N.Y. Mayoral Candidates Mostly Support Consent Forms for Circumcision Rite

Better Outreach to the Orthodox Community Is Needed

No Strong Stand: New York mayoral candidate John Liu, right, opposes the city’s requirement of parental consent forms for metzitzah b’peh. Others, including frontrunner Christine Quinn, left, back the regulation, but say the city should do better outreach to the Orthodox community, while Bill de Blasio, center, wants to find a solution to appease both parties.
Getty Images
No Strong Stand: New York mayoral candidate John Liu, right, opposes the city’s requirement of parental consent forms for metzitzah b’peh. Others, including frontrunner Christine Quinn, left, back the regulation, but say the city should do better outreach to the Orthodox community, while Bill de Blasio, center, wants to find a solution to appease both parties.

By Seth Berkman

Published May 03, 2013, issue of May 10, 2013.
  • Print
  • Share Share

All the top Democratic candidates vying to become the next mayor of New York City are calling for greater dialogue between Orthodox groups and city officials concerning the controversial Jewish circumcision practice known as metzitzah b’peh.

But among these leading Democrats, only City Comptroller John Liu says he would outright abolish the city’s regulation of the practice.

In contrast, Joseph Lhota, currently the top Republican candidate for mayor, says he supports the regulation, which is bitterly opposed by several major ultra-Orthodox organizations.

The new regulation, which came into force this past January, requires a mohel to obtain a signed consent form from a parent before he may perform metzitzah b’peh, or MBP. The regulation seeks to ensure that parents are aware of the procedure’s health risks — in particular the greater danger that medical authorities say the baby runs of contracting neonatal herpes, which can be life threatening or cause permanent physical or cognitive damage.

In a statement provided to the Forward, Democratic front-runner Christine Quinn, the city council’s current speaker, said the use of signed consent forms to perform MBP “protects religious freedoms” and is the “right policy,” but that the city’s health department “must do a better job in the future with its outreach on sensitive issues in which public health and religious practices intersect.”

Quinn’s top challenger on the Democratic ballot, Bill de Blasio, said that while the city “has a solemn duty to protect the public health, and we will never compromise on that,” Mayor Michael Bloomberg “was wrong to simply dictate to a community on a matter of religious tradition.” De Blasio added that he would find a solution “that protects the health of newborns and allows freedom of religious practice.”

The city department of health did not respond to requests for comment. But prior to approving the consent form in September, the city held public hearings on the proposed regulation this past July and Bloomberg met with ultra-Orthodox leaders.

Still, ultra-Orthodox Jews said that they have not had enough discussion with city authorities on the health risks of MBP, a procedure in which a mohel orally sucks away the blood from an infant’s genital area after cutting away his foreskin during circumcision. Most mohels who are not ultra-Orthodox use a sterile pipette for this procedure. But many ultra-Orthodox rabbinic authorities say the Talmud forbids this.

Currently, a group of pro-MBP plaintiffs are suing the city over their right to perform MBP.

Lhota, the former chairman of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and the current favorite among GOP candidates, publicly said in early April that using the signed consent forms was “a reasonable approach” to tell parents what the risks are.

One of Lhota’s challengers, John Catsimatidis, supported the regulation more directly. A representative for the campaign of the billionaire grocery store magnate told the Forward that Catsimatidis “believes a mohel’s work should be regulated by the health department, just like a variety of other procedures are,” and that “we understand the religious implications, but there also has to be a balance with the health implications.”

Republican candidates Adolfo Carrion Jr. and George T. McDonald have not taken positions.

Recently, Liu challenged Bloomberg’s decision, telling a Forward reporter that he opposed the signed consent forms and was “not in support of the changes that Mayor Bloomberg made.”

“For thousands of years, this has been a practice that has been observed by people,” Liu said. “As with most procedures, some risk is inherent. But I would certainly defer to the rabbis on this, as opposed to thinking that, well, we know better after thousands of years of this practice.”

Other candidates have made public statements directly to Orthodox Jewish audiences, criticizing the enforcement of the MBP regulation. In a talk with an Orthodox Jewish crowd in Brooklyn that was posted online in March, Democratic candidate Bill Thompson was told that any mayoral candidate who didn’t take a stand against regulation of MBP would be a candidate for whom people wouldn’t feel comfortable voting. In response, Thompson said, “The government needs to respect the religious beliefs of people.” Thompson added that he had heard there was no discussion between members of the Orthodox Jewish community and the city, and that he would be “absolutely willing to sit down and talk” about balancing safety and religious practice.

Another Democratic candidate, Erick Salgado, a minister from Staten Island, gave a speech to the Rabbinical Alliance of America and called MBP “a practice that was commanded by God,” one that had been practiced “since God told Abraham to do so.”

According to a recent New York Times article, there could be up to 30,000 Orthodox Jewish votes available in the Democratic primary this year. Quinn leads a majority of early polls. Primaries in the overwhelmingly Democratic city will be held September 10.

Sal Albanese, a former city councilman and Democratic candidate, also advocated discussion. In a statement provided to the Forward, Albanese said: “I think we’ve got to stop making this a good guy-bad guy issue. Everyone on both sides is trying to do what they think is best for the well-being of our kids. While I have my concerns, I’m open to bringing doctors and community members to the table to revisit the current policy.”

This year there have been two reports of infants infected with herpes after circumcision. Since 2000 there have been 13 reported cases, with two of the infants dying shortly after becoming infected.

Additional reporting by Josh Nathan-Kazis

Contact Seth Berkman at Berkman@forward.com


The Jewish Daily Forward welcomes reader comments in order to promote thoughtful discussion on issues of importance to the Jewish community. In the interest of maintaining a civil forum, The Jewish Daily Forwardrequires that all commenters be appropriately respectful toward our writers, other commenters and the subjects of the articles. Vigorous debate and reasoned critique are welcome; name-calling and personal invective are not. While we generally do not seek to edit or actively moderate comments, our spam filter prevents most links and certain key words from being posted and The Jewish Daily Forward reserves the right to remove comments for any reason.





Find us on Facebook!
  • “I don’t want to say, ‘Oh oh, I’m not Jewish,’ because when you say that, you sound like someone trying to get into a 1950s country club, “and I love the idea of being Jewish." Are you a fan of Seth Meyers?
  • "If you want my advice: more Palestinians, more checkpoints, just more reality." What do you think?
  • Happy birthday Barbra Streisand! Our favorite Funny Girl turns 72 today.
  • Clueless parenting advice from the star of "Clueless."
  • Why won't the city give an answer?
  • BREAKING NEWS: Israel has officially suspended peace talks with the Palestinians.
  • Can you guess what the most boring job in the army is?
  • What the foolish rabbi of Chelm teaches us about Israel and the Palestinian unity deal:
  • Mazel tov to Idina Menzel on making Variety "Power of Women" cover! http://jd.fo/f3Mms
  • "How much should I expect him and/or ask him to participate? Is it enough to have one parent reciting the prayers and observing the holidays?" What do you think?
  • New York and Montreal have been at odds for far too long. Stop the bagel wars, sign our bagel peace treaty!
  • Really, can you blame them?
  • “How I Stopped Hating Women of the Wall and Started Talking to My Mother.” Will you see it?
  • Taglit-Birthright Israel is redefining who they consider "Jewish" after a 17% drop in registration from 2011-2013. Is the "propaganda tag" keeping young people away?
  • Happy birthday William Shakespeare! Turns out, the Bard knew quite a bit about Jews.
  • from-cache

Would you like to receive updates about new stories?




















We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.