Updated, 10:30AM: This article was published in December 2017, but has been updated to reflect the thrilling developments in Scarlett Johansson’s love life.
Like Moses taking orders from that bossy burning bush, Scarlett Johansson didn’t ask to be the leader of the Jewish people. Nevertheless, between her Germanic beauty and obvious talent, Johansson never stood a chance of escaping the “Guess what religion she’s a part of!” game beloved by smug dads and Hebrew school teachers everywhere. Platinum blond and gravel-voiced, twice Esquire’s “Sexiest Woman Alive,” prone to tone-deaf gaffes, and one time a SodaStream saleswoman — Johansson was born to lead us.
Which is why, with a sense of duty and in the wake of her engagement to Saturday Night Live writer-performer Colin Jost, we are gathered here to rank her impressive list of boyfriends, lovers and husbands. We come not to shame or to judge but to celebrate, analyze and, as always, consider what Scarlett Johansson can do with her personal life to help the Jewish people.
We now begin.
Dated: Spring 2011
Read this history of assault allegations and taped assault incidents and tell me Sean Penn shouldn’t be No. 16.
Who is Josh Hartnett? What differentiates him from a Duhamel, a Hutcherson or a “Drake and”? Pass.
Speaking of unremarkable men, who is James Holzier? He is low on this list for lack of name-recognition and looking like a criminal. Good luck finding information on this not very famous man. Our research led us to the website for the University of Guam and to a fan site that looks like it was developed by young female terrorists. He may or may not be a real person.
Evidence is thin on the ground for JarScar: Paparazzi photos mostly show them touching arms in various locations.
After Johansson separated from this unremarkable-seeming person his lawyer gave a statement saying, “Mr. Dauriac is tired of having to run his life and his child’s life based on Ms. Johansson’s shooting schedule,” inducting himself to the side of history where men complain about women having jobs.
Dated: July 2017-Current. Engaged.
Colin Jost is the most ordinary-seeming man in the world. If he was in a period drama about civil rights, he might play the boy who wrestles with blowing off the big game to join the protest. But he is just as likely to play the boy who leads the frat brothers in a hate crime. As well as those imaginary jobs, he has a real job as the host of the news show “Weekend Update” on “Saturday Night Live.” But he still makes a substandard trophy-boyfriend for ScarJo. Colin Jost is the exact kind of man with whom you enjoy a few staid dinner dates, right before you meet the real love of your life. A “pre-bound” rather than a “rebound,” one might say. Nevertheless, they have determined to wed.
Dated: 2004 (rumored)
Most of the men on this list have a naturally wilted appearance, so Jeter brings welcome physical superiority as well as — again, unlike many others on this list — discernible talent. Top 10 material.
Dated: 2009-2012 (rumored off-and-on)
If you can’t be a glamorous star, but must be, rather, an ordinary person reading this list, don’t you want to live in the world where the glamorous stars casually date each other? That is what it seems Scarlett Johansson and Bradley Cooper did at the turn of the past decade. Tabloid evidence for S.C. + B.C. includes indisputable proof that once, at a dinner at Wolfgang Puck’s, Cooper got out of his chair when Johansson got up to go to the bathroom.
This list would be nothing without Jude Law. Men like Jude Law were born to date and then be dumped by Scarlett Johansson, and we honor their service.
Dated: Fall 2011 (rumored)
Any one of us — man or beast — would be lucky to date Joseph Gordon-Levitt. JGL is the anti-dreamboat, with undefined muscles and a petulant, though endearing energy. He’s a singing feminist with a cameo in “Star Wars”, and he’s married, to a robotics expert named Tasha McCauley. Above all, he is as Jewish as the day is long. No doubt Johansson thinks of him when she looks up at the moon, and also when she looks up at the third rock from the sun.
Dated: Spring 2012
The chiseled and dangerous-looking Nate Naylor has a website that’s just pictures of butts and his email address. The civilian ad executive is a real-life Don Draper (we assume, having never watched a single episode of “Mad Men”) with a disturbingly sexual Tumblr to which we dare not provide a link. He rises in the ScarJo boyfriends countdown because he is an outrageous person without being downright evil, and he seems to have made our girl happy.
5.Benicio Del Toro
Dated: 2004 (rumored)
Did Benicio Del Toro and Scarlett Johansson have sex in an elevator at the Chateau Marmont after the 2004 Oscars? That is the question the aliens will be asking after we are all mercifully swept away in the next Great Flood. Johansson decried the rumor as “very unsanitary” when asked about it in an interview with Allure the same year. Del Toro, on the other hand, told Esquire: “Did I ever have sex in an elevator with Scarlett Johansson after an awards show? I kind of like, you know, I, well. I don’t know. Let’s leave that to somebody’s imagination. Let’s not promote it. I’m sure it has happened before. It might not be the last time either.” If you’re looking for tips on how to get into the top five list of Scarlett Johansson’s Lovers, look no further than this quote.
This union has such little evidence behind it that it seems to be fully a product of the public’s collective fantasy life. How could we not dream that these two charismatic people might find love in each others’ extremely pale arms? We cannot. Justin Timberlake is Number 4. The people have spoken with one voice.
Lena Dunham’s ex-boyfriend, former drummer in the band Fun, and current power behind the throne that is Taylor Swift, Jack Antonoff went to prom with Scarlett Johansson when they were seniors in high school. Plus, he’s Jewish. And that’s how you become No. 3 on the Scarlett Johansson’s Lovers list.
I mean this is extraordinary:
Well here. Jack Antonoff took Scarlett Johansson to the prom (first pic) lol pic.twitter.com/zxEXbFRe5n— n (@jiyonghae) March 13, 2017
Dated: 2004 (rumored)
Patrick Wilson is a nearly perfect human specimen (subcategory: white people). He played Raul in “Phantom of the Opera” (the love interest who wasn’t a mask wearing ghost.) He played the sexy rich guy who Lena Dunham hangs out with in that one really intense episode of “Girls.” He sings like an angel. He is the one that got away. Scarlett will have to go watch him in the “Aquaman” movie if she wants to see him again.
That Ryan Reynolds could have been ours, but instead is with that mumbling shiksa goddess Blake Lively, is the bitterest truth the Jewish people have had to swallow since admitting that Judaism has zero claim on Meghan Markle. Ryan Reynolds is glorious to behold and a genuinely kind-seeming human. For a little while, he was the chosen people’s chosen person’s chosen person. If he and Lively ever call it quits, or if she gets swept up in some kind of “Sisterhood Of The Traveling Pants” stars-only rapture, we hope Ryan and Scarlett will give each other another try.
Jenny Singer is a writer for the Forward. You can reach her at Singer@forward.com or on Twitter @jeanvaljenny