh78gcnfv
— (((Yair Rosenberg))) (@Yair_Rosenberg) June 19, 2018
What do you think?
Is it ever appropriate to compare modern crises to the Holocaust?
— The Forward (@jdforward) June 19, 2018
Have more to say? Email us.
Did you know that only 2% of Forward readers donate to support our nonprofit newsroom? That 2% make it possible for millions to read the Forward without a paywall or subscription — removing any barriers to the full and fair Jewish story.
But while the Forward is free to read, it isn’t free to produce. Big stories — like deep dives into the antisemitism data, political scoops or reporting trips to college campuses — take months of research and fact-checking. All while we keep you informed of what you need to know each day.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Forward Publisher & CEO
Support our mission to tell the Jewish story fully and fairly.
