Missing Half of the Potentially Best Ideas
Karen Loew November 24, 2010
The e-mails flowed in — from Dan, Albert, David and Moshe. From Paul, Eric and Yoav. And from Benjamin, Rafael and Ethan. They all wanted a spot here, on the Forward’s opinion pages.
While it’s not a new trend for opinion editors to hear far more from the Mitchells and Jasons than from the occasional Donna or Jenna, when you’re on the receiving end of op-ed submissions, the quick emergence of a pattern of male dominance can come as a shock.
I had the pleasure of supervising the opinion pages for much of the fall, ending last week, when the opinion editor returned from a leave. From the beginning of September through mid-November, I received almost seven times as many unsolicited articles from men as from women: That’s 47 submissions from men and only seven from women. (This is the group of articles that a first glance showed were coherent and worth another read.) Over the same period, four times as many letters to the editor (using the same baseline) came from men as from women, 68 versus 18.
Because we just had a run of guest editors filling this page, I couldn’t actually accept many submissions. And many of those I received were not right for our pages. Even with those, though, I admired the writer’s nerve in sending his or her piece out into the world. You have to throw a lot of stuff at the wall for anything to stick. But why weren’t more women throwing stuff at the wall? Why weren’t women speaking out?
“That’s the $64,000 question,” said Ginna Green, an advisory board member and seminar leader for the OpEd Project, a New York-based nonprofit devoted to rectifying the gender disparity on the nation’s opinion pages. The OpEd Project runs seminars to coach women through the process of writing and submitting opinion articles — and it has established a track record of getting them published.
Still, the OpEd Project’s latest byline survey, for the week of November 12-18, shows typical results: In six of the country’s top news sources (including The New York Times, Washington Post and Wall Street Journal), op-eds by women were on average only about one-fifth of the total.
“Women cite a full range of reasons why they may not be willing to put thoughts to paper in a public realm,” Green wrote in an e-mail. But we all lose, she said, “when entire segments of society — women, people of color, young people — are unable to bring their ideas and experience to bear on society. So whether women don’t write because of fear, doubt or, quite simply, a lack of knowledge as to how op-ed pages operate, the OpEd Project aims to change that.” What actually ends up in print reflects the outreach and discretion of editors — who may or may not have worked to include female (or other minority) voices. But submissions are a measure of self-selection, a demonstration of people’s desire and motivation. And since when aren’t Jewish women, in particular, both opinionated and motivated?
Columnist Froma Harrop, for one, was surprised to hear that even at the Forward, the usual imbalance is in place. Harrop, 60, who is Jewish (and fondly remembers her grandfather reading the Yiddish Forverts), has had her self-described “wonky” column distributed by Creators Syndicate for 10 years and is vice-president of the National Conference of Editorial Writers.
“Jewish guys have opinions. They’re not shy about it,” said Harrop, who, in a 2007 survey by Media Matters for America, had the 20th-greatest reach of any American daily newspaper columnist (coming in ahead of the likes of Richard Cohen and Michelle Malkin). “Women are perhaps just less used to writing down their opinions and submitting them and thinking someone’s going to treat them respectfully or seriously. They are, in a sense, shyer.”
I agree. I’ve seen male writers assertive enough to submit both good and bad columns to the Forward, and to follow up, which can help them. If female writers are equally assertive — which is to say, equally present — I have no doubt they’ll appear on this page more often, and likely on other op-ed pages more often too.
Then again, why does it matter? Even Green from the OpEd Project acknowledges that women are “not a monolithic group” with opinions that always differ from men’s. But, she writes, “women make up more than half of the nation’s population, and what does it mean when our wisdom, value and experience — potentially, half of the nation’s best ideas — don’t even make it to the table?”
“I would never suggest that there’s always a ‘woman’s point of view’ — but I am suggesting that when the lens through which society looks to solve big problems and make big decisions is the lens of the wealthy, the privileged, the white and the male, as a nation and society we are all missing out.”
Women, it’s time to start typing. I’ll make it easy: Forward Opinion Editor Daniel Treiman awaits your submissions at [email protected]
Karen Loew is associate editor of the Forward.
A message from our CEO & publisher Rachel Fishman Feddersen
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward’s award-winning, nonprofit journalism during this critical time.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse.
Readers like you make it all possible. Support our work by becoming a Forward Member and connect with our journalism and your community.
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
